[(speaking at the Labour Left Coordination conference fringe…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
(speaking at the Labour Left Coordination conference fringe meeting)
Eric Heffer walks out on Kinnock. Photo: Stefano Carnoni. Revort. ne lett is disorganised Tread this morning a document called the 'Labour Activist" , and it said that the left is now stronger in the Labour Party than it has ever been.
There were two questions in my mind when I read that. Who are the left? And how on earth can anybody who is serious make that kind of statement after this week?
When Neil first became a Member of Parliament, he joined the Tribune Group. I used to look at these younger Members and I felt positively moderate in comparison with the things they were saying. I remember Eric Varley being like that.
The same with Neil. I remember a meeting with the Right to Work youngsters in the House of Commons. I and Neil and some other MPs came to meet them, and they were demanding a general strike.
I said we shouldn't demand things that were not practical, and I didn't think a general strike was really the slogan at the moment. And Neil outflanked me.
I began to wonder — was 1, under the aristocratic embrace of the House of Commons, moving to the right? I've been called a dinosaur by a few papers this week, but I've remained theoretically and practically in the movement precisely where I always stood — never a raging revolutionaryalthoughlthinklam a revolutionary in the best sense of the word, but never somebody who's given way on basic principles.
But this week I've seen a whole group of people who have moved to the right but who still call themselves on the left.
We have to define what we mean by the left.
I don't mind being called the hard left, I just think we're better calling ourselves the genuine left, those in the Party who genuinely, passionately believe that socialism can only be achieved on the basis of the struggle of working people to ge rid of the capitalist system. To me Clause IV is the essence of our Party's view.
Now I read all about this stuff that we can transform society by getting better television and all that sort of thing, and that we can get in this bank and that bank — when it comes down to it we can only transform society when we own the means of production, distribution and exchange, when we have forms of democratic control, workers management, and when we take control of the economy.
The truth is that the state, our state, is a capitalist state, designed to defend private property and the capitalist system. And the police is the police force of the capitalist society. The police operate as part of the state apparatus in defence of capitaliem All that is being set aside, on the basis of the argument of practical politics. But if we had started out on that basis, nobody would have been convinced they could do anything, and we would never have had a Labour Party or a socialist movement.
I've heard the argument that we ought to put up somebody to fight the deputy leadership. I'm not ruling it out, but I'm not sure that's the way forward at themoment.
I think we should be working out the sort of socialist policies we want and then going out in the Party and fighting for them. Not getting into a hassle about leadership at this stage.
We've got two years until the next general election and I do want a Labour government. I do even want a lousy Labour government. That's better than a Tory government screwing us into the ground. I get annoyed when I hear some people say
Coordination
that the people on the left don't want another Labour government. It's a lie. I do not know any people on the left who do not want a Labour government.
But we must agree with Arthur Scargill when he says that power without principle is impossible to us socialists. We want our principles to be carried out.
Think
Do you remember the old comrade last year who got the merit award? He said that when the Press praise our leaders, then they'd better think seriously about where they are going. That's what I say to Neil.
When all the press can say now marvellous it was, and the Mail can have an editorial praising the Labour leader it shows what Michael Foot said in the second volume of the Nye Bevan book - some people think a ed them down again.
is diso NUM resolution It was soon clear that with very little support in the composite meeting and the refusal of the NUM to support us, I reluctantly withdrew our composite in favour of the NUM resolution Then conference erupted on Tuesday afternoon during Kinnock's speech.
Eric Heffer immediately left the platform in disgust and many CLP delegates were outraged and began booing and leaving their seats.
Afterwards it was clear that many CLP delegates just had not grasped what Kinnock had done. The conference was buzzing Despite all the good resolutions being carried during the rest of the week, the strong impre sion hạd of
conference fringe
good Labour leader is someone who stands up and fights his own members.
Of course comrades make mistakes in struggle. Of course the NUM leaders made mistakes. I thought so at the time but I didn't say anything about it because workers were in struggle.
I'm an old-fashioned socialist and I take the view that when working people are in struggle I don't do anything that will hurt them and work against them in that struggle. It's the same with my comrades in Liverpool. I wouldn't say they're exactly right on every issue but they're in struggle. They need assistance by the movement. The entire movement needs to rally to help those comrades. That's why I walked off the platform because they're good, honest working class people in struggle.
You don't attack your own rgani conference was that Neil people, whatever you might -think, and you certainly don't attack them in the way they were 50 that it plays right into the hands of the class enemy.
We have to sit down and talk among ourselves and work out some clear ideas in relation to policies, we need to go out and campaign for those policies, and we have to have co-ordinyou organise. It's an old lesson.
It was a failure of one of the greatest socialist leaders that ever ever lived, Eugene Debs. He was a great leader, a marvellous man, nobody could fault him in any way except he didn't bother too much what was going on in the party machine.
We've got to talk, we've got to organise, we've got to work out what sort of policies we should organise on. gate Stockport CLP Militant believe the whole week is a victory for them...(Beam me up, Scotty).
As a delegate on the conference floor, perhaps the most depressing thing about last week was the way the whole event was stage-managed.
Many good militants joined the Party during the miners' strike. But many active members have become confused and demoralised since the defeat of decided *To reimburse the NUM for fines incurred during the strike, and called for a review of cases of sacked miners. *Not to recognise Black Sections. *To support campaigns of 'non-compliance' in local authorities. *To oppose nuclear power. *To campaign for lesbian and *To call for serious action to end Third World famine. *To oppose the withdrawal of troops from Ireland. *To commit Labour MPs to defending reproductive rights, and for a Charter for Women's Health.
----- pull-quotes -----
ACK BEC BON
ation among the various group- i You don't get anything unless