Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The causes dole queues

Socialist Organiser no. 247, 10 October 1985 · scan pp. 9–11 · Colin Foster · about 3,655 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Photo: Andrew Moore. 'import substitution' (replacing there is no technical difficulty imports by British-manufactur- about giving everyone a decent ed goods). job: it is a political question As proof of the possibility of how the economy is organishe cites Britain's war economy, ed. But his programme is effecwhich expanded employment by tively state capitalism, not 3.4 million in 1938-42; and the socialism. post-war Labour government Brazil has vast resources. Post which increased civilian employ- war Britain was the world's secment by 3 million in 1945-8. ond most advanced industrial He could also cite several power, with big captive markets Third World capitalisms - mili- in its Empire, in a world hungry tary-ruled Brazil, for example, for exports. In both cases the which increased its industrial working class was kept under workforce from 13 million to 25 strict control. million between the early 1960s Could modern Britain and 1975, and made the coun- heavily integrated into the world try an exporting power in sever- economy, but as a third-rate al good which it previously had industrial power, a net importer to import. of manufactured goods — carry The Third World countries out a similar national expandon't get full employment be- sion? Could "socialist moderncause their countrysides expel isation" make its production labour even faster than industry competitive with South Korea's grows: but Britain doesn't have and Japan's, despite improved that problem. wages, conditions, and workers' Glyn is right rights also advocated by Glyn? Probably not.

And what social force would carry out Glyn's programme? During World War 2 the British capitalist class had no choice but a siege economy. Third World capitalists are 'nationalists' by economic necessity. But British capitalists today are not narrow nationalists. Their business is world-wide.

And the working class? So long as the working class sets its aim narrowly as national expansion for Britain, it will not be able to lead society. And when and where the working class does triumph, its programme Will necessarily be different from Glyn's package of state controls.

As techniques of state control there is indeed not much difference between nationalisation and compulsory planning agreements. But for working-class control of the economy, common ownership is irreplaceable.

A shorter working week, vast expansion of education and re-training, re-designing of technology, socialisation of housework - these measures. mentioned scarcely or not at all by Glyn, would be simultaneous with the expansion of jobs under a system where the working class controlled the means of production instead of being subordinate to and used by the rhythm of the expansion of those means of production.

Immediate political pressures mean that working-class rule would either spread over several countries or perish. Workers' power in one country alone in present-day Europe would be only a passing phase. A socialist economic programme cannot sensibly be devised 'in one country"

As Third World experience proves, a nationalist state-controlled system of the type advocated by Glyn would have a capitalist content within the forms of planning. State enterprises would conform to international competition. Workers would be subordinated to the expansion of capital in the form of bureaucratic empire-building rather than traditional free enterprise. The present ruling class would not be broken up.- Glyn mentions only higher taxes on top people - but would continue to dominate the state and economic management. They would, apparently, still draw their dividends and their capital gains, alongside no doubt new incomes from corruption.

A lot of the limitations of the pamphlet, suspect, are seltimposed. Andrew Glyn would probably have preferred to write something more radical, but has bent over backwards to devise a scheme that could 'realistically' be put before Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley for implementation.

Implement

He gets the worst of it both ways. Kinnock and Hattersley will not implement this programme — indeed, not even the whole of the Campaign Group will so much as recommend "urgent consideration" of it. If a few bits of it should get implemented - some price controls, miscellaneous import controls, exchange controls - they will do nothing progressive.

But all the careful moderation and realism has deprivet the programme of the sweep and fire that could rally the rank and file.

Scattered through the paraphlet are references to 'mobilisation', "access to information' tull involvement of employees in relevant decisions' 'active support. None of them is bold enough to convey unambiguously the idea of more than SDPtype industrial democracy and consultation, or working class activity at a higher level than demonstrations, rallies, meetings and trade union negotiations.

The recommendations thus remain a blueprint for Westminster and Whitehall rather than a programme for action by the working class.

Read this pamphlet. Discuss it. Take advantage of the fact that it has broken the freeze on debating economic strategy in the Labour Party. But take it as the first word of that debate, not the last.

*'A Million Jobs A Year', by Andrew Glyn, Verso Editions, ( E1. Officially Britain has 3¼ million unemployed. In fact, according to the TUC, it has four to five million.

The advanced capitalist coun tries have over 30 million unemployed between them. There is no prospect of this figure falling seriously. If — or rather when — the US dives into a full-scale slump again, and the Third World debt crisis explodes once more, the figure will increase.

The Third World capitalist countries have no reliable figures for unemployment, but estimates range round 500 million. 25 per cent of black South Africans, for example, are estimated to be jobless.!

The Tories say that workers have priced themselves out of jobs. Wages are too high.

But unemployment was lower when wages were rising fast in the 1950s and '60s. Since around 1970 real wages have stagnated or fallen in the US and risen very slowly elsewhere, but unemployment has multiplied.

If you compare different countries, usually the ones with higher wages have lower unemployment. Britain has lower wages than the US, West Germany or Japan.

Unemployment is not caused by high wages. Both unemployment and pressure to reduce wages are caused by capitalist crisis.

Technology

A lot of people say that unemployment is caused by new technology. But capitalism has been introducing new technologies continuously ever since the steam engine, and on the whole employment has expanded rather than declined.

Detailed studies can find only a few thousand job losses, among the millions in Britain in recent years, caused by new technology. In fact productivity in most advanced capitalist countries, and especially in Britain, is rising very slowly. Unemployment mostly reflects lower production, not higher production with fewer workers.

And if you compare different countries, those with most new technology, like Japan and Sweden, generally have lower unemployment.

The most idiotic theory of all is Jeffrey Archer's, according to which people are unemployed only because they are too lazy to get jobs. How does he explain the hundreds of applications that firms have often had even for low-paid, dead-end jobs? And was it something in the water, or in the atmosphere, that made workers throughout the advanced capitalist countries suddenly start to turn idle around the end of the 1960s? The real reason why millions are unemployed is. because the economy is run for profit and not for human need.

Under the present economic system - capitalism - the aim of production is to expand capital, the accumulated •wealth of shes ulit is profitable tas tet 00s 11 tontane terr bosses, and not if it isn't.

Employment therefore expands and contracts in line with the pulse-beat of profits, investments and markets.

In boom periods each capitalstrives for an increasing share of an expanding market. New investment projects are rushed through. Speculation spirals.

But not every capitalist can have an increased share. Even-* tually the expansion falters. Investment is halted. Projects already underway are revealed. to be unprofitable. The slump" spreads from the credit system through the investment industries to every sector of the As workers lose their jobs, the capitalists who previously sold goods to those workers lose their | markets. And those capitalists, in turn, sack more workers. The. system spirals downwards.

People go short - because "too much" has been produced!"

The slump levels out only when enough capital has been written off, and wages have been reduced sufficiently, tor profits to be restored. A new boom starts - and with it the seeds of a new slump.

In the Third World , the rapid destruction by capitalism of the traditional economy in the countryside has generated huge, and rising unemployment for decades. In the advanced capitalist countries, it was a bit different int he '50s and '60s.

A new framework allowing ther rapid expansion of world trade: after World War 2, and the growth of a wave of new indus-* tries, made booms strong and slumps shallow. Masses of new workers were drawn from underdeveloped countries and regions; more and more women were drawn into wage-work.

Capitalism always made sure that there was a slight surplus of workers over jobs - otherwise workers' bargaining position would be too strong - and in slumps the surplus became bigger. But the real turn for the worse came after the late '60s, when the framework of international finances set up after 1945 began to break down.

Forces

Under capitalism men and women do not control our own social life. We are tossed around by economic forces, of human construction but beyond human control - supply and demand, profit and investment, credit and liquidity.

So capitalism, internationally at least, has no way to restructure itself except crisis.

The US is no longer superdominant. New industrial powers have arisen. Previously central industries like cars and steel are in decline; new ones are emerging. The system knows no way to adjust to these changes other than by the travail of trade wars, slumps, and deindustrialisation.

The remedy? We must take control of the means of production we have created and run them by democratic planning for need. We must replace the crazy patchwork of national rivalries with a co-operative international system. In place of the rat race, we must run society on principles of solidarity.

The struggle for jobs can be brought to completion only by the working class taking power in society. But we can start now with a fight for workers" control, for unity of the employed and unemployed, and for work-sharing without loss of pay.

Scan page 10

Colin Foster reviews 'Tender is the Night' BBC is currently serialising a screen version of Scott Fitzgerald's novel "Tender is the Night' — a naive, sprawling, but eloquent story of the decay of apitalism between the wars.

Giant

The US came out of World War 1 as the young giant of apitalism. It boomed while the uld empires of war-shattered Europe wallowed in crisis. Ford cars, "flappers' , jazz, escalating Stock Exchange speculation — it Sweating-song', written by T tailors' strike in Leeds in 1888 ist paper 'Workers' Friend' in Up in the morn, at break To the Sweater's den we go; We sweat our health and strength away, And pale and sickly grow, That the sweaters may dwell in mansions fair, And wear the cosliest cloths While our children starve in hovels bare Where the sunlight goes is one and nan nas a right to October Ma an the was the biggest, brashest party in history.

The US working class had little part in the celebrations. But they were silent. After all, their wages were higher than in other countries, and industry was generating more and more jobs.

Crashed

In 1929 the New York Stock Exchange crashed and the great hangover began. The US became a country of hungry shanty-towns, unemployment movements and mass strikes, public works programmes and fascist rallies, on the road tO World War 2, Scott Fitzgerald's life curiousguire on the occasion of the Jew I republished by the Jewish soc early 1900s.

It he be honest and true, It for his bread he'll freely give The best his hands can do. Why should he toil starving the while, Driven and bullied by men Who never were fitted for But are fit for a sweating honest work den?..

We hope with best men Better days yet to When and int In Britain and everywhere, Whether he labour by needl or spade, Shall gather in rightful share. ly paralleled the curve of US capitalism. From the shabbygenteel middle class, he suddenLy became rich and famous in 1920 when his first novel, "This Side of Paradise' was a bestseller. He was 24.

On the strength of his new wealth he married Zelda Sayre — who previously had refused him because of his lack of funds — and from 1924 lived mainly on the Riviera, spending fantastically, drinking more and more, and working less and less.

"Tender is the Night', his fourth and last completed novel, took him nine years of increasingly laboured effort, from 1925 to 1934.

Patient

His life turned sharply downwards in 1930, when Zelda went into a mental hospital. She soon became a permanent patient. Fitzgerald returned to the US and became a lonely, brokendown man, scratching a living by scribbling for magazines and the movies. He died in 1940.

Like almost everything Fitzgerald wrote, "Tender is the Night' is about himself (though the main character, Dick Diver, is also partly modelled on a triend, Gerald Murphy). He aims, as he put it, to "show a man who is a natural idealist... giving in for various causes to the ideas of the haute bourgeoisie, and in his rise to the top of the social world losing his idealism, his talent, and turning to drink and dissipation."

The novel opens with Dick, an American student in Zurich in 1917, talented and charming. Out of generosity, idealism, vanity and love, he marries Nicole Warren, an heiress but a mental patient.

The brilliant Divers become a focus, a warming flame, for the moneyed Americans on the Riviera. But bit by bit Dick drains himself.

He ends with a whimper. Nicole leaves him for Tommy Barban, a man who announces this creed: "I'm a soldier. My business is to kill people. I fought against the Riff [Moroccan anti-colonial rebels] because I'm a European, and I have fought the Communists because they want to take my property from me"

And Dick? "In the last setter had Son him he told her he (medicine Lakes section and considered a pleasant place...

Nicole represents in part, of course, the old patriarchal myth of the femme fatale. But she also represents a whole class - the rotten wealth of theleisure class.

"Nicole was the product of much ingenuity and toil. For her sake trains began their run at Chicago and traversed the round belly of the continent of California; chicle factories fumed and link belts grew link by link in factories; men mixed toothpaste in vats and drew mouthwash out of copper hogsheads; girls canned tomatoes quickly in August or worked rudely at the Five-and-Tens on Christmas Eve; half-breed Indians toiled on Brazilian coffee plantations and dreamers were muscled out of patent rights in new tractors — these were some of the people who gave a tithe to Nicole and, as the whole system swayed and thundered onward, it lent a feverish bloom to such processes of hers as wholesale buying, like the flush of a fireman's face holding his post before a spreading blaze. She illustrated very simple principles, containing in herself her own doom, but illustrated them so accurately that there was grace in the procedure...

In many ways Scott Fitzgerald never grew up. His whole life he remained childishly selfobsessed, snobbish, and sexist with a bemused image of women as mysterious and wonderful creatures.

Snob

He was fascinated by the rich, with an edge of hostility as a self-made snob resentful of those bred to wealth and as a man guilty about his own selfdissipation. His social philosophy was veneered by a Marxism impressed on him by intellectual awe in face of his friend Edmund Wilson, the resulting mixture being well-expressed in a letter to his daughter:

"My generation of radicals and breakers-down never found anything to take the place of the old virtues of work and courage and the old graces of courtesy and politeness. But I don't want you to live in an unreal world or to believe that the system that produced Barbara Hutton can survive more than ten years, any more than the French monarchy would survive 1789".

But like Boswell or Pepys, Dickens or Henry James, Fitzerald. have been TONG The story of bourgeois decay so graphically and in so agonised a way that there was poetry in the procedure. A striking feature of our society in recent years has been the urge towards fitness and the discovery of the enjoyment of exercise. According to one estimate* there are some five million runners in Britain at the moment, an astonishing figure.

Cynics have been quick to note how tracksuits, etc., have become fashionable, but this is in itself a proof that healthy lifestyles are not just a passing fad. Health Education News pointed out recently that those who wear fashionable sportswear without expending the effort to keep fit are nevertheless trying to associate themselves with a lifestyle that they admire. Elsewhere, HEN evidences public interest in health in its coverage of this summer' health fairs and "fun runs" Peole are heeding the Health Education Council's advice to "Look After Yourself"

But why should people need to be told to look after themselves? Perhaps part of the answer lies in the division of labour that results in some getting little or no exercise, while others get unbalanced exercise, The resulting boredom and stress leaves many without the inclination to undertake exercise, instead laying them open to the encouragement to indulge in various unhealthy habits such as smoking, drinking and eating lots of junk food.

Out of the five million British runners, some two million are women. Overcoming the discouragements of myth and male chauvinism, women's athletics has exploded into prominence of late. At competition level, women are now able at last to compete in all track events, having previously been excluded for a variety of bizarre reasons.

The result has been a drastic closure of the gap between male and female records. Most striking has been the progress of the women's marathon record. The gap has dropped from 40 to 10% in just 15 years.

Some experts think that the narrowing will continue until women catch up men, at least in the longer distance events. Most however believe that anatomical differences place a limit on this catching up. We will now look at these arguments.

1. Body fat. Women carry up to twice as much fat as men (relatively speaking). In running, this is simply a weight to be carried around. However, where the weight is supported as in cycling and swimming, the buoyancy of fat and its insulating properties are a distinct advantage and women already outdo men in long-distance swimming (e.g. cross-Channel).

Even in running, fat may be an advantage in endurance races since women's muscles seem better able to burn it 2. Shape of hips. Broader hips tend to make running less efficient with energy wasted as the heels are kicked out. Knees are also prone to damage. This can be overcome by training to run differently.

3. Sweating. Women"s sweating mechanism seems less efficient, leading to overheating. However, their greater capacity for radiating heat from the ski may be an seem to have relatively bigger hearts and more blood. Therefore, they can get more oxygen around their bodies. However, efficient at using the they get.

These arguments show that the question is still open and that women may catch up with men, depending on the event and the conditions, and assuming, of course, that they want to.

Most people run not to compete but for health and enjoyments and one very tangible effect of regular exercise is on body weight.

Overweight is very common in Britain (which is after all the most unhealthy of the industrial countries), largely because of a high intake of refined foods with a large energy content. With little of that energy being used, it is simply stored as fat.

Useless

Often the same companies that promote unhealthy foods have a highly profitable sideline in "diet" foods and there is a lucrative market in books peddling one or other generally useless diet.

But overweight can be easily reduced by regular running and less refined toods, as several interviewees in the Kunning supplement* testified. Comments like "I eat what I like now" were typical.

One myth persists that exercise is bad during pregnancy, and that childbearing marks the end to an athletic career. This is no doubt a consequence of the male medical view of pregnancy as an illness.

In fact, apart from women with a history of miscarriage, exercise such as running can be very beneficial. Examples of such benefits are: less risk of varicose veins, piles, toxaemia, insomnia and depression; shorter and easier labour; fewer complications during labour and less. need for forceps and Caesarean births; faster recovery after birth (including less stretch marks).

Their running also improves after birth. This may be because running during pregnancy is like gradual resistance training, making the heart and blood system more efficient.

Many athletes have shown such improvements, including Ingrid Kristiansen who broke the marathon record 18 months after the birth of her son.

*Information from "Running for Women" - supplement to the October issue of Running agazine. Running magazine =s organised a network to put unem beginners in touch with experienced women runnem who will help them get star For details, write to Sisters work.

Mort

Scan page 11

Teache This strike co the background of co attempts by management

----- pull-quotes -----

Songs of liberty and rebellion ng

women's muscles seem more Science

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 247

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →