Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Bosses perks Pay How classes vote

Socialist Organiser no. 248, 17 October 1985 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 1,188 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Another 2.65 million part-time women workers are on "low-paid" hourly rates, and an unknown number of part-time male workers and young workers.

A major aim of Tory government policy in recent years has been to reduce young workers' wages relative to adult rates. The Youth Training Scheme is part of this effort; so is the government's plan to remove all workers under 21 from the protection of wages councils.

According to Labour Research, already "The Low Pay Unit says that pay rises for young females have fallen 30% behind the equivalent increases for adults and for males 23%- 32 A new book 'How Britai n Votes', by Heath, Jowell, and Curtice, substantially changes our picture of the relationship between voting and social class.

Conventional pollanalyses seem to show that Labour support is declining steadily in the working class, and that support for the Alliance is spread evenly throughout all social classes.

But these analyses do not separate off the self-employed from the working class, or supervisors from other workers. Moreover, they classify women not by their own jobs but by their husbands' Reanalysing the data, Heath, Jowell and Curtice show that rank and file manual workers vote Labour as consistently as Salariat Petty bourgeois Foremen etc Clerks etc Manual workers they did in the 1960s; that the long-term decline in the Labour vote is entirely due to the increase in the 'salariat' and the relative decline in the manual working class; and that the Alliance vote is concentrated in the middle class.

These are figures 1983.

Con All It's a pity thai "salariat' does not distinguish between managers and the very high-paid on the one hand, and highly-qualified wage-workers on the other. Still, there is plenty of food for thought.

The figures could be taken to support the people who argued after the 1959 election that Labour was declining because of the growth in the number of relatively well-off white-collar workers, and that therefore Labour must become more moderate, more middle class.

But there is another way of looking at it. Over recent decades salaried and clerical workers have become unionised in large numbers, and often militant. Couldn't their lack of attraction to Labour be due to the fact that Labour is too "moderate' , too fuddy-duddy, too timid and stodgy? first excluding the [semi-Stalinists] from SA and now blocking with and handing over the paper to them is final proof of its utter bankruptcy.

"Its small and declining base is increasingly a hard core who ..are prepared to swallow anv ideological baggage which fits the latest alliance"

Wavered

For nearly 40 years now the international current of which SA is part has wavered between class struggle and power bloc politics. Time and again it has veered away from a working class programme in order to embrace revolutionary processes' led by Stalinists or nationalists — Tito, Mao, Ben Bella, Castro, Ho Chi Minh.

But it always retained some reservations, and the ability to veer back again.

In early 1979, following the death of its veteran theorist Joseph Hansen, the US SWP made a bigger-than-usual lurch - and, it seems, a decisive break with working-class It has identified itself completely with the one-party bureaucratic regime in Cuba. It has not only supported the Sandinistas against US-sponsored counter-revolution (as indeed every socialist must), but also endorsed every detail of Sandinista policy, including their alliances with the bourgeoisie and their suppression of strikes.

It fully supported the USSR's invasion of Afghanistan in December 1979 (though it has changed its mind since). While

Scan page 5

Graham Norwood, Deputy Leader, Lambeth Council "We must begin a fightback". • Photo: John Smith, IFL What we expect now is that the NEC of the Labour Party fulfill its immediate commitment to give practical financial and political support to those councillors in their legal case, but also to ensure that there is no let-up in the demand over the next couple of years for the next Labour Government to ensure that Lambeth councillors and any others who may be penalised in the next two years of struggle, do in fact have the retrospective legislation applied in favour of them.

Decisive

In a more general sense, Kinnock's attack on Liverpool, and his whole tenor, show that he is no longer the sort of windbag leader that he was. He is much more decisive and he has gone over much more firmly to the right.

There have also been conspicuous moves by people like Blunkett to some extent in his support for Meacher, despite Meacher's betrayal of the miners, to align himself with Kinnock, We've also seen people like Livingstone virtually disappear from the conference in order to avoid being put on the spot for their own past performances.

I suspect this may be one of the last conferences where we will be seeing a lot of the genuine debate for which Labour Party conference is rightly renowned, towards a Tory-style rally around the leadership.

In that case fringe meetlings and other events will become more important.

The left needs to do two things aimed at getting one end result: we need to get a constructive analysis of what the left has to offer as an alternative to Kinnock.

Ten or twelve years ago when Wilson was leading the Labour Party in much the same way that Kinnock now is, people were trying to give the left some sort of focus to galvanise it against the leadership. Benn was also rising as a potential new leader. What we need to do now is to get a similar set of circumstances.

Analysis

So we need an analysis around which much of the left can unite as an alternative to Kinnock. It has to be something more constructive than simply booing Kinnock.

Secondly we need to get a leader or a potential group of leaders as a collective left leadership. Whether that is people like Benn, Heffer and Skinner or whether we want to look to other sections of the labour movement than simply Parliament and try and get local government leaders, rank and file people, gays and lesbians, etc. around a united left who would be the spokespeople for the left that is what we need.

I cannot see Kinnock being defeated, but if we do not challenge him then the climate of intimidation against any dissenter will only get worse.

We have to begin a fight back, simply for the democracy of the Labour Party. Kinnock said before coming to conference that whatever resolutions were passed, if he didn't like them he would ignore them.

There was also a climate at conterence, particularly during the miners' debate, where anybody dissenting in some sections of the hall, from the Kinnock line, were being treated as absolute traitors, as friends of Mrs Thatcher, and that general climate Kinnock did nothing to deter. Quite the reverse.

I'm optimistic in the sense that we've had some good decisions coming out of conference and you cannot miss the general goodwill towards the miners from rank and file delegates, and towards the councillors, Unfortunately I think there is a growing cynicism

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 248

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →