A milestone of the left's retreat
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Two studies recently — one by the Commission for Racial Equality and one by the Policy Studies Institute - have shown serious discrimination by employers preferring to give jobs to whites rather than to equally-qualified blacks.
Another recent set of figures sums up the result of this discrimination.
Among males with O levels, 9 per cent of whites are unemployed, 18% of Asians anc 25% of West Indians. 6% of whites with A levels, City & Guilds, ONCor OND are unemployed, but 22% of Asians and 10% of West Indians. -WI Understandably Roy chose to unveil his new insight not to a working class audience but to the Institute of Personnel Management.
The FT comments: "Mr Roy Hattersley finally scrambled aboard a fast-moving bus, the front seats of which are already occupied by Mrs Margaret Thatcher, and David Owen: wider share ownership...it is a sign that the political and economic differences of the parties amin differennac of the nartiec are perhaps not quite as great as sometimes pretended"
Vladimir Derer, secretar of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, presents his view of the Labour Party Conference. 1985 Annual Conference of the Labour Party may be viewed as just one more
milestone along the road of Labour Left's retreat. The Party's right wing leadership had almost everything its own way.
The sole exception was the resolution on women's reproductive rights, which Conference carried by a massive majority on a card vote, despite the National Executive Committee's recommendation to oppose. From now on Labour MPs who in the past voted for the White, Benyon, Corrie and Powell Bills will no longer be able to hide their opposition to Party policy behind conscience clauses. It remains to be seen, however, whether the Leadership is prepared to enforce Party discipline on this issue.
Opinion
True, the NUM resolution and the one on Gay & Lesbian Rights were also carried against the NEC's advice, unfortunately, however, by a less than two-thirds majority. This means that these Conference 'decisions' amount to little more than an expression of opinion.
The same is true of the composite resolution on local government which proposed "to fully compensate those representatives of the Labour movement who have suffered personal loss, bankruptcy, disqualification" as a result of non-compliance with the rate-capping and clawback legislation. This resolution was singled out by Neil Kinnock as "the one which got away" despite the fact that it was previously earmarked by him to be shot down. It was carried 'overwhelmingly' on a show of hands, but there was no card vote.
Hence the decision need not be included in the next Party Programme.
None of these demands will go into the Party Programme, let alone the Manifesto. In other words, even here the Party's right wing managed to hold the line and the Left won no more than a small consolation prize.
On all other issues where Conference divided on the Right/Left lines, the Left was routed. The most important setbacks were on Economic Policy and Reselection.
On Economic Policy Conference approved the recent NEC document, 'A New Partnership, A New Britain', which provides a totally inadequate basis for a genuine 'alternative strategy' by blandly substituting vague talk about increasing "the involvement of working people in taking key decisions" for a definite commitment to a significant extension of public ownership in key sectors of the economy.
It is clear that years of waffle about "workers control" and "old style nationalisation" have at last borne fruit. The resolution which demanded the taking into public ownership of 25 of the top manufacturing companies, a demand which featured in the Party's 1973 Programme and was carried by Conference only three yars ago, was this time defeated with the NEC recommending opposition.
On Reselection, the resolution which asked that any changes in the present reselection procedure should not be introduced before the next general election was declared, by the Chair, defeated on a show of hands. All calls for a card vote were defeated.
Some been taken in by the NEC's assurances that the issue will not come before Conference next year. The NEC's record on assurances is such, however, as to make it highly probable that it will introduce its proposals for an alleged extension of franchise next year. Even the modest form of accountability provided for under the existing procedures for mandatory reselection have been a thorn in the PLP's and Leadership's flesh even since it was first introduced in 1980.
Last year the NEC failed to get through Conference its proposal for an optional extension of the franchise in parliamentary selections. It is obviously counting on a pre-election change in the climate of opinion within the Party to enable it to push through proposals which would do away with any meaningful form of accountability.
Ditch
Such changes are, of course, essential if the next Labour government is to be free to ditch with impunity even the present, much diluted, version of Labour's aims promised in the current NEC's statements.
ponse to it, was a suitable corollary to these developments. The public attack by Neil Kinnock on the NUM leadership and on Liverpool's Labour administration make it clear that this is part of the parliamentary leadership's strategy to crush the Left within the Party by appealing over the heads of Party members to the electorate at large. (Perhaps this is the extra-parliamentary action Kinnock's sidekicks on the Labour Coordinating Committee have been fantasising about).
The welcome these moves have received in the bourgeois media makes further comment unnecessary. It is clear, however, that the last pretence of loyalty to fellow Party members has been thrown overboard.
This is not to suggest that criticism of what is regarded as tactical mistakes should be suspended. | Criticism, however, should be advanced through Party channels only. When fellow members of the Party are under attack by Labour's enemies, that is the time to close ranks, not to deepen divisions.
The idea that the watering down of the Party's socialist commitment and marginalising Left is going to improve Labour's electoral prospects is a delusion. When presented with the choice between two social democratic parties the electors will choose the genuine article.
Conclusions
What conclusions should the Left draw from the above developments? The first is that the strategy it adopted after Labour's defeat in the 1979 General Election was based on an erroneous assessment of the situation. Until 1981 the Left was a major influence on Party policy and, within the Party, it occupied a commanding position. It lost it because it failed to appreciate that when Labour is in opposition, and above all when it is confronted with determined opponent, the question of Party unity is paramount, even though it must sometimes involve a measure of compromise'.
Some aims have to be temporarily abandoned if others are still to be effectively pursued.
Even after 1981 the Left could still have advanced in a number of directions, had its objectives been integrated within the framework of Party unity. Fail.
ure to adopt this strategy meant that the field was left clear for the conditions of Party unity to be dictated by the Right wing. If the forward march of reaction is to be halted, then the at present dispersed and margi nalised forces of the Left mus learn to work together.
As a beginning they shoul cooperate at least on issues or which there is agreement. In thi longer run, however, such WILLIE cooperation will succeed only if strategies adopted are appropriate to the requirements of a given situation. Cooperation must therefore go hand in hand with a critique of the assumptions on which the politics of the various Left groups rest.
----- pull-quotes -----
HAU aheballwea AD UI BBISHE
The Party Leader's interven- tion, and the delegates' res-