How to Build Sol Darity
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
opposes direct links and looks More S. Africa, page 5.
the chains THE demonstration in London on 2 November called by the Anti-Apartheid Movement can be the springboard for a mass solidarity movement.
But what kind of solidarity movement? What forms of solidarity action are best?
The Anti-Apartheid Movement's main drive is to pressurise governments to impose sanctions on South Africa. This campaign, like pickets of Barclays Bank and other companies with investments in South Africa, does a lot to raise awareness of South Africa and of British capitalism's links with apartheid, But there are two problems. So long as capitalism remains capitalism, and South Africa remains profitable, capitalists will find ways to invest in and trade with South Africa. They will confine sanctions to token measures.
Socialist Organiser Lonc public meeting Workers Against Apartheid Speaker: Bob Fine, just back from South Africa.
Sunday 3 November, 7.30 at the Cock Tavern, Phoenix Road, Euston.
British bosses make huge profits out of black workers in South Africa. . 1200 out of 2000-odd multinationals in South Africa are British. Sanctions would damage their profits; and so the British government will take no serious action.
And more. Suppose the sanctions campaign were more successful. Multinationals based in South Africa would sell out to South African capitalists: South Africa's trade would face difficulties.
This would put the South African government in trouble. But it would not positively help any particular alternative in South Africa. It could push the South African ruling class into doing something - but the result would not be real liberation, or even necessarily much improvement on the present situation.
Direct action by workers to boycott south African trade is more effective than pressure on governments - and it can give a particular boost to workers and a working-class alternative in South Africa.
Boycotts are not the only form of working-class solidarity action. Workers in Britain can make direct contact with South African workers - exchange material, swap views, organise speaking tours, raise money for strikers and so on -especially in British companies that operate in South Africa.
British and South African shop stewards can be linked through multinational combine committees. If such direct links are built, then boycotts and other industrial solidarity can be tied to specific The cott of model. refuse from or Neil stress WHY NOT RECOGNISE AHEM! EXCEPT CUDDLY LITTLE RAMBOTHA THE A N. C.?..
WE HAVE A CONSISTENT POLICY OF NOT RECOGNISING ORGANISATIONS ENGAGED, iN ACTS OF VIOLENCE demands coming from the black ANC as the only resistance moveworkers in South Africa - trade ment in South Africa: it therefore and conditions, an end to discrimination, repeal of various apartheid laws.
Direct links between women's NORKERS organisations, student unions, socialist groups, etc., in Britain LIBERTY and in South Africa can also help give positive solidarity to the fight for liberation rather than just negative solidarity against the Botha regime.
Model Scandinavian unions' boySouth African trade is a British unions should to touch goods coming going to South Africa.
Kinnock has placed great on his anti-apartheid commitment, embracing HING ANC leader Oliver Tambo at this year's Labour Party conference. The Labour Party should campaign against apartheid, locally and nationally.
Unfortunately, the Anti-Apartheid Movement falsely sees the an adjunct to the ANC's diplomatic strategy.
The ANC is certainly an important part of the movement in South Africa. But only part.
For the ANC, the objective of the struggle now is a democratic revolution by all classes combined. The workers' fight for socialism is put off to a later 'stage'.
But the class struggle is afready taking place. Black workers are fighting now for their distinct interests as working-class men and women - for a decent life, for social equality, for control at work. This class struggle is inextricably bound up with the struggle for democracy: indeed it is the living core of it.
The first issue of Workers* Liberty magazine is a special issue on S.Africa. 75p plus postage from 214 Sickert Court; London N1 2SY
Scan page 4
WRP expels Subscribe To: Socialist Organiser, 214 Sickert Court, London N1 2sV Please send me. months sub. t enclose Ent aust Organiser no.250 31 October 1985 Page 4 nside the Left IF YOU live long enough you see everything! After over three decades as the unchallengeable - Ayatollah of the organisation - now known as the Workers' Revolutionary Party, Mr Gerry Healy has been thrown out in a coup organised by his protege and long-time pupil Mike Banda, the WRP general secretary.
13 of Healy's supporters on the party's Central Committee have also been expelled, including Alex Mitchell and Vanessa and Corin Redgrave. (They seem to have had the majority on the smaller Political Committee which actually ran the Ms Redgrave — who brought a libel case against Socialist : Organiser on behalf of Healy and Banda in 1981 for what we - said about the WRP's methods and regime - has now turned • her lawyers loose on Banda. She the WRP's general secretary and seven of his factional allies for the return of property she says is hers.
Last weekend an emergency WRP conference endorsed Healy's expulsion and decided to re-register' the party -which means purging everyone considered undesirable by the Bandaites.
A sizeable chunk of the promiment 'Newsline' writers, people with lots of money in the bank, and other WRPleaders, are with Healy, though the Bandaites control the press and 'Newsline' . This is a split down the middle of the WRP, not just the lopping off of the old godfather.
It first became public knowledge that the WRP was in serious crisis when the Newsline failed to appear for nearly two weeks in mid-October. It reappeared on 23 October with a front page headlined 'Gerry Healy expelled' and an 'Interim Statement by the WRP Central Committee'. . Since then Newsline has published two statements of the so-called International Committee of the Fourth International, a shadowy and semi-fictional International of small clone-groups gathered around the WRP. For reasons so far obscure - but which probably concern Banda's need to have a source of authority against Healy and the majority of the old Political Committee much is being made of the ICFI.
Insofar as can be established from the public statements of the Bandaites, there are political questions at issue between the two sides. The Bandaites accuse Healy of having become "almost entirely preoccupied with developing unprincipled relations with bourgeois-nationalist leaders and with trade union and Labour Party reformists in Britain". . Certainly this is true as a picture of the WRP. For many years now the organisation has heen uncriticallv Third-Worldist. It moved from - wrongly — denouncing Libya's Colonel Gaddafi as a fascist in the early 70s to uncritical gloritication of him since the late '70s. The general assumption on the informed left has been that the WRP were receiving money from Gaddafi (and, at different times, other Arab governments and possibly the PLO).
The charge about reformists" is right too. The WRP gave full and uncritical support to Ted Knight and Ken Livingstone = over the last five years. 'Labour Sean Herald', the paper launched by Knight and Livingstone, is printed on the WRP press on terms favourable enough to allow it to survive as a full-colour weekly with little visible network of sellers: its managing editor, Steven Miller, has been closely associated with the WRP:
The implication of their comments on Healy is that the Bandaites are different. Critical letters have been published in the post-Healy Newsline, one from the party's long-time hack 'theoretician' Cliff Slaughter criticising Ted Knight, and another accusing the paper of uncritically glorifying the riots in Brixton and Tottenham.
The Bandaites seem to be reverting to hard-sectarian 'Build the Revolutionary Party' politics and promising to dis tance themselves from dependence on 'nationalist leaders.
But the split cannot be explained by the political differences: the WRP isn't that kind of organisation. Politics have always been subordinate to organisational questions and calculations. Differences between the leaders were fudged or resolved on the principle 'Gerry decides'.
The split has to be explained by the disruption of that system: the different political emphasis would come after that, liberated bv it rather than coming before it and geterating it. And it cannot be taken for granted that a WRP led by Banda will be much different from what it has been in the last decade, on Third Worldism for example.
The Bandaites charge (in the resolution of the ICFI of 25 October) that Healy grossly abused his political authority over a protracted period, using the cadres of the ICFI and the WRP for his personal purposes and violating their rights... The practices which he carried out constituted an attack on the historically selected cadres of the Trotskyist movement... In the recent period (Healy) conducted an unprincipled factional campaign within the ICFI, exploiting personal contacts to portray himself as a victim of political conspiracy and to engage in a scurrilous slander campaign against leading members of the IČFI". He is also accused of "acting ever more arbitrarily within both the WRP and the ICFI", attributing their alleged success "not to Marxist principles of the Fl" or "the collective struggle of its cadres, but rather to his own personal abillties" "His personal life-style underwent a corresponding degeneration"
Another ICFI resolution (of 27 October; Newsline, 29 October): talks of *the exposure of the corrupt practices of Gerry Matgamna Gerry neury Healy and the attempt by the WRP Political Committee to cover them up"". It says that *the corrupt practices of G. Healy were revealed in the June 30 letter of comrade A.Jennings". It refers to "evidence of Healy's corruption... including his signed statement acknowledging the truth of the allegations" (of Jennings presumably). It accuses Healy of having cheated or attempted to cheat the WRP's international offshoots out of 182,000, allegedly to help the WRP.
All this, especially the charge that Healy's 'practices' constituted an attack on the historically selected cadres of the Trotskyist movement, suggests that Healy himself may have been driving towards a purge of his present opponents. In any case they struck first, expelling the Political Committee majority.
A number of things are reported by contacts in the WRP. Their interaction and sequence is not yet clear to us.
Aileen Jennings is a long-time WRP official, the daughter of two militants who became Trotskyists in the '30s. She joined the WRP's forerunner, the SLL, at the age of 14 in 1959, and is the wife of Newsline editor Paul Jennings. Her document is said to contain documented allegations of sexual coercion, and apparently there are a lot of people eager to provide similar allegations, including the editor of the WRP's 'Young Socialist' journal, Julie Ireland.
Stories and allegations like that have been commonplace for decades. That they emerge now within the WRP (rather than as stories told by ex-members) is a function of the faction fight.
A Liverpool member of the Central Committee is said to have been badly beaten up. Photographs of his injuries were circulated in the north-west. Apparently some members from Liverpool occupied the printshop (in Runcorn, nearby) and this was one reason for the nonappearance of the paper.
Healy is alleged to have control of up to half a million ounds of party money and te lave spent £20,000 from the 'Special Emergency Fund' on a All this is spectacular enough by normal standards of behaviour, morality or decency, and therefore it can be used plausibly to "explain' the Bandaites' break with Healy. But it's all old hat. Preparing for the libel case that never got to court, we had no difficulty in lining up an impressive number of former WRPers willing to testify in court about atrocities. For decades Healv has been living off the fat of the land, in the style of a pasha or film star (while the average WRP organiser frequently went unpaid and sometimes hungry), and treating the organisation and its members with infant-like egocentricity, as something that existed to satisfy his whims.
Everybody who knows the WRP knows that. For Healy's lifestyle to 'degenerate' in the last period it would have had to get to Howard Hughes stand. ards! Therefore the Bandaites' public explanation explains nothing except that it is convenient for them now to blow the whistle on Healy.
Banda has been with Healy for over 30 years. As a WRP sympathiser put it: Banda is doing a Khrushchev, denouncing Healy in the same way that Khruschev, Stalin's lieutenant, denounced his master in 1956./ Stalin was blamed for everything - and nothing fundamental changed.
That not very much has changed is shown by the announcement that the expulsion was 'unanimous' on the Central Committee - after the dissidents were removed!
The rank and file members of the WRP, those whose self-sacrifice and commitment has been abused by the leaders of the organisation — not just Healy -are being forced to think the issues through for themselves. The denunciation of Pope Gerry must destabilise the organisation. The ICFI resolution says: 'Now that a decisive split has taken place with the Healyite anti-party renegades the ICFI is confident that all leaders and members of the WRP, whatever their legitimate differences on perspectives and programme, will subordinate themselves to the discipline of our international movement... " A political ferment that the Banda bureaucracy cannot fully contain may open up.
In Manchester resolutions have been passed by overwhelming majorities demanding free discussion, an end to the notorious 'security' stipulations behind which the leadership has exercised a merciless dictatorship, and a full rank-and-file investigation into the Healy affair in which no remaining members of the leadership will be involved Thus, out of the mouths of Healy's long-time associates and disciples, comes vindication of what Socialist Organiser has said about the WRP, and vindication too for our refusal to let them bludgeon a lying public apology out of us by their use of the courts.
The SLL, the WRP's forerunner, degenerated into a sectarian semi-religious cult in the '60s. The shape that the post-'68 left took in Britain was determined by this, the disappearance of what had previously been the only Marxist group in Britain worthy of the name and its transformation into a repulsive sect. If the SLL had not degenerated, things would have gone differently and better for the left in the last two decades. Its degeneration was therefore an enormous tragedy for Marxism in Britain.
Now, as the two WRP factions square up for a public battle that can only discredit both of them, it is not a loss for the left but a gain. The WRP - if it survives at all - will never be the same again, and the atmosphere on the left will be all the cleaner and more wholesome for that. The first issue of the magazine "International", produced by the group which recently split away from "Socialist Action' appeared last weekend. Unfortunately it is disappointing.
Its masthead reads "A journal of Marxism in the Labour Party"; 'Marxism in the Labour Party' can mean many things, from co-thinkers of Eric Hobsbawm to Socialist Organiser. But "International' says nothing about where it comes from -"Published by "International' " is the only, and scarcely helpful, information on the contents page - or where it stands in relation to existing varieties of Marxism.
In particular it says nothing about where it stands in relation to Socialist Action! Indeed, the casual reader would probably think the magazine was produced by Socialist Action, only in one of its less manic moods.
Sympathy
Presumably the aim is to appear undisruptive and constructive in the eyes of international associates of Socialist Action, the better to gain their sympathy. However, if Socialist Action Is really run by an alliance of 'revisionists and crypto-Stalinists' with 'a clique which systematically puts organisational manoeuvres above politics' ', as the 'International' comrades said in their polemics before the split, then the labour movement should be told about it. If not, then why split?
The vagueness carries through to the magazine's articles. Central to Socialist Action's recent evolution has been the dropping of historic Trotskyist ideas in favour of full-scale identification with the Sandinista revolutionaries of action' in Nicaragua. What does 'International' think about it? "It is possible to agree or disagree with the tactics of the FSLN in dividing the bourgeoisie and in the subsequent establishment of a revolutionary government with bourgeois parties... they comment sagely; the furthest they get in criticism is to warn against "a schematic application of the Nicaraguan experience to coun tries such as Brazil, Mexico, Chile or Peru" or El Salvador.
The longest article in i the magazine is by Paul Lawson on *Building a Marxist movement in Britain' . Like Socialist Organiser it stresses the dual tasks of organising the Labour left on a wide scale and within that building a Marxist nucleus. But - in a long review of left politics since the early "70s - it offers no self-critical assessment of the tack of Socialist Challenge (Socialist Action's predecessor) in the late "70s, towards the SWP and the gimmick of SocialGet SOCIALIST ORGANISER each door by post.
RATES: €8.50 for 6 months. E16 for Name.
Address creat ist Unity, a far-left, anti-Labour electoral alliance.
And an orientation to the Labour Party demands that Marxists combine tactical flexibility with the greatest clarity and sobriety of assessment and principles. The same Paul Lawson wrote an article in Socialist Action's predecessor, Socialist Challenge, greeting Mitterrand's election in 1981, which was far short of the required clear-headedness. And the magazine indicates that the "International' comrades still have some way to go in clarifying their vision.
In 1981 Lawson wrote that Mitterrand's election was a "historic opening for the French working class" "an historic opportunity for socialism". He warned that Mitterrand's programme was inadequate and that "A strategy for victory must involve using (?) the struggle and vigilance of the masses to crush the bourgeoisie" • However, "a massive workers' mobilisation to gain their demands" was "inevitable"
State capitalist
Four and a half years on it reads oddly. But "International* contains an article by Phil Hearse hailing as a socialist economic policy for Labour" the recent pamphlet by Andrew Glyn "A million jobs a year"
Glyn's programme is in fact state-capitalist — a programme in which the 'active support of workers is 'used' to help impose an array of price controls, import controls, exchange controls, nationalisations, and other government controls on the economy. It has no programme for workers' control or a new state based on workers' democracy. Moreover it is a programme for one country alone: These are more than marginal faults for a "socialist economic policy.
Nevertheless the politics of "International' are certainly an improvement over *Socialist Action'. • There should be a basis for joint work between us and them, and in the common work we can discuss the differences.
Scan page 5
SOUTH AFRICA IN REVOLT YÜSER SENESE. ELEASE Sowero, 1976
----- pull-quotes -----
Public meeting
union recognition, better wages mainly to government sanctions as
FRO SO Breaking