Labour and Troops Out
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
from page in the other direction. There will be no united Ireland without a united working class, or at any rate unity of the big majority of Protestant and Catholic workers.
Who else would unite the country so that the conditions for working class unity come into existence? The Trade Unionists for Irish Independence' are plain about it: Britain must 'hand over to the Irish government' ly put into words. ly put into words. Trish govern- There is more said here than is actualment there will, for a certainty, tolon- hands immediate and probably very bloody cIvil war between Catholic and Protestant Ireland. Nothing is more certain. After the Orange general strike, the developmeht of a mass UDA, etc. it is impossible to believe otherwise.
Humanitarian
Now the Trade Unionists for Irish Independence' want sectarian civil war just about as much as Sheena Clarke or I want it. What they in fact mean is that Britain should collaborate in coercing, bludgeoning, beating down and disarming the Protestants, as part of the withdrawal package.
In this they line up on one side of a long-standing Irish nationalist divide: with those who look to Britain to coerce the Orange population, against those who seek intra-Irish solutions.
Valerie Vaz from Ealing CLP seconded the composite.
The government, she said, refuses to have a dialogue with the people of Northern Ireland' because it alleges they are terrorists. Terrorists produce extreme fear, therefore - she came triumphantly to the point - Margaret Thatcher is the biggest terrorist. plastic She build the hip-searched by women and men prisoners. In Brixton we have seen the results of the policy of 'shoot first and ask questions later' People in Northern Ireland live with it every day. In the name of humanity we must begin the dialogue now.
Stuart Bell, MP for Middlesbrough and a front-bench spokesman on Northern Ireland, was first in the discussion.
face on Ireland and of the alternative between Troops Out and a united Since 1981, he said, Labour has been for a united Ireland - unity of hearts and minds of the people. Labour will create policies that will bring unitynot unity by way of the armalite but unity by way of bringing Northern Ireand into harmony with the South.
Labour doesn't want a united Ireland be hallenge of a united Ireland, work- hich is united in conflict. We take up Through a Labour government we rig it closer BE:
unde Socialist Organiser, no. 248 October 17 1985 Page 10 Protestant supremacy, and pledged that Labour will build on any progress made by the Tory government.
Next came Sarah Roelofs of Hornsey CLP. She told conference about the strip-searching of women in Armagh Jail, and of two Republican women in Brixton jail who are regularly body-searched. We need to discuss British withdrawal, she said, and have an end to censorship 'that prevents Party members discussing issues. Labour should 'end its collusion' on censorship. We want women's voices, black women's voices, and particularly Irish women's voices, to be heard'.
Listen to women for a change, she appealed to conference. This was the main emphasis of her speech: let some other people, your moral or intellectual superiors, make up your minds for you.
Roelofs' vacuous speech is significant because she is one of the most prominent and ubiquitous activists in the London Labour movement on Ireland, promoter of the 'dialogue' with Sinn Fein, and contributor of articles to London Labour Briefing The humanitarian element in the left's agitation — about strip-searching, plastic bullets, etc. - concerns real issues, but is demonstrably insufficient. You may well think body-searches unnecessary or wrong, and object to plastic bullets as dangerous and indiscriminate, without shifting to belief in Troops Out. For someone who believes in the civil war/bloodbath argument to be moved, their arguments have to be met. The humanitarian agitation will not do that. It might well be part of a general campaign on Ireland, but at present it often serves the left as a substitute for dealing with the issues.
The incoherence here is basic and ingrained. It shows how little the left has learned over the last 14 years. On two issues, the left has mushroomed, briefly - on the hunger strikes and on internment. There is still some continuing spin-off from the hunger strikes visible in the Labour Left. But still the response was very limited, and many roused to lodge a horror-stricken protest when the government allowed ten men to starve themselves to death didn't become convinced of the arguments for Troops Out.
Waverers Against internment there was a powerful movement in Britain - for a while. Nothing very much was gained from it. The movement had dissipated long long before internment ended. The reason was that in the final analysis liberal outrage could not answer the fundamental questions. And liberal outrage had a limited audience when the fundamental questions were nOt answered. Many people boog if the choice were between rah empty as Stuart Bell's.
mainstream of Labour policy, and the Tory government must face a debate.
Labour makes plain its belief that Ireland is one country. Labour will restore civil rights in Northern Ireland, ending no-jury courts, the informer system, strip-searching, etc. It will search for a further consensus in the movement.
Archer hoped women would take part.
Trade unionists in Northern Ireland have had to live with sectarian division and stagnation and cuts. They don't all agree about the sectarian issues, but all want jobs. The people of Ireland have waited too long for unity. But we need a way of achieving unity which does not deepen and widen the divisions. If we can heal the wounds and not make the existing wounds fester, then it is worth spending a little additional time on it.
He appealed to conference not to vote on the matter this year, but to wait for the report of the Labour Party working group on Ireland.
This was Militant-style economism grafted on to promises of a reforming Labour administration in Northern Ireland.
From the aspirant Labour Secretary of State for Northern Ireland and his would-be assistants this is not enough.
The question is: what will they do in Northern Ireland if Labour wins the next election? Will they continue to preside over the repression of the Catholic minority? Will they run the artificial Six County bearpit state? Good-sounding noises about a united Ireland somehow, some day, aren't enough from these people as they move towards government office.
Alex Kitson, deputy general secretary of the TGWU, summed up for the National Executive. It was a clownish speech, which nevertheless dealt devastating blows at the advocates Out.
Alex Kitson said it was an important debate. He noted that his own union had 100,000 members in Ireland, north and south. Paying tribute to the courage of the people of Northern Ireland, he said that many of those present did not understand what was involved because they had never been to Belfast. He himself visits Belfast regularly.
'We as a Labour Party have done everything we possibly could do to help. (At which point he was interrupted for three or four minutes by loud heckling). 'It's the trade unions that hold Northern Ireland together' he continued.
Having spent most of his time clowning like that, he then got to the point. He challenged delegates to go to Ireland and ask the people who live there about British withdrawal. "They'll tell you it won't work. It's a recipe for civil war between Protestant and Catholic communities which will not bring a united Ireland any nearer. Instead you will end up with an independent Protestant state and a helpless Catholic minority' The Irish Republic doesn't want British withdrawal either, he said - none of the three main parties does. The New Ireland Forum has said that unity can come only by way of 'freely negotiated and agreed arrangements' For us to say that we know better than in the Irish Republic, and • Fould have to live wi sequences, is not only stupia.
would be downright dangerous abour Party policy is for unity by cour sent, which presupposes greater working class unity in Northern Ireland. The No-one wants to give the Unionists a veto 'on political change • But you cannot unify Ireland by forcing one milpeople into what they see as a foreign country. They don't want it;
people in the south don't want it.
Geoff Bell's composite for Troops Out was 'overwhelmingly defeated' on a show of hands. The composite calling for an open debate in the Labour Party on withdrawal was lost on a card vote by 4,383,000 to 899,000.
I think the left lost the argument at this year's Labour Party conference.
Worse. With the partial exception of Geoff Bell, the left did not even seriously attempt to answer the arguments. The left could be used as a scarecrow to help the right and soft left establish that their position is reasonable, "humane' , and practical, and that their opponents are either fools who do not understand the implications of what we advocate, or blood-thirsty Catholic nationalists. That same soft-left and right who will assume the main responsibility as custodians of Northern Ireland and chief jailers of the Catholic minority if Labour wins the next election were able to win the argument.
Rearrangement
When you got right down to it, the lett didn't have answers to the questions raised against Troops Out. For immediate British withdrawal unaccompanied byarearrangement acceptabletothe Protestants and Catholics of N. Ireland and to the people of the south would lead to sectarian civil war and to two Irelands rather than a united Ireland. The weakness of the left at the conference was no accident: it flowed necessarily from the belief that Troops Out alone is a sufficient platform.
Troops Out alone has no power of persuasion in the labour movement. It immediately brings to mind the objections to Troops Out; it begs questions that "Troops Out' alone cannot answer; and thus the bare slogan inevitably reinforces the prejudices against Troops Out.
Troops Out is a purely negative position: it needs to be accompanied by positive answers to the questions raised by British withdrawal if it is to have any influence on people who do not already think that getting Britain out is itself the central goal, whatever the consequences for the people of Ireland.
At conference Sarah Roelofs represented the mindless romantic left - those for whom Ireland is a surrogate Cuba, part of the Third World. But Geoff Bell has written some useful works on Ireland. There is no doubt that for him Ireland is a place inhabited by real people and not the mere symbol it is for Roelofs. Yet both Geoff Bell and Sarah Roelofs failed to deal with the issues. Both of them could be utilised as a scarecrow by the soft left and the right.
The only viable programme for Ireland is one which argues for self-determination for Ireland as a whole and within that autonomy for the Protestant areas. The British labour movement should argue for that. It is the answer to the questions posed by "Troops Out' which "Troops Out' alone cannot answer.
Such a programme is not a miracle sulution - not a scheme which can be put as good advice to Thatcher and Fitzgerald to carry out. But it is a possble democratic programme for the British and Irish labour movements. Socialists should not be side-tracked by false realism' or get tied up in working out 'answers' for the present forces in a situation over which we have no control.
democratic demands, and a possibil ity of relating to the division and anguish NOW If we put self-determination for Ireland as a whole and autonomy for the Protestant areas alongside "Troops Out', does that amount to British chauvinism?
No. The humanitarian objections to the bare "Troops Out' slogan are reasonable objections. Since it is a fact that sectarian civil war in Northern Ireland would probably spill over into Glasgow, if not Liverpool, the British working class has a direct and immediate interest in avoiding it. The Irish nationalist notion that Britain has no right to intervene in the affairs of Ireland is necessarily qualified by the fact that one in five of the seople of Ireland define themselves as British. In any case, we should be inter nationalists, not any sort of nationalists.
Workers have a right and duty to try to "intervene" in the politics of every country.
British Labour has the right in collaboration with the Irish labour movement — to intervene in Northern Ireland. Only it should intervene with a democratic working-class programme, and not with the visage of a Roy Mason or a Merlyn Rees — or even a Peter Archer:
The British troops have no right to be in Ireland,and do no good there. At best they freeze and perpetuate the conditions for sectarian civil war, all the while carrying on their own simmering war against the Catholic minority. That the situation and the prospects now are so bleak is in large part Britain's work.
But we should stop using "Troops Out' as a sectarian ultimatum, and instead engage in a dialogue with those in Britain (and Ireland) who think they have good reasons against Troops Out.
We should try to convince them.
For that a merely negative point of view is not enough. As well as "Troops Out' we need a positive programme.
Lenin said it a long time ago:
"There is not, nor can there be, such a thing as a 'negative' Social-Democratic slogan that serves only to 'sharpen proletarian consciousness against imperialism' without at the same time offering a positive answer to the question of how [Marxists] will solve the problem wher [they] assume power. A 'negative' slog.
an unconnected with a definite positive solution will not 'sharpen', but dull consciousness, for such a slogan is a hollow phrase, mere shouting, meaningless declamation"
The argument goes back a long way.
In early 1969 some of us argued against the almost-exclusive concentration of the SWP (then IS) on "Troops Out' (until the troops went on the streets, in August 1969, and IS dropped the call in panic!)
We criticised the implied notion that the Catholic civil rights movement would organically 'grow over' into socialism; and argued for propaganda for the workers' republic.
In the mid-"70s we argued against the notion put forward by some on the left that a mass movement could be built in Britain on the single slogan "Troops Out'. It was not out of anti-imperialist 'purity' that we insisted that a movement in Britain must explicitly argue solidarity with the Republicans: it was because we believed a movement must give some positive answers, and none was clear from the slogan "Troops Out'!
Today Protestant leaders talk about armed resistance even to the promised Thatcher-Fitzgerald plan. The danger of sectarian civil war is a serious Issue.
To say that the Protestant bigots' militancy would collapse once Britain withdrew is wishful fantasy. To say "There's already a bloodbath' is an evasion. Simmering war with hundreds of casualties is different from all-out war with thousands - different not only in immediate human terms, but also in terms for the future possibilities of socialism or even democracy. And the other standard left answer, Revolutions always involve bloodshed' ', is worse. There is no comparison between the revolutionary violence of the working class against its exploiters, or of a subject nation against a conquering army, and the violence of two working-class communities slaughtering each other.
We should support Troops Out. But to give this call any political grip and substance we must couple it with tetan prope only c a solbie solution some given the present facts of the situation or anything resembling them is a united Ireland with federalism, i.e. an attempt to negotiate between sections of the Irish people and to conciliate the Protestants.