Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Hatton meets the press

Socialist Organiser no. 246, 3 October 1985 · scan p. 8 · about 870 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

has a tremendous fund of goodwill won by its solid work, like the building of 4,000 new houses, and the basic arguments about Tory responsibility for local government cuts and the need for a fight have got through to many thousands of workers.

The full reasons for every thing Liverpool council has done over recent months are not clear. The record suggests divided or unsure counsels. It is not clear exactly what the council leaders have in mind now. Not even they can believe that Marxist leadership i can win support from people by means of issuing redundancy notices to them against their will and denouncing them.

A general pattern does however emerge from the council leaders' and Militant's policy since May 1983.

According to Militant's addled version of Marxism, iron laws of history drive the working class ever onward towards Marxist politics. The job of the organised Marxists [i.e. Militant] in the meantime is to make general propaganda and to build their own following.

Victory is inevitable in the long term: so why take risks now? If the situation is favourable now, it will certainly be more favourable in the future. And it makes no sense to risk positions, prestige, and propaganda platforms for the sake of ephemeral struggle.

So Militant have tried to mainrain a delicate balance: on the one hand giving Liverpool a profile as a fighting socialist council; on the other trying to make sure they keep the council in office and themselves in the leadership of the council.

At the crunch they may fight. But, contrary to all intelligent tactics. they have tried again and again to postpone the crunch and to extend the time in which the council stands in opposition to the government but not quite in collision with it.

On 22 September, with the Liverpool council workers" vote against indefinite strike, that approach led to a serious defeat The consequences of that defea concern not only Militant but also the whole of the labour movement and especially the left.

There is a serious risk now of long-term division and dislocation in the Liverpool labour movement, and of the door being opened for witch-hunts against Militant and other leftIstS.

The left must do battle against the jackals and witch-hunters, and at the same time fight for a change of line by the Liverpool uncil and Labour Party: **GODZILLA meets the monsters"? "Jesus Christ meets Pontius Pilate and his legionnaires"? "Derek Hatton meets the press"?

Well, Hatton did Face the Press' last Sunday, 29th, on Channel 4.

Face the Press' is a serious programme in which a panel of journalists grill the week's guest. I saw Militant's Peter Taaffe get a very rough ride on the same programme a couple of years ago.

After a week in which things seemed to fall apart in Liverpool, when the council's call for an all-out strike had been rejected by a decisive section of the workforce and the council had then decided to give 31,000 workers redundancy notices, Hatton might have had some difficulty in keeping up a front against the probings and proddings of hostile hacks. other than supporters of Militant? Redundancy notices are the council's policy, chosen instead of alternative policies. Instead, for example, of a policy of the councillors going illegal, standing out the government, going to jail, and thus showing a real lead to the workers of Surely the point in dispute between the serious left and the rate-raisers like Knight, Livingstone, and Blunkett was precisely this. The council is not just a passive agent of the government. At any rate it shouldn't be.

The True Freedom by P.B.

Shelley, from The Masque of Anarchy, written in memory of the "Peterloo Massacre" in Manchester, on August 16 1819.

Men or England, heirs of Glory, Heroes of unwritten story Nurslings of one mighty Mother, Hopes of her, and one Rise, like Lions after slumber In unvanquishable number, Shake your chains to earth like dew Which in sleep have fallen on Ye are many - they are few What is Freedom? - ye can tell That which slavery is, too wellFor its very name has grown To an echo of your own.

Still. Hatton put quite well, addressi but basically fri Gillian Reynolds as Jilly, and "The man from the Robin Oakley.

Soft In fact the journalists gave him a soft ride. A representative of the serious left press — or of the Liverpool council workers - on the panel would have given dapper Derek a far rougher ride, I felt.

What art thou, could slaves Answer from their living graves This demand - tyrants woul flee Like a dream's dim imagery.

Thou art not, as impostors A shadow soon to pass away A superstition, and a name Echoing from the cave of Fame.

For the labourer thou art bread, And a comely table spread From his daily labour come In a neat and happy home. Thou art clothes, and fire, and food For the trampled multitude No - in countries that are free Such starvation cannot be As in England now we see. himself over ng the sharp endly chair familiarly snarling at Daily Mail"

----- pull-quotes -----

Songs of liberty and rebellion

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 246

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →