Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Liverpool's Labour council has stood out against the…]

Socialist Organiser no. 246, 3 October 1985 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 4,247 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Liverpool's Labour council has stood out against the Tories longer than any other. But this week its fight seemed to be collapsing in chaos. NALGO was on strike and the NUT was planning court action, against the council's issuing of redundancy notices (as a 'legal device').

Why? Martin Thomas reports.

"The treachery of Kinnock and the whole story. Mistakes have been ma THE jackals are out for a feast. The vote last week by Liverpool city council workers against an indefinite strike will be used as a lever by every self-serving bureaucrat in the labour movement to "prove" that confrontation doesn't work.

In fact the 47 percent strike vote indicates the opposite.

If Neil Kinnock and the national union leaders had supported the strike call, there would certainly have been a majority. And with the strike under way and solid, Liverpool would have been in a very strong position to win the £25m it is demanding — a fraction of the central government grant cut from the city in recent years.

The big-business magazine The Economist, on 21 September, soberly outlined the odds:

"Suppose the Militants persist in saying no? Mr Baker's [the Tory minister's] trouble in this game of chicken is that he dare not, in the last resort, force Mr [Derek] Hatton [the council deputy leader] off the road...He can hardly afford chaos in Liverpool... Yet, except by giving way himself, he has little power to avoid it, if Mr Hatton and the council labour force - not necessarily the same thing insist"

The treachery of Kinnock and the national union leaders is not, however, the whole story. Mistakes have been made in Liverpool, too, and they need careful analysis.

The story starts in May 1983. On May 5, as in three years out of every four; one-third of Liverpool City Council's seats were up for re-election. Labour won control of the council with tremendous gains — 11 extra seats, a 40% increase in the Labour Traditionally Labour had been weaker in Liverpool than in other big cities. There was a strong Orange working class Tory vote. Since 1973 the city council had been the tawdry jewel in the Liberals' gimcrack local government crown, controlled by them with the help of the Tories.

Five thousand jobs cut in six years; high rents; not -one new council house started for three years; moves to privatisation; and cuts all round - that was the Liberals' record.

Commitee

In the fight against the Liberals the Labour Party had become stronger, more active, and more left-wing, and the council unions had developed a powerful joint shop stewards' committee.

Labour's election promises drive on housing repairs, 6,000 new council houses and 4,000 new council jobs.

There had been other leftwing Labour councils elsewhere promising similar things: Lambeth since 1978, the GLC since 1981. a clutch of left-wing London bc nugh councils since 1982. On the whole they had done a bit better than their Tory or right-wing Labour predecessors; but it was mostly a matter of responding to central government grant cuts by rate rises instead of cuts in jobs and services.

The left-wing councils were more benevolent administrators, but still administrators within the existing system. As administrators they frequently clashed with their workers. Their promises of struggle against the government got no further than thetoric, Liverpool, however, was partly different. The new council Labour group, unlike any other, was pledged not to raise rates to compensate for central government cuts.

Other left-wing Labour coun cils were alliances of individuals of different. shades, held together more by the arts of committee-room politics than by a definite strategy. In Liverpool the Militant tendency commanded a leading role in the Labour group; a majority in the District Labour Party; and a strong presence in the council A unified strategy by the whole Liverpool labour movement was thus possible. And Militant's national network should have made it easier to wIn national support for a struggle in Liverpool.

The new Labour council started well, building new houses, creating new jobs, going well over the budget prepared by the Liberals for 1983-4. By October the Tory government was already warning the council about 'overspending'. The council responded with a vigorous campaign among council workers and the local community. 20,000 people joined a march on 19 November.

By February 1984 Derek Hatton was explaining to Militant that "the crunch" would come "probably at the end of March"

"We will refuse to balance the books and this can be challenged in the courts by any creditor or ratepayer…..The courts could then appoint receivers who could take over the financial control of the city council..

A campaign committee mapped out plans to include a possible all-out strike from March 29.

But Labour's majority in the council chamber was only three - and a number of Labour right wingers declared that they would never vote for an unbalanced budget.

On budget day, March 29 — despite a one-day strike by council workers, and a huge, enthusiastic demonstration at the Town Hall - there was no majority on the council for Labour's unbalanced budget or the Liberals' alternative cuts budget.

The campaign continued right through to the council elections on May 3. Labour gained another seven seats, securing a solid majority for its unbalanced budget.

A survey by the University of Liverpool showed that 80% of council workers living in contested wards had voted, 75% of them for Labour. It also showed that they were ready to 'go over the too' with a local general strike and a rent and rates strike. According to a poll pub lished in June, 55% of Labour voters would back a general strike if the Tories sent in commissioners.

Meanwhile the miners' strike was at its peak. Nearly half the Notts miners were out, and the strike was 100% in all other major areas. On May 7 Arthur Scargill appealed for solidarity: "If ever there was a time to join with this union, to come out on strike...now is the time"

But things started going wrong. Instead of stepping up their campaign, pushing through the unbalanced budget and going fast and hard for confrontation, the Liverpool council leaders dawdled. The campaign dwindled. The unbalanced budget was not put to the council again. Instead, the council leaders went off to talk to Tory minister Patrick Jenkin.Conference On June 23 some 2000 delegates attended a labour movement conference in support of the council. But there were no specific plans for action: Th Militant itself reported, mood of the conference was... more akin to a rally". Socialist Organiser put it less blandly: "Workshops planned for the afternoon were called off in favour of an orgy of self-congratulation about the 'strength of the Marxists'. For many delegates this was an annoying missed opportunity".

What was going on? Militant continued to talk about "struggle" "campaign" "mobilisation", even "unavoidable confrontation". But their policy on rate rises had been subtly changed from "no rate rises to compensate for government cuts" , to "no massive rate rises to compensate"

Early in July the council leaders announced a deal with the government. The Tories would give them a little extra money - much less than they were demanding - and permit various financial tricks to shift the problem into the next year. Liverpool could then get through with a 17% rate rise.

This, said Militant, was a "95 per cent" victory. Socialist Organiser commented: (According to Labour leaders in Liverpool, about 45% of the problem has been shifted to next year. In other words, the real confrontation has just been put off...

"If Liverpool is to take on the Tories, then the time to do it is when the working class is involved in the biggest class war in a decade. "Next year' there may well not be a miners' strike or a docks strike.."

In Liverpool, however, there was strong support for the deal. The prospect of immediate confrontation had been fading, and clearly the Tories had conceded something, if not 95%. No council had ever before won concessions by standing up to the government.

The deal had a big impact on other Labour councils. Seeing the talks with the Tory minister and the failure to set a rate and ignoring the campaign before May and the miners" strike - councillors thought they had hit on a way to defy the Tories and win concessions without going over the brink into illegality and direct action.

They argued that Labour councils — in particular, those facing the Tories' new rate-cap regulations — should refuse to set a rate at the normal budget time in April 1985.

And as budget time approached, in early 1985, the miners, against all odds, were still on strike. Liverpool would have a second chance to come to the crunch with the Tories under favourable circumstances.

On February 1, Militant reported: "With Liverpool's crisis worse this year, shop stewards back united -CalLI paign". - Liverpool Labour believed that an unbalanced budget was best, but for the sake of unity would initially not set a rate. And then?

"Liverpool proved last year that a mobilised working class with a Marxist leadership at its head took on the Tories and won a major victory". Militant gave no more specific indication of what sort of mobilisation would be needed. It did not suggest that it would be more than the demonstrations and rallies that sufficed in 1984. And it gave no hint of any urgency about bring ing the struggle forward so as to give aid to the hard-pressed miners and ensure the Tories were attacked on two fronts.

On March 2, just five days before Labour councils were due to vote in defiance of the government, the miners met at a recall conference. Unsure of the council's determination, they decided to return to work.

Sadly, the miners' doubts were well-founded. The GLC and ILEA immediately broke the 'no rate' front, by setting lega rates. Ten Labour councils did refuse to set a rate. But by early June every one of them had backed down except Liverpool and Lambeth.

Liverpool was not central until June. In contrast to other councils, Hackney in particular, it faced no legal threats, and indeed Militant said (14 June that because of the 1984 delay in setting a rate Liverpool "councillors remain technically in a 'legal' position"

But by June. once again, Liverpool council faced a shar] choice. Confrontation or not?

Councillors proposed a 20% rate rise which with some financial juggling would allow Liverpool to scrape through the year. The unions said no. Sc Liverpool set an unbalanced budget - 9% rate rise, £265 million expenditure, £148 million income — on 14 June. It demanded from the government the return of £29 million grant and £88 million penalties.

So far, SO good. Maybe chances had been missed, but now, as 'Militant' put it (21 June), "After two years of shadow-boxing...the gloves are off"' Instead of general calls for a "mass campaign", Militant said boldly: "Strike to defend councils".

Despite everything, Liverpool was still potentially in a strong position. In 1972-4, a single tiny Labour council, Clay Cross, defied the Housing Finance Act, a Tory law to increase rents. The councillors were surcharged and disqualified. But the Tories never managed to collect the rent arrears. The Housing Finance Act was repealed by the Labour minority government in 1974, and the Tories have never tried to reintroduce it.

Liverpool could beat the government. It needed only two things: determination and unity, what the_rate-capped councils had lacked.

They had talked of mobilisation, struggle, detiance, controntation. But the councillors would only go "right up to" the brink, as Islington's Margaret Hodge put it, not over it.

They called for their workforces and local working class communities to unite with them. But it was a unity in which the workers were a stage army, manipulated and manoeuvred according to the tempo of concil chamber tactics.

Local

Most of the rate-capped councils had; in their capacity as managers of the local state, conducted bitter disputes with sections of their workforces in the run-up to their defiance of the government. The workers still supported the councils when they showed some signs of fighting the Tories. But quickly they found that they were being manipulated again.

In July 1984, for example, Islington council declared, we were to give in to rate-capping, we would have to sack 750 of our staff" . In March 1985, the council refused to set a rate, and called on workers to back it in a fight to the end with central government. Two and a half months later the council leaders announced that they had after all found financial tricks that would enable them to comply with rate-capping while making no cuts; they thanked the workers for their support and told them to go home.

Other councils did similar Grand Old Duke of York acts.

One lesson was clear: a council seriously taking on the government would need to be absolutely open and honest about its finances. Otherwise right-wingers would always be able to paralyse the struggle at the crucial point by producing this or that "new" financial trick to allow for some sort of muddling through.

Liverpool and Militant had shown more determination than councils like Islington. Would they now show enough determination and skill to win?

Unfortunately they didn't. Like the other left councils, though in a different way, they had drawn the wrong lessons from 1984. In truth, the concessions that Liverpool won from the Tories were a by-product of the miners' strike and the willingness of a broad spectrum of the Liverpool working class to take direct action. Councils like Islington saw it as a victory for council chamber mock-heroics; John Hamilton (left) and Derek Ha march. Photo: John Smith, IFL.

the Militant in Liverpool, apparently, saw the crucial factor as their "Marxist leadership"

Militant has always had a mechanistic view of the world according to which increasing economic crisis will steadily and automatically bring triumphs and new recruits to "the Marxists". There is no need to adjust and develop this "Marxism" in line with living reality: everything has been foreseen and provided for in Militant's "perspectives", and new events do nothing but confirm them. Less complacent Marxists are flibbertigibbet irrelevances - "the sects"

Arrogance

The inbuilt arrogance of this view was given a boost by Militant's puffed-up self-satisfaction after July 1984. They felt themselves all-powerful. In October of that year they launched themselves into an utterly destructive and divisive conflict.

Sampson Bond, a Militant supporter, was appointed as council race relations officer against the strong opposition of the Black Caucus, a committee of black groups set up to liaise with the council under the Liberal administration.

The Black Caucus said that

Scan page 7

Bond had got the job only because he supported Militant policies — policies that opposed any positive discrimination and resolutely insisted that the problems of the black working class were no different from those of the white working class. Militant replied that the Black Caucus just wanted the job for their own Caucus But the Black Caucus had after all been recognised by the Labour council as more or less representative of Liverpool blacks. Liverpool City Council NALGO boycotted Bond. The Trades Council, the council joint shop stewards committee, the regional TGWU, and most black groups, called for the appointment to be reconsidered. Militant climb down? Never!

The "Marxist leadership" tried to bulldoze all the objectors. A year later, the issue is still inflamed. The Black Caucus has moved from objections to Militant towards hostility to the whole labour movement. Militant, outraged that the Caucus will not recognise the enthroned nod gas isters gang of pimps *Marxist leadership* and has called the police against black demon1984 strators. The council joint shop stewards committee has been seriously strained and disrupted by the affair.

Despite all that, in June the joint shop stewards' committee voted unanimously to support the unbalanced budget.

On July 26 Militant explained that this budget would mean the council running out of money around late August or early September - unless the courts stepped in first.

Yet the council's campaign remained low-key compared to 1984. Instead of becoming bolder and sharper as the crunch came nearer, the coverage in Militant became vaguer and softer. The urgent calls for strike action were replaced by appeals for general "support" in a longterm campaign. In late July, without explanation, the council budget was reduced from £265 million to £255 million, and the date at which the council would run out of money was put back to "late November"

Emphasis

What was happening? What were the council's plans? Workers in Liverpool and elsewhere weren't sure.

More and more emphasis in campaigning was put on the surcharges threatened against the councillors for not setting a rate until 14 June, rather than the prospect of the council running out of money. Yet those surcharges were a secondary issue.

The councillors (as Militant had indicated in its issue of 14 June) had a strong legal position on this point. And long before the legal processes were completed on that surcharge, the council was due to run into a position with its finances exhausted, the workers on strike, and the councillors in open and flagrant illegality!

Militant of 13 September summed up the confusion. Page 1 and most of page 3 were given over to the surcharges and a one-day protest strike against them on September 25. Two short and inconspicuous articles announced that the council would start running out of money at the end of September and that it planned to issue 90 days' redundancy notice to all employees!

On 16 September a council meeting was called to decide on the redundancy notices. Workers blockaded the Town Hall to stop it taking place. Council leaders joined the demonstration.

Why did they ever propose the divisive redundancy notices? "Purely a legal device, explained Militant. By discarding the need to budget for wages after December, the council could restore its credit and keep going longer. And not issuing the redundancy notices could make councillors liable to huge surcharges.

Council workers could see no sense in starting a fight for jobs by issuing redundancy notices so that any strike had to demand not only more money from central government but also reinstatement. And why this concern for petty legal devices? Was this confrontation with the government or wasn't it?

The redundancy notices policy was the exact opposite of what was needed to galvanise the Liverpool labour movement for a fight. Inevitably it was divisive, diversionary, confusionist. Inevitably it split the workers section from section and shop stewards from the rank and file.

Tamely

The 31,000 were asked to tamely accept dole cards and trust the council's promise to take them back on April I. The workers _ no more than a stage army in Militant's scenario were being put out to grass for three months. Instead of the councillors standing on the line and giving a self-sacrificing lead in the fight for the city they offered up the workers instead, demanding that the 31,000 passively give up their jobs at the say so of people who were unwilling to put their own heads on the block. This wasn't Marxism _ and it wasn't leadership either.

Within a few days the front had apparently been straightened out by Derek Hatton promising not to issue redundancy nonces, and the stewards calling an all-out strike from September 25.

But immense damage had been done. The council should have explained clearly and in advance how and when it would run out of money: continued spending up to the last possible moment, thus forcing the banks and/or the senior council officials to take the responsibility for stopping wage payments; demonstratively stopped debt payments to the banks before wage payments; and brought the campaign to a climax by mobilising councillors and workers together to picket or occupy the offices of the officials or bankers refusing to pay wages.

That way everyone could have seen that the councillors were prepared to put themselves in the front line _ that they were undertaking a real struggle against the government, not just a manoeuvre or a gesture.

As it was, many workers thought that the redundancy notices were a ploy to save the council three months wages and get it through the year. Or was the strike call a version of the same thing? "I won't strike to bail out Derek Hatton", said some workers. They were wrong but their confusion was not surprising in the circumstances.

In early September the city treasurer had come up with a scheme to get through the financial year by taking money from next year's housing repairs budget. This plan was now taken up by right-wingers and the Communist Party.

The media and the national Labour and trade union leaders also played their part in shaping the 53%-47% ballot result against strike action. But they had been hostile all along. It was the council's blundering tactics that gave them their opening.

And since the vote there has been worse. Militant declared that the vote was only a minor setback: its lead article ио 27 September pure banding f And on that same day, 27 September, redundancy notices started going out _ those same redundancy notices that had provoked a workers demonstration to stop the council meeting on 16 September.

In the aftermath of the ballot defeat, the GMBU [in which Militant is strong] was swung to supporting redundancy notices. Militant explained: "This is purely a legal device to enable the council to keep paying wages until 18 December...This device will give the councillors and the union (?) valuable time to extend the campaign of explanations " - especially to the mem bers of NALGO and the NUT, who had been against the strike.

For regaining lost ground inside NALGO the council's tactics could hardly be worse. NALGO is strongly against the redundancy notices; the council is like a general who prepares his shaky regiments for battle by trampling them underfoot in the course of his retreat! And insulting them, too: both the NALGO members in general [penpushers, not 'real workers] and their leaders [traitors ] have been freely denounced and blamed for the ballot defeat.

In fact the NALGO branch leaders argued for a strike. Not as vigorously as was necessary, to be sure: wrongly but understandably, they were jaded and unenthusiastic after a year of being bounced about by Militant and trying to puzzle out what the council was really up to.

But the NALGO branch officers are not, and do not claim to be, "the Marxist leadership". They are trade unionists doing a trade union job as best they can. The job of "the Marxist leadership " is to win the confidence of trade unionists, not to lay down the line and denounce the trade unionists when they fail to live up to Militant's "perspectives"* "Success of our campaign.

By Monday 30 September 3,000 NALGO members were on one-day strike and marching through Liverpool's streets against the redundancy notices. Teachers picketed the building where bundles of redundancy notices were due to be issued to head teachers, and the council sent them out by taxi instead. At Least one college principal has been suspended for refusing to issue redundancy notices.

Local NUT leaders, with the support of their members, are taking the council to court to stop the redundancy notices. A council committed to saving jobs will be in the ridiculous position of defending in court its "right" to issue redundancy notices and probably losing the case.

The Tories could have cut the process short at any point _ by getting someone to bring a court case to declare the unbalanced budget illegal, by telling the banks that Liverpool's credit was not good, or simply by stopping central government grant payments. They chose to wait and see _ and now they can sit tight and watch the Liverpool labour movement wound and perhaps tear itself apart.

'NALGO and the NUT have gone for the City Treasurer's option of "capitalisation" ', also favoured by the Liberals and the Tories. This means "borrowing" money from next years housing repairs.

Device

As a device for retreat it is a lesser evil than the redundancy notices. In principle it could win time for a fight next April to ensure that enough money was won from central government to return the money to housing repairs and maintain other servIces.

In practice it wouldn't. Par ticularly because of NALGO's and the NUT's opposition to the strike from 25 September. GMBU and TGWU see "capitalisation" as a scheme to keep NALGO jobs safe while putting matian jobs at risk. "Capizatwould be scarcely less divisive than the redundancy notices.

Any orderly retreat requires a fairly high level of trust in the people carrying out the retreatAnd, as a result of Militant's blunders over the last 18 months and especially the last three months, that doesn't exist in The first thing necessary to mend the situation is that the council should withdraw the redundancy notices.

According to Militant of 27 September, without the notices *The City Treasurer has said that he would refuse to sign cheques for fear of being liable for fraud. "

Then let change the cheques and

----- pull-quotes -----

included no privatisation; a £2 rent cut; no spending cuts; a

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 246

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →