Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Apartheid Faces Its Worst Crisis Ever

Socialist Organiser no. 246, 3 October 1985 · scan p. 5 · Clive Bradley · about 1,373 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Despite the shootings the struggle continues Socialist Organiser no.246 er 3 1985 Page What is the significance of the talks the African National Con gress has had with representatives of South Africa's capitalist class?

The most far sighted sections of the South African bourgeoisie have long been critical of the apartheid system because it creates social tensions that could at some point explode, threatening the very existence of capitalism. That is not to say that apartheid is not in the interests of the bourgeoisie — it provides them with cheap labour and boosts their profits. But it is to say that the less ideologically blinkered capitalists can recognise the contradictions that the system creates.

The crisis in South Africa now gives a new urgency to the attempt to find a reformist" solution - that is one that can minimise potentially revolutionary violence and therefore minimise the losses to the capitalist class itself. President Botha recognises this too in his own way: he has been attempting to find some middle road that allows the introduction of reforms without seriously alienating the extremists among the white supremacists.

Problems

For Botha there are two big problems: he is himself an extremist bigot who can barely bring himself to announce even the very minimal reforms that have been announced; and there is in any case no middle road for the apartheid system - it is not possible to reform it sufficiently to syphon off the black revolt and keep it, in essentials, intact.

For the big bourgeoisie, who for the most part are outside of the Nationalist - that is the Afrikaner — establishment, it is possible to experiment with more radical tactics to achieve the same basic end. To that effect Gavin Relly of Anglo-American, the largest and most powerful of the mining houses, has proposed reform measures that would go much further than Botha is prepared to, though still fall short of ending the racist system. And further to that effect, a number of South Black workers and the struggle African bourgeois have actively pursued "talks' with repres entatives of the ANC.

From their point of view it is vital to cultivate good relations with the ANC. Sooner or later, they calculate, the apartheid regime will end and there Will be black majority rule in South Africa. According to a recent survey by the Sunday Times the majority of South African whites agree with this assessment. Many who are half-hearted white supremacists, like many American capitalists who have a stake in the apartheid system in the shape of investments, consider it wise counsel to prepare for the future by making friends with political forces likely to be important in any black majority settlement. The ANC is an obvious candidate for courtship from that point of view. In particular, therefore, it is considered to be crucial to demand the unconditional release of Nelson Mandela: make friends and influence people. There are of course some pretty major stumbling blocks for these South African bourgeois in their efforts to be nice to the ANC. First, the ANC is committed, and has been committed since the early sixties, to "armed struggle' as a strategy to bring down apartheid. Executives of Anglo-American are unlikely to welcome such a commitment. And in any case it could be politically embarrassing to be too closely identified with forces openly calling for violence - indeed the ANC is currently calling for the street violence to be taken into the white areas.

Circumstances

Dr Zac de Beer, a former opposition MP, an Executive in Anglo and a participant in last week's talks, commented: 'We obviously cannot support' the ANC's 'armed struggle' policy; but that policy is 'the product of many circumstances. Perhaps the time will come when those circumstances will change".

Even more problematic is Norkers Liberty on South N1 2SY. the ANC's apparent commitment to the nationalisation of the mining industry. In an interview with Newsweek magazine, ANC leader Oliver Tambo said: 'South Africa is basically very wealthy, but that wealth is owned by very tew people -three major companies, Barlow Rand, Anglo-American and Sanlam...The blacks have virtually nothing...The distribution of wealth is quite inequitable, and these monopolies will go"

But Tambo added: 'But below that level, there wil! be plenty of room for private enterprise"

Talks After the talks de Beer noted that both sides believe in a mixed economy. He commented that their side had tried to persuade the ANC that nationalisation is 'not a remedy" . Nevertheless, some closer political agreement than that is going to be necessary if these talks are to come to much as far as the bourgeoisie are concerned.

Meanwhile further step:

towards organising Sout/ African liberalism have been taken with the setting up of a new 'convention alliance'.

Table Founded by the leader of the main white opposition party, the Progressive Federal Party, and Zulu Chief Gatsha Buthelezi, the new alliance, which brought together over 150 puliticians, business people, lawyers and civil rights campaigners aims to bring everybody - from the ANC through to the ultra-racist Conservative Party - round the negotiating table.

It is not just a naive and futile gathering of political children. The white opposition groups are representative of the big bourgeoisie - of people like de Beers. And Buthelezi is barely describable even as a liberal. His Inkatha movement, judged by its role in attacking more radical opponents of the racist regime, 1s in tact closer to being a proto-fascist movement complete with armed thugs.

But these developments should give us cause for som hope; they indicate the extent to which the ruling class is begining to split in South Africa — and from that point of view it is worth recalling that a crucial feature of all revolutionary situations is the splitting of the ruling class.

The other feature is that the oppressed can no longer go on being ruled in the same way. And mass resistance continues, particularly among the youth Is call for the country to be made ungovernable has met with a huge response. The content of the call is questionable: Tambo, while calling for an insurrection, is also predicting that apartheid may survive another decade; but there can be no doubt that the black youth are answering the ANC's call.

Knowledge

It is the certain knowledge that they cannot beat down the oming revolution indefinitely hat is forcing South Africa's ruling class into its greatest ever crisis. One of the biggest shocks about the Mexican earthquake is that human folly made its effects even worse.

According to reports, a third of the buildings in Mexico City's north-east quarter were reduced to rubble by the earthquake. Many of those buildings may have been built hurriedly -and, more to the point, cheaply and ultra-profitably without observing quake-resistance codes in their design.

Buildings that were earthquake proof" - like the 43-story Latino-American building survived the devastation. If all the City's buildings had been built like that, the number of deaths would have been greatly reduced.

And the aftermath of the earthquake spells more problems for Mexico. The wolves of the International Monetary Fund are still baying at the door.

Debt

Mexico owes $96 billion in foreign debt — three years ago its threat to default sent money markets into crisis. And the IMF are not going to let them off the hook, or even given them much leeway, just because of a little earthquake.

The Economist magazine starkly spells out the thinking of the capitalists: *The temptation to abandon the whole IMF policy must be resisted" , they say. The IMF policy, of course, is for the Mexican poor to 'tighten their belts' to pay off the debt.

And, The Economist goes on: *the earthquake may have shattered some of the old lies. Perhaps the immediate and generous response of the United States will undermine the old... dogmatism against foreign investment."

How to get rich on disaster.

Mexico should be given massive aid without strings to help overcome the effects of the quake. The Mexican people should not be made to suffer more for the benefit of multinational bankers.

----- pull-quotes -----

Africa. 75p plus p&p from: 214 Sickert Court, London

ZULA CANTUES AGE 16

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 246

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →