Women and reproductive technology A WOMAN'S RIGHT TO CHOOSE The women in Britain's prisons
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
What policy should socialists have on re rights? Michele Carlisle opens a debate. tions from our readers are welcome.
Many 'peace women' have found themselves in prison Socialist Organiser no.246 October 3 1985 Page 10
In 1979, when John Corrie attempted to revise the 1967 Abortion Act, the issue for
the labour, trade union and women's movements was clear cut. These forces united to defend the 1967 Act, which allows abortion on specific conditions, and the Corrie Bill was defeated.
Today, with technology even further advanced and the economy sinking further into crisis, the issues are more complex. The recent threats to women's reproductive rights have raised controversial questions which the Labour Party must address if we are successfully to counter these The debate surrounding experimentation on embryos was raised by Enoch Powell in his Unborn Children (Protection) Bill, and the poor response from the Labour Party highlights the need to discuss the issue fully. The Bill attempted to ban all embryo research, thus jeopardising research into genetic disorders and restricting the likelihood of successful in vitro (test tube) fertilisation (IVF) treatment.
Furthermore, because the Bill gave the embryo a legal status, the proposals had grave implications for abortion.
The Warnock Report, on which the government will base its own legislation, allowed research on embryos up to 14 days old and its position on IVF was less restrictive. However, while the intention of the committee may not have been to endanger abortion rights, that will undoubtedly be the effect.
Embryos will be protected from research at 14 days and foetuses from abortion at 24 On | August 17 Freedom Camp' was set up outside the gates of Styal Prison in Cheshire. Women from all parts of the country went to show their support for those locked inside.
Their action also drew attention to the increasing number of women stuck in prisons for what can most accurately be described as 'crimes of poverty"
Women locked. up for such crimes are swelling the numbers in the already overcrowded women's prisons. The treatment they receive at the hands of the authorities serves to degrade and demoralise them. The camp at Styal was an attempt to show these prisoners of poverty that they are not forgotten.
Response Af first the police responded with their usual viciousness when the women from the camp went, at night, to sing to those inside.
Gradually, though, it dawned on our boys in blue that exchanging songs was not part of a desperate attempt at a breakout.
Settling down to "normal" police harassment the women I spoke to said they would stay as productive Contribuweeks. Anti-abortion groups would not allow such a contradiction in the law to go unexploited.
With only 40 Labour MPs voting against the Powell Bill at its second reading, it is vital that by the time the next Bill on embryo research comes along, the Labour Party has a clear policy to which its MPs are committed.
The basic principle is that women must have control over their own fertility. Research which will uncover some of the mysteries surrounding infertility must be supported. Similarly, the procedure for IVF must be made available to all women, regardless of marital status, sexual orientation, race or financial means.
At the same time, adoption should be more accessible and less bureaucratic. We must challenge the ideology which tells women that they should have children, while supporting the right of women to control their own fertility.
Research which can reduce genetic disorder should also be supported. This is part of our attempt to improve the quality of everyone's life, without devaluing the lives led by disabled people. We are not in favour of genetic engineering in order to create a "superperson' , but if disabilities and deaths can be avoided through embryo research, then they should be.
Obviously, improvements in the NHS and diet and living conditions would also reduce the number of disabilities. Unlike many doctors seeking personal acclaim, we Goodland long as the women inside wanted them to (or until they got evicted by the council).
The camp was set up by some "Peace Women" (their label not mine) from Nottingham. In their own words, "over the past few years many peace women have been imprisoned for short (and recently longer) periods of time. These women have been horrified by the conditions and treatment which all women in prison are subjected to." The experiences these women have had has led to an important broadening of the "alternative" middle class women's movement. Just like the shared experience of police brutality encouraged links between the miners support groups and Greenham women, so the shared prison experience has brought greater mutual understanding to women previously separated by social background.
Conditions in Styal are no worse than in other prisons but that isn't saying much. All categories of prisoners are kept together. Women detained under youth custody provisions are not interested in science for science sake, but in what scientific advances mean for ordinary people. Embryo research is not an alternative to the political and social change which is necessary if women are to exercise real control over their bodies.
We should also oppose a 14 day limit on embryo experimentation.
Obviously there is a need for a licensing body to regulate research, with lay representatives from feminist and women's health groups, but to award a legal are locked in with veterans. Public indignation was whipped up by sensationalised stories of bullying. Obviously the fuss died down and as the women inside felt deserted, it was decided to set up the camp.
Rules
Like all prisons, petty rules serve to demoralise the prisoners. Some rules have tragic consequences. As soon as you go into prison any medication prescribed by your own GP is stopped. You get what they give you when they give it to you.
This had tragic consequences in January at Puckle Church remand . centre when Sarah Hewer died from lack of medical care. She was awaiting trial on a 60p shoplifting charge.
The fact that the chief medical officer in Styal is a vet says it all.
Added to the grim conditions of Britian's prisons, many women have to undergo the added torture of having their families broken up, their children put into care, etc. The effect this has on women is impossible to calculate. As the banner outside the camp proclaimed: Locking women up is no solution. status to a 14 day old embryo would only endanger the abortion law and thus restrict women's rights. In a society in which the state exercises control over women's fertility, rights are only ever given to an embryo/foetus at the expense of women.
Another issue which the Labour Party must be clear upon is that of time limits on abortion. The 1967 Abortion Act does not specify an upper time limit for abortion, but relies on the 1929 Infant Life Preservation Act to distinguish between abortion and infanticide. The 1929 Act makes it an offence to kill a child 'capable of being born alive' and pinpoints 28 weeks as the time when a foetus becomes viable. This year, a report supported by groups such as the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists and the BMA recommended that a foetus should be considered viable at 24 weeks because of advances in technology.
Kenneth Clarke, the then Minister of Health, informed the two private clinics which performed late abortions that their licences would be withdrawn if they did not comply with a 24 week limit. They have complied.
The few doctors who perform late abortions on the NHS must make a personal choice as to whether they are prepared to risk prosecution and continue the practice.
In reality the 28 week time limit meant 24 weeks, because the difficulty in estimating the date of conception made doctors cautious. Most women who need late abortions do so because they have been told that the foetus is abnormal, or they were slow in being diagnosed as pregnant or being referred to a clinic.
NHS bureaucracy is to blame for many late abortions. A time limit on abortion does not protect the foetus - a woman who is desperate for an abortion will always be able to get one (even if it is self-inflicted, at great risk to her own health). A limit criminalises women and doctors who take part in late abortions.
We must argue for the abortion service to be better funded and streamlined so that referral is quick, and for effective and safe contraception to be available to all women, including the undersixteens.
We must also fight to change the society that forces women to have abortions because of lack of money, or inability to cope with a child, or possibly a handicapped child. We must oppose any move which makes criminals of those affected by these conditions.
The Labour Party needs a firm commitment to defending women's reproductive rights.
Scan page 11
Brixton