Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Action splits up

Socialist Organiser no. 248, 17 October 1985 · scan p. 4 · about 582 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

The supporters of Socialist Action have split. A minority, describing itself as a public faction' will no longer sell and support the weekly Socialist Action. Instead they will distribute Labour Briefing a monthly bulletin oriented to the left in local government), Youth Fightback, and the Paris-based fortnightly International Viewpoint. They also plan to publish their own journal, quarterly to begin with.

The minority sees the Socialist Action editorial board as suffering a "growing ascendancy" of co-thinkers of the US Socialist Workers' Party - a group that *is revisionist and evolving in the direction of some cryptoStalinist positions"

SA, they say, is run by a coalition of these semi-Stalinists and a group round SA editor John Castro Ross. The Ross clique systematically puts organisational alliances and manoeuvres above politics. Its gyrations around still criticising the Kremlin_to some extent, it prints articles about how good life is for workers in the USSR. It has rejected almost all action in solidarity with Solidarnose as an affair of social-democratic cold-warriors.

It has explicitly discarded the Trotskyist theory of permanent revolution. Currently, its policy on South Africa is to identify completely with the Stalinist-led ANC. The recent SWP congress ended with the delegates chanting in unison "ANC! ANC! ANC!* Africa John Ross says he still supports permanent revolution, but in practice he tully agrees with the SWP on South Africa and Nicaragua. The same political approach has been applied to Trish and British politics.

SA describes the Provisional Republican movement as the nearest thing in Europe to a mass revolutionary workers' party, and sees no need for a Marxist organisation in Ireland fighting for Catholic-Protestant workers' unity on the basis of class struggle rather than militarism. In Britain, the role of Castro, Ortega, Oliver Tambo or Gerry Adams, is played by Arthur Scargill: SA pretends that the least criticism of or differentiation from Scargill is a betrayal of the miners. It denounces practically all the Labour Left - including such groups as Labour Briefing and Militant -as "ultra-left", and has vocally and persistently opposed any challenge to Kinnock's leadership.

SA's lurch towards such politics has drastically reduced its profile on the British left -partly because of the politics themselves, and partly because of the factional conflict accompanying their development. For some time SA's supporters have been divided into three main groupings pro-SWP-US; Ross; and the present public faction - with none of the three having a majority. There are also smaller sub-groupings. Ross has run the paper first in alliance with one group, then with another.

The public faction does not go as far in criticising the Ross/ SWP approach as Socialist Organiser would - in fact, in most respects this grouping simply continues the old-style politics of SA's predecessors before the post-1979 lurch — but there should be a good basis for practical collaboration and political dialogue between us and them.

We have suggested discussions to them, although they say that they want to get themselves in shape before major discussions with other groups. They plan a conference next spring. They hope to gather round themselves many old SA supporters who have stopped selling SA in despair at the factional conflicts of recent years but who remain active in the labour movement.

They also hope for international support. The majority of the international current to which SA belongs is opposed to the SWP-US's politics, or at least to its worst excesses, and so the new public faction expects sympathy from groups in France, Sweden, etc.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 248

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →