Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Caused by capitalism

Socialist Organiser no. 249, 24 October 1985 · scan p. 7 · about 1,184 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

down the poor should therefore be based on investment for retirement, not a promissory note to be presented to a future generation".

"The full long-term costs of SERPS", says Fowler, "cannot prudently be afforded". He bases his argument on the assumption that average future economic growth will be 1½% per how many children to have.

"Why should someone who consciously decided not to have children be expected to pay for others who decide to have a particular number of children"

Shenfield is a member of the right-wing Adam Smith Institute and co-author of its pamphlet calling for health cuts. In its submission to the Fowler Reviews the Adam Smith Institute called for privatisation of social security benefits.

Even if a serious review of the social security system had been desired (which it wasn't), other aspects of the procedure of the Fowler Reviews ensured that would not be it.

The piecemeal approach of the reviews — they were established at different times, staggered between November 1983 and April 1984, and each was limited to a few particular aspects of the social security system - guaranteed that no overall assessment could be made of the system as a whole.

And the Housing Benefit Review team, for example, was "not concerned with general housing policy issues... or with income tax relief on mortgage repayments"

None of the Reviews considered reform of taxation. The whole exercise was set up so as to on finding the cheapest giving paupers a pitrestrain them from eft, rather than on g of the whole tax/ THE TUC has called a demonstration against the Fowler Reviews; Labour leaders have promised that the next Labour government will reverse Fowler's cuts and have called for support for local anti-Fowler activity.

But the official labour movement has so far done very little in the way of organised day-to-day campaigning.

At local level this has often created a vacuum filled by social workers, welfare rights officers, community workers, community development officers and so on, who have organised street corner leafleting, petitions, and public meetings.

Campaigns against the Fowler Reviews have thus often been not very political or orientated to the labour movement. Vague appeals to 'public opinion' are preferred to serious efforts to mobilise the labour movement against the cutbacks.

Substitute

But this is a class issue.

Street theatre and song-anddance routines may help build a labour movement based campaign, but they are no substitute for it. Strikes will be needed to stop the Tories.

And not just strikes by the civil services unions — but strikes by the trade union movement as a whole.

Since any strike against the Fowler Reviews will be political and thus in breach of Tory anti-union laws, such strikes will also raise the broader question of trade union opposition to and defiance of the anti-union laws.

The campaign against the Fowler Review is not exclusively a trade-union one. It must also involve all levels of the Labour Party. The Parliamentary Labour Party should commit itself to campaign of parliamentary obstruction at Westminster and consistent campaigning outside Parliament.

Labour-controlled local authorities should also provide full benefit system to redistribute income - let alone on what makes the initial market distribution of income so unequal.

Submissions from outside bodies were invited by the Review teams, but made difficult by the timescales.

Even the Confederation of British Industry, hardly the claimant's best friend, decided not to submit any evidence to the Fowler Reviews due to the short time-scales, and instead wrote to Fowler suggesting that no short-term changes be made until after a more thorough examination of all the issues involved.

The hearings of the Review teams certainly did not amount to a 'great debate' People who made submissions often got short shrift.

At one hearing of the children's and young people's Review team, a Tory MP who suggested that taxes might be raised to pay for higher benefits was cut off in mid-sentence and told: "I wonder if you could stop there, unless you actually want to sum up the rest of what you are saying in something like two sentences... You have been speaking for 7½ minutes by Greenwich Mean The Reviews did not call any claimants to give evidence; they did not commission any research; and they have produced no official summary of the evidence submitted to them. support, both financially and through opening up their facilities to local anti-Fowler campaigns, with no strings attached.

The tact that social security attracted more resolutions than any other issue at this. year's Labour Party conference indicates the potential for mobilising the Party membership.

The basis for campaigning against the Fowler Reviews is the network of local groups which already exists throughout the country, roughly comparable to the network of miners' solidarity groups during the strike and often including the same people.

Central

Operating on the basis of class politics and a labour movement orientation, such local groups can play a central role in winning working-class mobilisation against the Fowler Reviews.

But to campaign only against the proposals of the Fowler Reviews is insufficient. We must also campaign for an alternative.

But the question 'what kind of social security' begs the question 'what kind of society'. Most aspects of social security assume the existence of poverty, unemployment, and low wages, and try to moderate them.

So long as capitalism exists, of course we have to fight for better ways of moderating its effects — improved rates of benefit, abolition of means-testing, etc. - but the problem is how te combine the fight for better social security with the fight to overthrow capitalism.

So we need a series of transitional demands which combine Photo: Steve Bell the defence and improvement of claimants' rights and benefits with an attack on the power structures of capitalism.

We must fight for abolition of means-testing and more staff in DHSS offices - but also to abolish the whole hierarchical and non-accountable management structure of the DHSS, replacing it with joint claimants— trade unionists' control and management.

We must campaign for better benefits - but also for higher wages, through the establishment of a national minimum wage and automatic wage rises in line with a working-class cost of living index determined by bodies involving consumers, trade unionists, and claimants. Benefits should also be indexlinked.

Abolish

Higher rates of benefit for the unemployment would be a major step forward, but we should also fight to abolish the need for unemployment benefit (save for transition periods between jobs) through abolishing unemployment: cutting working hours, but not wages; nationalising all firms threatening closure and putting them under workers' control; retraining at trade union rates.

The entire philosophy which underpins the social security system — one which blames the poor for being poor and discriminates in particular against women and black people must be challenged. But to challenge that is to challenge the philosophy of capitalism itself. Benefit Retirement pension Supplementary benefi Child benefit Invalidity benefit Housing benefit * Unemployment benefit Widows' benefit Family income supplement * Not including rate rebates Figures for 1985-6.

Number of Cost receiving it thousands)

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 249

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →