Ireland after Britain
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
COND UDA paramilitary: how can socialists win away Protestant workers from the bigots who would turn Ireland After Britain' into a scene of bloody red by Sociainst Orge Number 2 March/April 1985 SOCIALIST FORUM no.2 contains Socialist Organiser's case for a federal united Ireland. Now reprinting: 50p plus postage from 214 • Socialist. Organiser no. 249 October 24 1985. Page 9 Stan Crooke reviews Ireland After Britain, edited by Martin Collins (Pluto Press in association with 'Labour and IRELAND After Britain" was publicly launched at the Labour Committee on Ireland fringe meeting at this year's Labour Party conference.
The title suggests that the book might address the real and crucial problem: given the fact that British troops in Northern Ireland have no right to be there and do no good, how to make British withdrawal lead to a united Ireland rather than to disaster - a Protestant drive for an 'independent Ulster', full-scale bloody civil war (which the Orangeists will win), population movements, repartition and the permanent division ot Ireland into two states, Orange and Socialist Organiser has argued that the British and Irish labour movements must fight for a democratic programme including self-determination for the Irish people as a whole (all 32 counties) and regional autonomy within that for the mainlyProtestant areas.
Alternatives
Alternative suggestions to deal with the problem could be valuable. Unfortunately the book doesn't have any.
Some of the essays in it are valuable but about quite other questions than Ireland after Britain'. • Sarah Spencer, for example, describes the recent undermining of civil rights in Northern Ireland and Britain, but stresses that she does not intend "to propose political solutions or be identified with any particular approach"
Euro-MP Christine Crawley describes her childhood, her views on the Common Market, and her strong belief that there must be a united Ireland" but has as little to say about the nature of that united Ireland as Aine nic Murcada in her articSickert Court, London N1 2SY.
le on the Irish cultural revival, or Sylvia Meehan in her piece on *As for the future, it will to be sorted out in the future of time" , explains Sean Redmond, former Stalinist and now general secretary of the Irish Municipal Employees' Trade Union. Tony Benn (who elsewhere has suggested that UN troops could replace British forces) foresees an "endless scope for skill in constitution-drawing [after British withdrawal] around what the exact relationships would be, whether there would be a federal, bi-polar or unitary legal system and so on"
Danny Morrison of Sinn Fein likewise: "There are people within the movement who say we must be definitive about a blueprint for a future Ireland. I don't think you can predict that, and I would probably be against trying... It is a nonsense to start defining in detail what we want"
(It would indeed be nonsense for people in Britain to start proposing details for a future Ireland. It is a worse nonsense for Sinn Fein/the IRA, who are the centre of Northern Ireland affairs, not to sketch out at least a coherent outline).
So the book actually says little about Ireland After Britain'. It does not even do much to clarify the mechanics of British withdrawal.
Clive Soley, in one of the more serious essays, puts forward "united Ireland by consent" but gives no indication of how he would ensure that this was any more than a formula for a British Labour government to mouth democratic phrases while continuing - in deference to Orange opinion — to act as jailer and gauleiter over the Six County Catholics.
Danny Morrison clearly wants the British Army to disarm the Royal Ulster Constabulary and the Ulster Defence Regiment (a local part-time force, almost exclusively Protestant, which is part of the British Army) as it withdraws, but the book's editor Martin Collins contemptuously dismisses this idea.
*The army, quite frankly, are more likely to mutiny or desert to the side of the Loyalists than disarm them.
Many of the book's contributors stress that Protestants should have nothing to fear from a united Ireland. "They would have the same rights as everyone else", writes Gerry Adams, *a republican government or even Irish nationalist parties would have to be at pains to assure the Loyalists of their civil and religious rights".
Intentions
The good intentions are not very reassuring, because the 26 County state is a Catholic confessional state in much of its legislation. In line with the teaching of the Catholic Church, it forbids the exercise of such civil rights as divorce and abortion which are now enjoyed in the UK Danny Morrison agrees with Adams but explains Sinn Fein's decision to drop the idea of a federal Ireland. From 1972 through to the early '80s they had this policy (in a different form from the way SO would argue it), but Morrison argues that it "began to look like a sop to the Loyalists. It looked too much like something which had been grafted onto the republican programme in order to try and buy the Loyalists off... A school of thought began to grow which opposed making compromises with Loyalism and was in favour of beginning to describe the struggle in different terms"
Morrison argues that Protestants will benefit from a united Ireland but it is a waste of time trying to persuade them of this now. "There is nothing we can do to convince them and I think it is pointless to waste energy in trying... It is only breaking the political will of the British to remain in Ireland that will affect the Loyalist community"
Essentially, the Provisionals' perspective relies on forcing Britain to break the Protestants' will and coerce them into a united Ireland. Once coerced, and deprived forever of British backing, the Protestants will - so the argument runs - become quickly reconciled. They will have equal rights and will benefit from the economic advantages of a united Ireland.
Provisionals
The Provisionals' perspective makes some sense from the point of view of a nationalism based on the Catholic community - though even from that point of view it must be criticised as underestimating the strength of Protestant communalism. From a working-class socialist point of view it has a worse fault. It writes off Protestant/Catholic workers' unity as utterly impossible, and thus probably also rules out even North-South unity of Catholic workers - for the Southern workers will not join a Catholic workers' united front to coerce the Protestant proletariat.
The editor of the book, Martin civil war and repartition? Photo: Camerawork. Collins, is a writer for Socialist Action. Yet his contribution does not offer any socialist alternative. On the contrary: he takes the Catholic-community-based nationalism of Adams and Morrison, chops out the seriousness which it has in its own terms -its effort to grasp the real problems and define answers - and presents the gutted remnants, in a sauce of fantasy, as a process of socialist revolution.
All problems, argues Collins, will be swept aside in an irresistible march to a socialist Ireland — made, apparently, not by the actual Irish working class (even Collins must be aware that the Six County Catholics include only about 10% of that working class), but by some Force of History high above us.
Collins cites Fidel Castro as someone who "did not set out with the aim of socialist revolution" but expropriated the capitalists as a pragmatic response to the threats of imperialism and internal counter-revolution.
The same process is even more likely to occur in Ireland: "Gerry Adams and his Sinn Fein comrades do not have to descend from the Sierra Maestra unsure of their reception by urban workers; the roots of the republican movement are deep in the nationalist ghettoes. The demographic profile... creates a unique social dynamism which is the raw material of which such revolutions are made"
The Protestant majority of the Northern workers? Evidently they have disappeared. Meanwhile the 'dynamism' will send mortal shock waves through imperialist Britain. British withdrawal "would have an effect in British politics which will make the 'mould-breaking' formation seem paltry by comparison"
Nationalist
Expanding upon his theory that "there has been no significant political recomposition of the working class without the stimulating drive of a political crisis caused by Irish rebellion", Collins looks forward to a "reopening with added vigour of the nationalist dynamic in the working class of Scotland and Wales" , and a wholesale transformation of the labour movement.
*The weakening of the integr ation of Loyalist trade unionists from the north of Ireland -consistently the most ardent supporters of the trade unions' 'John Bull' past - and the alternative social models thrown up in the process of forging a new Ireland will act as a powerful stimulus". . The Protestant workers play a role after all! Their removal from British-based trade unions (how?) will radicalise those unions...
And in place of stodgy Labourism, Collins looks forward to a crackpot version in Britain of Jesse Jackson's 'rainbow coalition': "an alliance around Labour of women, of peace cam- an alliance that could recompose the leadership of the working class and present itself as a genuinely new alternative"
The book Ireland After Britain' is apparently an attempt at a literary prefiguration of this alliance of social groups.
Around Adams, Morrison and Murcada, Collins seeks to rally women (O'Hare, Meehan, Robinson), peace campaigners (McBride, Sadlear), trade unionists (Redmond, Merrigan), and the Labour Left (Crawley, Benn, and, scraping the barrel, Ken Livingstone). It is a sort of literary version of the Congresses against Imperialism, Fascism and War which the Stalinists used to organise in the 1930s.
In his preface, Collins describes the book as a 'dialogue' with Sinn Fein. More like an interchange between Long John Silver and the parrot perched on his shoulder.