Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[YOUNG BLACK men and women in South Africa…]

Socialist Organiser no. 247, 10 October 1985 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,012 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

YOUNG BLACK men and women in South Africa have entered a new stage of struggle.

For over a year now black students have conducted a very effective boycott of schools in defiance of the 'Bantu education' which is meant to prepare blacks for a life of unskilled inferiority.

They have taken on the armed forces of the state, showing a relentless courage - stones against canisters. They have suffered terrible casualties in terms of police killings, assaults, detentions and torture.

Boycott

They have taken a leading role in organising communi ty politics, including the consum er boycott of white shops in protest against the Emergency, the killings and the detentions.

They have been the major force within the multi-racial United Democratic Front and within the black consciousness front around AZAPO and the National Forum. They have born the brunt of the state's attacks, notably in the case of the banning of COSAS, the UDF school student body, and the harassment of its leaders.

The high profile and energetic politics pursued by the students raises the question of the role of students in the larger liberation movement, and in particular of the relation between students and workers.

What kind of politics and organisation are the students pursuing?

How integrated are they with the struggles of black workers?

The first thing to say is that black students do not of course form a homogeneous mass. Some have oriented to black consciousness, scornful of the liberalism and white influence they see in the UDF student politics.

Some - have oriented to the politics of the ANC, especially through COSAS and SASO, the UDF college student organisation.

Within the colleges and universities there is hot debate between the student bodies affiliated to the UDF _ NUSAS for whites and SASO for blacks - and those affiliated to black consciousness, especially AZASM, Other students, both black and white, have played a key part in the development of the independent trade unions.

General

Beneath this diversity there are nevertheless some general characteristics of student politics in South Africa.

As in other societies, there is often considerable tension between students and workers. While unions emphasise structured grass-roots organisation and strict accountability of leadership to a welldefined constituency, student groups emphasis mobilisation and activism, spontaneity, leadership by example.

From the unions' point of view, students often appear to be rushing them into action for which they are not prepared. From Sowero. 1976. South African vouth tal student point of view unions often appear slow and reluctant to take up political challenges, confined within the realms of economistic piecemeal reform in the workplace.

Trade unions have often found the methods used by students insufficiently rooted in their constituency, too reliant on spontaneity, too coercive in individualistic ways, too formalistic in their claims to represent the community.

The burning of black councillors and their homes, the killing of black policemen, the setting up of People's Courts dealing out rough justice against collaborators and boycott-breakers - and the loose notion of 'collaboration'" which threatens to spill over and brand trade union organisers themselves as 'collaborators" riots in the townships against the South African Defence Force and the police - these methods often appear dangerously undisciplined and self-defeating even to the most radical workers.

In some areas, like Port Elizabeth and Uitenhage, the tensions have come to the fore, with extreme hostilities developing between

Scan page 7

n South Africa, Bob Fine looks at the struggle of students E FRONT LINE ST APARTHEID on the police.

many trade unionists on the one side and many students on the other - a tension exacerbated by the unemployment looming ahead for many students, In other areas, students and workers have managed to come impressive array of alternative educational courses for shop stewards and organisers. They see this as an integral aspect of trade union democracy and workers' control.

The students, however, today, do not go in for alternative educasimply, Revolution needs an educated working class. The state has done its damnedest to deny black people an education. It would be ironic if just at the moment when econoTion Ma.rk The problem is to these policies into practice.

Many of the difficulties in the way of a student-worker alliance are complicated, in my view, by a tendency within the ANC to celebrate, hail and claim the credit for the largely spontaneous militancy of students, rather than give it form, shape and direction.

Oliver Tambo's strategy of 'making South Africa ungovernable' puts students more than any other group on the front line. The ANC does not sufficiently use its authority to organise a channel for student struggles.

here are two related dangers. There is a limit to the courage of even the black students of South Africa. How many times can they come back with stones against highpowered rifles?

And there is a risk that the students could turn their anger inwards, embarking on a search for ever more collaborators within the black communities.

Confront

The struggle can be confined to the black townships, and not directly confront the white state.

Solidarity between students here and students in South Africa is a matter of urgency. Links can be made with the unbanned student organisations, perhaps in the first instance with the student organisations for higher education NUSAS and SASO in the UDE. AAASM in the National Forum.

Concrete solidarity is needed. and the first step towards establishing it would be to make contact and find out as directla as possible what, solidarity black students want, what oppression they tace. and what strategies of resistance they pursue.

Recently clear evidence has come out showing the systematic physical and psychological torture of young detainees, often as young as 12 or 13 years old, The student movement in this country • could play a great role in making common cause with black students for a democratic education system as an essential part of a future democratic South Africa.

The first issue of Workers"

Liberty magazine is a special issue on S.Africa. 75p plus postage

----- pull-quotes -----

FROM SO

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 247

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →