Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The knives out

Socialist Organiser no. 249, 24 October 1985 · scan p. 5 · about 1,315 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Fowler reviews Stan Crooke looks at the Fowler Reviews, what they mean and how to fight them Birmingham and Oxford DHSS workers struck for better staffing. Photo: John Harris. s in supplementary benefit THE findings of the Fowler Review Teams, set up in 1983-4 by Tory Secretary of State for Social Services Norman Fowler to examine the Social Security system, were published as a government Green Paper on 3 June this year.

The proposals put forward in the Green Paper would cut the social security budget by f1 billion a year. A White Paper with more definite proposals for legislation is due in November.

According to Labour MP Gordon Brown, the Green Paper proposals would mean the following cuts: • 600,000 households would lose Supplementary Benefit (to be renamed Income Support), and two million more would have their money cut. Total cut: £180 million.

• 20,000 households on Family Income Supplement (to be renamed Family Credits) would lose benefit altogether. Another 100,000 would lose £5 a week.

• Widows would lose £15 million in the first year, rising to £100 million later.

• 1.8 million families would lose all housing benefit, and another 5.2 million would have their money cut. Total cut: some £500 million.

Social spending in Britain is already lower as a proportion of national income than in other West European countries, including Italy and Ireland. Since 1979 the Tories have cut £9 billion from the social security budget, and handed out £13 billion in tax cuts, mainly to the wealthy.

These attacks on the worst-off sections of society are not dictated only by blind class hatred on the part of the Tories. They fit into the Tories' whole strategy to try to solve the crisis of British capitalism at the expense of the working class.

Capitalists are not making big enough profits. To help increase profits, the Tories try to cut state expenditure, a major item of which is the social security budget.

Denis Healey, under the last Labour government, had already made Britain's rate of tax on businesses one of the lowest in the capitalist world. The Tories have cut taxes further for the rich.

Cuts in social security are also designed to push down wages. All other things being equal, raising profits means cutting wages.

The submission from the Institute of Directors to the Fowler Review Teams was quite open about this. "The problem is that supplementary benefit has been extremely generous... The problem is not that low pay is too low... but rather that supplementary benefit has been too high"

Leading monetarist academic Patrick Minford claims that "the key ingredient that stops wages moving down is the unemployment and supplementary benefit level"

Lord Young, now Employment Minister, argues that •The level of benefit for young people can act as a disincentive.. for boys and girls there should ideally be... no benefit at all" . And Fowler himself says that his reform of Family Income Supplement will "prevent families in nearly all circumstances from facing a position in which there is little or no financial benefit to be gained from continuing in lower-paid jobs"

Cuts in social security also have an important role in the ideology of the Tories and the self-styled new Moral Right, with its emphasis on the importance of the "family unit' and its attempts to force women back into the home.

Campaign

The Institute of Directors submission to the Reviews says that "child benefit should be reduced; it weakens the tamily by replacing parental provision with state provision' . Social security cutbacks will force women into the role allotted to them by the New Right - an unpaid workforce caring for the young, the elderly, the sick and the disabled.

All in all, the Tories reckon that social security cuts will have a bracing, disciplining effect on the lower orders. As one journalist reports, "Those closest to Ms Thatcher believe the current concerns about unemployment and poverty are grossly exaggerated for partisan purposes. One report that has much struck her recently is that the unemployed are said to spend £9 a week on beer"

DECEN WERE G FOR YOU A Cut EIGHT million people in Britain - one in seven — now depend on supplementary benefit. Another 1.4 million are entitled to it but do not claim it.

The Reviews propose that supplementary benefit be renamed Income Support and claimants be categorised into four different 'client groups': unemployed; single parents; sick and disabled; aged over 60 years old.

The unemployed will receive the Income Support basic personal allowance except that those under 25 will be paid at a lower rate on the grounds that they are not fully independent). The three other categories will receive the basic personal allowance plus a special premium.

Meanwhile, all extra payments will be abolished.

62% of claimants receive an AR ('additional requirements') payment for, e.g., heating, diet, laundry, etc., of some kind. In December 1982, 87,000 claimsociety CLE ants received ARs of £7 or more per week. Some disabled claimants receive ARs of up to £30 or £40 per week. 90% of pensioners receive ARs.

ARs will be completely scrapped.

The number of SPs - one-off "single payments' for such things as bedding, furniture, removal expenses, etc. - has grown from 0.8 million in 1981 to three million in 1984. In 1983, nearly two million SPs were made, at an average amount of £75.64. These give the supplementary benefit system some limited flexibility to respond to need. Under Fowler's scheme, need won't count.

SPs will be replaced by loans from a new Social Fund' administered on a discretionary basis by the iocal DHSS office management.

Those most in need will suffer most: they are the most dependent on AR and SPs, and will therefore suffer the largest drop in living standards as a result of their abolition.

There will be Limit (i.e. the amount of savings a claimant can possess before s/he is denied benefit) of £6,000. Now it is £3,000. But weekly benefits will be cut by 40p for every £100 of savings between £3,000 and £6,000.

The earnings disregard (i.e. the amount a claimant can earn each week before it is deducted from his/her benefits) is also to be increased from £4 to £5, with certain categories of claimants being entitled to an earnings disregard of £15.

A racist new length-of-residence limit will be introduced: "the claimant will need to have been present in the country for a come Support, qualify for InThe Social Fund will be the only element of flexibility in response to need — to cope with *the exceptional circumstances and emergencies faced by a minority of claimants". It will be administered by the local DHSS office. Payments out of the fund will be on a discretionary basis, and most payments will be in the form of recoverable loans. The Social Fund will have a fixed, cash-limited annual budget.

The idea of any entitlement to extra money is to be scrapped, almost entirely, in favour of 'discretion' In practice, this will mean more means-testing and a lower take-up rate. (Only 50% of those entitled to means-tested Family Income Supplement, for example, actually receive it. About Il billion of benetits goes unclaimed each year).

There will be no appeal beyond the local office where the original decision was taken. One of the objections contained in the Green Paper to the current method of making single payments is that the rate of appeal is too high. (In fact, it is now 21%, as against 45% in 1976).

The decision to create a Social Fund has clearly been influenced by the American system of public assistance, which is predominantly discretionary, administered at local level and often made conditional on changes in the behaviour of claimants.

Socialist Organiser no. 249 October

----- pull-quotes -----

MORE STAFF NOW

NOW DECEMBER 3rd WE'RE ON STRIKE FOR YOUR BENEAT society

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 249

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →