Pacifism and Leon Trotsk
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Leftists who normally respect Trotsky — if not the bulk of his followers — as a socialist thinker (whatever we may feel about his record in power, his centrist failure to provide any real opposition to Stalinism in the late twenties and the limitations of his analysis of Stalinism for the rest of his life) will have been surprised that you chose to reprint one of Trotsky's less intelligent socialist-theoretical pieces, "Pacifism and War".
Neither Woodrow Wilson nor William Jennings Bryan ever had anything to do with the pacifist movement. The said movement did not support the League of Nations though there was an overlap in the mid- and late Thirties between the League of Nations Union and the less committed fringes of pacifism, just as there is now an overlap between the United Nations Association and the less-committedly-unilateralist fringes of CND.
No pacifist has ever accepted the "deterrence" theory of pacifism — "the general opinion in petit bourgeois circles began gradually to behold in the growth of armies a guarantee of peace" - indeed this attitude attributed to pacifism is the standard basis of establishment anti-pacifist argument, and was so before 1917. Nor has any pacifist accepted the view of imperialism described.
Leon Trotsky In an article singularly devoid of hard factual evidence, of reference to sources and quotations, of any real Marxist perceptions, both the spokesmen and the attitudes attributed to pacifists are in fact those of their opponents.
The fact that since this Trotsky's epigoni have chosen to define pacificists by the misconceptions of their tounder means that they have resorted to a level of debate no less dishonest than that which has characterised Stalinist attacks on Trotskyists.
While Trotskyists use one set of libeis they can hardly complain of the other.
Fraternally, LAURENS OTTER BELEAGUERED Nicaragua, facing a renewed build-up of US aggression, has reimposed a State of Emergency.
The government has taken sweeping powers of arbitrary arrest, detention and investigation. The right of habeas corpus has been suspended, along with the right of appeal to the Supreme Court.
So have constitutional rights to freedom of assembly and expression - and the right to organise workers and to strike.
The ruling Sandinistas claim that the State of Emergency is in response to "new and more dangerous acts of aggression" by the US, acting through. "agents of imperialism" within Nicaragua. A new offensive by the US-backed 'contras' is being planned.
Agents of imperialism are certainly at work against Nicaragua, in and around the country. And the majority of the country's people are determined to defend the gains of the revolution which overthrew the hideous Somoza dictatorship in 1979.
But the new laws are not aimed only, or mainly, at the 'contras' and their helpers. Undoubtedly progressive oppositionists will suffer too, including working-class militants whose actions may be considered 'damaging to national security' Reagan's criticism of the new laws is sheer hypocrisy: and we must redouble our efforts to defend Nicaragua from US imperialism.
But at the same time we should call for a restoration of democratic rights and for full freedoms for Nicaraguan workers.