Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

South Africa in 3D

Socialist Organiser no. 249, 24 October 1985 · scan p. 10 · Martin Thomas · about 750 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The South African author Alex La Guma died in Cuba on Friday 11 October, aged 60. He was a political activist - a 100% Stalinist, son of the pioneer Communist and nationalist James La Guma, and a member of the South African Communist Party since his youth — and also a fine writer.

He was prominent in organising the 'Congress of the People' in 1955 which adopted the Freedom Charter, and was jailed and put under house arrest several times. He left South Africa in 1966, moving first to London and then to Cuba.

The most famous South African authors are whites -Naomi Gordimer, Dan Jacobson. They write as committed anti-racists, yet there is (it seems to me) a curious one-dimensionality in their books. The nuances, blindnesses, inhumanities of white South African psychology, both die-hard and liberal, are portrayed in the round; yet the black characters in the fiction tend to be curiously blank.

Pretence The authors are well aware of this. They know well that the servile 'Yes baas', , the deliberate pretence of naivety and stupidity, or the brutality and crime or wild revolt, are the masks adopted by an oppressed people to protect its humanity against the oppressors; they know that beneat those masks there is thought, anguish, debate about a struggle for a new society and new relations between people.

Yet their social position makes it difficult for them to portray the psychology of black revolt from the inside.

Black South African authors, Alex La Guma foremost among them, do not have the converse one-dimensionality.

They portray 'from the inside' a vast variety of black attitudes - self-destructive or submissive despair; uncontrolled fury; fear and weakness; courage and patient struggle - and their interactions.

La Guma's "The Stone Country, for example, portrays without idealisation a varied group of prisoners in Cape Town jail. From black South African fiction a reader can also get an impression of different cultures making up black South African society - the ghettoes of Soweto, the black farm labourers' compounds, the desolation of the bantustans, the cosmopolitan society of the 'Cape Coloureds' But the authors can also depict white attitudes, not as a blank exterior, but as a human response to circumstances.

Take La Guma's 1979 novel "Time of the Butcherbird'. Shilling Murile is a young African just out of jail, coldly intent on individual revenge — to assassinate Hannes Meulen, the Afrikaner farmer who killed his brother and got Shilling sent to jail. Hlangeni is the chief of Shilling's clan, about to be forcibly resettled under the white government's bantustan policy: he speaks for submission. MmaTau, Hlangeni's sister, is an ANC militant: she rallies the clan to resist collectively. The shepherd Madonele would; left to himself, go along with Hlangeni, but rallies to the majority swayed by Mma-Tau. Cleaning for the very rich But not only these characters and the relations between them are portrayed sensitively. La Guma also shows us the world from the point of view of Edgar Stopes - an English-speaking salesman who feels himself superior to the crudeness of the rural Afrikaners yet is utterly racist - and of his wife Maisie:

Category In one passage of 'In the Fog of the Seasons' End' (1972) La Guma even depicts with some vividness the thoughts and interactions of white policemen. The one category whom no-one seems to be able to depict as more than brutes (or maybe it just seems not worth the effort to do so) is the black police and petty officials, who figure in some black South African stories and novels as more immediately feared oppressors than the relatively remote whites.

La Guma's politics do colour his novels, those I've read at least, 'In the Fog of the Seasons' End' is about a militant, Beukes, moving among the 'Coloured' community of Cape Town (from which La Guma himself came) to organise illegal leafleting to coincide with ANC sabotage attacks. Beukes risks his life and freedom to get leaflets distributed in factories hailing the military actions of the exile ANC, but apparently does not think of doing leaflets about workers' conditions and demands.

Yet here again La Guma portrays human responses vividly - the heroic (but not plasteridol) Beukes and his comrade Elias, the scared Bennett, the sympathetic but cheerfully nonpolitical Tommy, the worn-out Flotman.

"A Walk in the Night', 'And a threefold Cord', ', The Stone in Seasons End he Fee Tim the the Butcherbird' are available in Heinemann paperback (the African Writers series).

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 249

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →