Labour and
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Public opinion in Britain wants troops out of Ireland. Labour movement activists by now know the basic facts about the troops brutality and the plight of the Northern Ireland Catholics. Yet there is little activity in the British labour movement on Ireland tion which would make 'Troops Out' one element in a coherent London police activities against the Prov- Northern Ireland Catholics. When Ire- Ireland but to bloody repartition and two isional IRA. The London government land was debated at the 1979 conter- Irish states; and very much wants to involve Dublin; but ence, soon after Labour ceased to run 3: That Northern Ireland is some sort central to its calculations is the the government, the debate was domi- of legitimate expression of the rights of question of how much they can concede nated by men like Michael Foot and the Protestant community, which can to Dublin without provoking a massive Stan Orme, both of them exuding the only be changed fundamentally with Orange backlash. That's what will deter- political stench of Long Kesh concentra- their consent. mine the degree of 'movement' from the tion camp. Official Labour now has a new These arguments command wideeleven-year-old Northern Ireland stale- face turned to Ireland. mata which the Duhlin /Tandon neontia. Today ite ronrecontativAc etrece that ment. and have to he demolished if WHY IS THE Troops-Out-Of-Ireland current so feeble in the British labour movement?
For 13 years or so now opinion polls at various times have shown as much as 50 percent, and sometimes more, of the British people to be in favour of British withdrawal from Northern Ireland. Yet organised campaigning or even persuasive advocacy of British withdrawal is no important part of British political life -sixteen years after British troops took control of Northern Ireland; nearly 14 years after Britain abolished the old Protestant-Unionist home-rule government in Belfast, replacing it by what has become indefinite direct rule from London; and 11 years after the Orange general strike of 1974.
Even after a notable accession of counts for little in our movement. As one advocate of Troops Out, Sheena Clarke, put it at this year's Labour Party conference, "We have a clear position on Nicaragua — why are we different on Northern Ireland?"
The debate on Troops Out at this year's Labour Party conference is one place to go looking for an answer to this question. Not long ago it was difficult and usually impossible to get Ireland debated at Labour Party conference. Now 'the Irish debate' looks like becoming a hardy annual, providing us with a public register of the state of labour movement opinion on Ireland. A Labpur Party National Executive working party on Ireland is due to report within the next year.
This year's debate took place on the eve of the latest British government attempt to change things in Northern Ireland. The terms of a new DublinLondon deal on Northern Ireland will be announced in two or three weeks, after many months of secret' negotiations between the British government and the 26 County coalition.
This deal is likely to include some 26 County government involvement in the running of Northern Ireland, together with a unification of Dublinprogramme.
mangar mann mona am tanta tors will dare agree on.
Backlash
It was the Protestant backlash, in the form of an Orange general strike - a movement of revolutionary scope and implications, but serving reactionary goals — which wrecked the last LondonDublin attempt to build Protestant/Catholic power-sharing political structures in the Six Counties, back in 1974. 11 years later all the signs are that the politicians have nerved themselves for a new attempt to remodel Where Labour stands on Ireland may be very important in the months ahead if the Tories come into head-on conflict with the Orange majority in Northern Official Labour has evolved a little from the Party's politics of the "70s, when it was responsible for terrorising, jailing and torturing the half-a-million they are for a united Ireland, pledging themselves to work for it gradually by creating all-Ireland political structures which will, over time, sap the will of the Northern Ireland majority to resist a United Ireland.
However, this is on the level not of serious politics but Walter Mitty fantasy. It's the equivalent of the joke answer to the question: how do you catch a bird? Put salt on its tail.
Like your average bird, the Orangeists won't stay still long enough to have the salt rubbed in.
In government Labour would run Northern Ireland, perhaps make a few reforms here and there, and leave the basic framework intact.
Against Troops Out, official Labour stands on three positions, two of them clearly interlinked.
1: That British withdrawal would be followed immediately by sectarian civil war, and therefore, 2: Troops Out leads not to a united spread acceptance in the labour movethe left is to make progress. If the left is unable to deal with these arguments, then there will be no decisive shift in broad labour movement opinion on the Irish question — or on Ireland's "British question' Against the official position, the lent rallies around "Troops Out', which has now become something of a shibboleth, uniting behind it forces who have very different assessments or programmes to offer in answer to the question: after Troops Out, what then? Some sections of the left argue that no-one in Britain has a right to an opinion on the internal affairs of Ireland - other than to support Sinn Fein.
But what this year's Labour Party conference debate seems to me to show conclusively is that it is now counterproductive to use Troops Out alone without spelling out a positive programme too.
The conference saw a very important discussion around two resolutions, one calling for Troops Out during the life of the next Labour government, and the other calling for a discussion on Troops Out in the labour movement. I propose to give full summaries of the speeches, discussing the issues that arise as we go along.
Geoff Bell, from Hackney North and Stoke Newington Constituency Labour Party, said that the key to the debate on the Irish question was the Loyalist veto - the so-called right of the Unionist minority in the 32 counties to halt application of Irish majority rule and to insist that the forces of the British state are used to back their right.
(Yes, this Loyalist veto is very important - but the Loyalists have a veto and can insist on Britain remaining only because of the credibility with which they can threaten to do the job against the Six County Catholics and the 26 County state themselves, bloodily. That is the reality behind Britain's acceptance of the Orange veto.
Essentially, therefore, Bell was beside the point. In the minds of honest delegates what matters is the threat of Orange militarism).
Bell continued by quoting Ramsey MacDonald, pioneer Labour leader, first Labour prime minister (1924, 1929-31), and renegade, who broke with Labour to fig-leaf a Tory-based 'National Government' in 1931. 'Is Ulster going to deny the right of the Irish majority to be unified nation? No, emphatically no! Bell concluded: to vote against his composite is to be to the right of Ramsey MacDonald.
But all that was long ago, wasn't it? Some say Ireland should forget the past and live for the present. But now we live with the consequences of the past, of the unjustified partition imposed against the opposition of 75% of the Irish people. The consequences have been long and Should we say partition was wrong but nevertheless we should now accept it as a fact and live with the consequences? Geoff Bell invited the delegates to transfer that argument to South Africa. No-one would use the argument that South Africa exists as it is and that no new settlement can be accepted without white agreement. We should not use an analogous argument about majority rule in Ireland.
(This argument by analogy has little force. The whites in South Africa are a socia caste with an average income per head about 12 times that of the African population. Whites monopolise top jobs n industry and the state, taking some 98% of property income; the working class, apart from skilled craft workers, supervisors, and some white collar parades. is almost entirely black. In Northern Ireland the Protestants' leges are marginal.
Protestants are workers, their privileges consisting mostly of a better chance of a more secure 1ob in a more highly-paid industry. The Protestants are the majority in Northern Ireland. The whites are a 1-in-7 minority in South Africa.)
Bell anticipated one of the arguments of the opponents of Troops Out. (Like everyone else on his side of the debate, he ignored the other one, about Troop: Out contradicting a united ireland). He replied to the argument that withdrawal means a bloodbath in two contradictory ways. First, he seemed to concede the point.
*I'm not going to say that the minute Britain leaves Ireland peace will follow. But I would say it is a precondition for peace in Ireland". This seems to mean that there would be civil war immediately after British withdrawal, though perhaps not a very serious one.
Scan page 9
Ruitich tunane in Rolfnet Phato: Camerawork But Bell immediately went on, 'speaking as someone from the Protestant community in Northern Ireland', to denounce the idea he had just conceded.
"Do not beliéve all these horror stories about civil war and the holocaust that will follow if Britain leaves Northern Ireland. Because what that is really saying is that the Irish are stupid, bloodthirsty, and incapable of ruling themselves. That sort of argument is just one more anti-Irish joke.
What reason did Bell have for believing that the conflict following British withdrawal would lead to peace and a united Ireland, rather than to full-scale civil war, repartition, and population movements? Either he had none, or he didn't dare spell out his reasoning: that ne muks a civu war can uc wun. hashintan civil man non ho wan o he swung over to his second postion on civil war: only the 'anti-Irish' can believe it will happen.
Do communal civil wars arise because people are "stupid, bloodthirsty, and incapable of ruling themselves**? Yes, perhaps, on one level. But Marxists do not usually limit explanation to these 18th centurv utopian-rationalist arguments:
Civil wars arise because there are irreconcilable differences. Ireland has already had one civil war; the old United Kingdom, before Ireland seceded, came close to an Ireland-centred civil war just before World War 1.
So the notion that bombast about 'anti-Irish jokes' is any sort of answer to the real questions is a pretty strange one. It answers nobody, and cannot reassure those who support keeping the troops in Ireland for humanitarian reasons.
Bell's key point seems to be the allegation that anti-Irish racism is at the root of opposition to Troops Out - an attempt to shout at, indeed to abuse the conference, using the charge of anti-Irish racism as a blackjack. But it wasn't a well-chosen blackjack, even if blackjacking were the right thing to do.
Torturers It was time - Bell continued - for Britain to withdraw from Ireland - for Britain to take away its Bloody Sundays, its torturers. its strip-searches, to take away its plastic bullets and its lead bullets. Leave Ireland in peace' ', he said, 'and then peace will come' Seconding, the delegate from Kensington CLP, Miriam James, who is also Irish, said that withdrawal is in Labour's interest as well as Ireland's.
Labour's reputation in Ireland is not good: a Labour government sent troops to the Six Counties in 1969 and brought in the Prevention of Terrorism Act in 1974, 'which the Tories have used against everyone who stands for freedom and civil rights, not only in Ireland but in this country also' But there is a new understanding on Ireland in the Labour Party. Confersultation, then withdrawal = 'not' , she ence can commit the Party to first conadded, 'from Ulster, but from six coun ties of Ulster".
Set up consultation with political org anisations and trade unions throughout Ireland, and it will help Labour on its way to creating a free and united Ireland - by removing the British troops. The Irish issue is dividing people in Britain. Britain in Ireland is Ireland's problem: that's the Irish problem' Labour should formulate policy to get troops out, and 'then and only then can we shake hands with brothers and sisters in Ireland as equals.
Consent Hillsborough CLP), herself recently Councillor Sheena Clarke arrested and questioned under the Prevention of Terrorism Act when she visited Northern Ireland, moved the other composite.
It is 17 years, she said, since the civil rights marches in Northern Ireland brought home to us the horrors of Unionist rule: what progress has been made? There is a fudge on unification. The commitment to unification only by consent is commitment to an insuperable obstacle to unification. How will unifica'tion come by consent? Wait for a nationalist majority in the Six Counties? Nobody can seriously believe that rational argument will change Protestant minds. Britain will have to go sometime.
(What would happen then? If not 'rational' persuasion — to what, submission to a Catholic state? - then what? Withdrawal or coercion? Would a united Ireland follow? Or would there be a civil war? Sheena Clarke said nothing about this. She conceded that it is 'understandable that people have reservations'; but then she turned down the road of the argument that Britain's presence in Northern Ireland is analogous to colonial or imperialist presences in Third World countries).
We have a clear position on Nicaragua, said Sheena Clarke: why are we different on Northern Ireland? Her composite asked for a debate in the labour movement. She recalled the recent BBC censorship to eliminate an interview with Martin McGuinness of Sinn Fein.
We should talk to trade unionists in the whole of Ireland, she said, reading out part of the declaration of Trade Unionists for Irish Independence and Unity, a group of Stalinist and other nationalist full-time Irish union officials (and a few others). The declaration says inat a united working ciass in a 3z County Iredland could be a dynamic force leading to an Irish government pledged to working class interests. A divided Ireland produces the converse: weakness and division'. Britain must declare its intention to disengage and "hand over to the Irish government".
Sheena Clarke urged Labour to 'consult Irish comrades, both trade unionists and members of nationalist parties. We need practical proposals to schedule British withdrawal'.
Well, no. Before we need practical proposals to schedule British withdrawal, we need to convince people that Britain should withdraw, that Britain has no place in Ireland. We need to convince the labour movement that the argument that Northern Ireland expresses the democratic rights of the Protestants is wrong.
We need to convince people either that civil war will not follow British withdrawal, or that some good can come out of civil war.
The most striking thing in Sheena Clarke's speech, though, was her annanant andorcamont of the ctatement she read out. Yes, of course, a 'united working class in a 32 county Ireland could be a dynamic force..' The problem Is to get it.
it is sleight-of-hand and abracadabra politics to pretend that a united Ireland and a united working class are the same thing. It is utterly wrong-headed to postulate a united working class arising after and out of a united Ireland. For if the workers are not united, who will unite the country (whatever that may be without its people)?
No, the relationship between a united Ireland and a united working class goes Continued on page 10 Socialist Organiser, no, 248 October 17 1985 Page 9
Scan page 10
The debate, he said, signifies that Labour is serious about Ireland. Northern Ireland's future is now in the "key word' consent was missing from the "Troops Out' motion. But a socialist programme needs to include a complete and coherent set of
----- pull-quotes -----
Why? John O' Mahony reviews the Irish debate at Labour Party conference this year, and concludes that the campaign for the single slogan 'Troops Out' needs to be replaced by a broader agita-
strength in the last three or four years, the Troops Out current still