Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

YTS cheap labour

Socialist Organiser no. 247, 10 October 1985 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,096 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Student demonstration ondon, 1984. Photo: Andrew Wiard SOCIAL SCHEMES GOOD - WHY RE FORCE YOUTH ONTO THEM??

From April 1986 the Tory government plans to expand their Youth Training Scheme from one to two years.

Somehow they hope to double the scheme in this way but spend only 38% more on YTS. The result can only be to reduce still further any element of real training in the scheme, and make it just cheap labour!

The government is planning to get rid of the 'Mode B' schemes run by voluntary groups. local authorities, and colleges, and have only schemes run by employers. The Mode B' schemes:often include more real training and are less dominated by profit considerations; they also give black youth a much better chance than the employers' schemes. In January 1985, 40% of Asian YTSers, and 44% of Afro-Caribbeans, were on Mode B schemes, as against 23% of white YTSers.

All this makes the official Manpower Services Commission's promises to improve YTS schemes - in training, health and safety, and equal opportunity - empty words. As it is, in January 198530 percent of all employer-run YTS schemes fell short of MSC standards. The only way this figure is likely to fall is by the MSC reducing its standards or turning a blind eye.

The Tories are still talking about making YTS compulsory. but they are hesitant. They have great difficulty getting their present number of YTS places, let alone what they would need if every 16 and 17 year old had to be on YTS. (As of 1984, 25% of 1o year olds were on YIS). And to force huge numbers of unwilling youth into the schemes could make them unmanageable.

But already many youth get their supplementary benefit docked for refusing or dropping out of YTS schemes. And that will continue.

YTS is mostly cheap labour rather than training. According to official figures, 30% of YTSers do work similar to ordinary employees, and 40% help ordinary employees do their job. Most YTS schemes lead to no recognised qualification.

Where YTS schemes do lead to a useful qualification, this is usually for one of two reasons.

Improve Sometimes trade unions ha managed to improve the qual of the schemes. Elsewhe employers use YTS as a che substitute for the first year their apprenticeship or traini schemes.

YTS is cheaper for employe than regular training. And th can use it as a filter. At the e of the year - or two years they allow chosen youth to ce tinue on the rest of the traini programme, and the others c be thrown out with no questio asked.

Only 30% of YTSers get a j with the same employer at t end of their scheme; 40% get job at all. (MSC figures frc 1984).

From the point of view of the Tories and the employers, YTS has two purposes. Expensive traditional systems of apprenticeship and training can be scrapped and cheaply replaced. And young workers' wage rates generally can be forced down.

In both respects YTS has had some success. Apprenticeships are vanishing fast. A number of big employers now take on school-leavers only through YTS. And in 1984 youth wages began to fall seriously behind adult wages.

trade unions have won important gains for YTSers.

The basic pittance of £26.25 a week is frequently topped up. YTSers in Massey Ferguson get £83.41 a week; in Hackney and Sheffield councils, ₺52; in ICI Gloucester, tS0; in the British Airports Authority, £38.43.

Fares, cheap canteens or free meal vouchers, and free clothing have been won for YTSers elsewhere. In some companies the trade unions have equal opportunity clauses which cover YTSers.

Organise, and we can defeat the Tories' plans and win real training at decent wages!

(Most of the information in this article is taken fram Labour Research July 1985, and Bargaining Report June 1985. From Labour Research Dept, 78 Blackfriars Rd., London SE1 8HF). controversy, not the hail the leader show which suits the Tories or the SDP.

But one thing is bad. It is a very long time since Labour had any fierce debate on economic strategy. Labour Party democracy, women's rights, black sections, nuclear disarmament, all draw passionate arguments, and rightly — but on the overall framework of economic strategy the leaders have a much easier ride.

As a result the policy is very poor. This vear the National Executive (NEC) argued that the centrepiece of Labour policy should be a National Investment Bank. It's another scheme for coaxing capitalism into growth, not much different from the National Enterprise Board of the 1970s or the National Plan of the 1960s, and not likely to be more successful. In the shadows beside it stand wage controls.

As usual, the Marxist left said the NEC policy was futile tinkering, and we were in a small minority. But this year there was also a voice of dissent from the broader left.

"Urgent"

The Campaign Group of Labour MPs published a pamphlet, *A Million Jobs A Year'. On the title page the MPs stop short of definitely supporting the pamphlet's arguments, and say only that they "merit urgent consi deration "; six MPs in the group refused to sign even that endorsement. Nevertheless, the pamphlet appeared. Economic strategy was made an area of mainstream debate.

Unfortunately the contents of the pamphlet are not such dynamite as you might think from the MPs cautious approach.

It is written by Andrew Glyn, a supporter of Militant" and a Marxist. Yet the arguments are not at all Marxist. They are radical Keynesian.

Glyn says that "A Keynesian expansion is one which is not accompanied by such controls, at the level of industry and economy, as are necessary to secure success. But only the most milk-and-water Keynesianism rejects far-reaching state controls on the economy.

Keynes himself, a convinced Liberal until his death in 1946, advocated a "somewhat comprehensive socialisation of investment", and thought that his policies would kill off the private capitalist, the "rentier"

Glyn advocates state controls over financial • institutions, export of capital, prices and imports. In addition large companies must be state-controlled. Glvn would prefer to do this by nationalising the top 250 monopolies, but also offers two alternative methods: compulsory planning agreements, or stackng company boards with government and union nominees who would outvote shareholder interests. • This array of controls, Glyn argues, would enable a Labour government to expand the economy to full employment and

Scan page 9

million jobs a yeal

----- pull-quotes -----

Train a can be organised. bie. in a number of companies the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 247

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →