Desperately seeking the exit
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Morbid Perhaps others, more stupid And she thinks about God a awful load of old rubbish. lot, not always in the politest of Apparently some of those in the terms. Joseph, as you might GLC's plush new Metro cinema expect, doesn't really get a look with me did enjoy it - although in, which traumatises him great- 1 had the feeling that they proly — so that he spends the entire bably would have enjoyed a film looking morbid and sullen blank screen with a high-pitched and chasing no-doubt allegorical squeak if it had been directed by characters into no-doubt allegor- the right person.
Meanwhile, two further char- idea that I'm a philistine or acters (no doubt allegorical take anything. Far from it. I watch their clothes off in front of the Channel Four. I even read City fire, and then have a trauma Limits occasionally. So I know because one of them is going soporific garbage when I see it. back to his wife in Prague...(Is Trust the GLC to fund it, that's Edward Ellis reviews H Jean Luc Godard, curre Cinema in London.Nuw in my book a story has got a beginning, a middle and an end: if it's got a moral or a message, it should put it across simply and clearly with no beating about the bush.
And that goes for a film. If, for some bizarre reason, eccentric directors consider it artistically desirable to make films French, or even in German, that's all right by me, so long as someone puts legible. sub-titles at the bottom.
What I can't stand is long, boring, arty films with no story and no good tunes.
John Luke Godard's Hail Mary' is therefore a very bad film.
It has its attractions, of course. Any film that sends Catholics into apoplectic frenzy can't be all bad. Probably even Life of Brian' gained a certain "je ne sais quoi' after getting into trouble for threatening to bring heavenly retribution crashing down about our heads. And apparently 'Hail Mary' has provoked lots of protests from outraged papists, angry at its blasphemous subject matter.
The wonder is that anybody, papist or otherwise, understands enough of it to notice the blasphemy Okay, so it is about a woman called Mary who is a virgin and yet clearly pregnant; and okay, her perplexed boyfriend is called Joseph. And okay, the unpleasant little brat to which she gives birth disappears at an early age commenting laconically lam He that is. I must be about my Father's business'.
But apart from that, guess is as good as mine.
Puritanical
Much of the film consists of long close ups of bits of Mary's body. It is this that has so upset devotees of the real Mary. The more puritanical presumably rest their case on the well known fact that the real Virgin Mother did not possess such bits; while others with more of a feminist bias have claimed that the film is merely high-brow pornography - a false claim on two counts, because it falsely equates the incomprehensible with the highil Mary', the new film by Itly showing at the Metro brow, and because it falsely assumes that anyone would be sufficiently awake to be erotically stimulated.
There are lots of shots of natural things - full moons, half moons, water, sky, that sort of thing: There are some pretty impressive shots of the sky, In fact, every time Mary thinks about God.
ical clothes shops.
this in the Bible?).
Heavens, what shall I do?
On the other hand, Godard's work is in reality deeply subversive: it undermines our own learned perception of the relationship between sequences of events; Godard squeezes the essence of mortal existence out of painful human situations as if squeezing puss out of a spot. He seizes upon our latent fixations, explores the contradictions between the empty spaces, opens up the inner reality of the Anone on naalito of tha gaps in our miscomprehensions of reality; sends us to sleep...
than I might enjoy this GodI don't want anyone to get the all I can say.