Towards a Socialist Movement
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Bob Fine, a regular writer for Socialist Organiser, has recently visited South Africa. Last week he discussed his impressions and ideas with Charlie van Gelderen a veteran South African Trotskyist now living in Britain; a black South African comrade, a sympathiser of the Cape Action League, identified below as X Martin Thomas from the Socialist Charlie. I read a report of a UDF meet- often raised. There were a number of ing where a black trade unionist asked discussions in the trade union educathe question: how do we know if you tions about nationalisation. The Freehere is not what's happened in other which doesn't exactly call for nationali- get into power what's going to happen dom Charter [of the ANC] has a clause Bob. My main impression, from the trade unionists that I met - in FOSATU, in Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers' Union, in GWU, and others — was the depth of workers' concern with trade union democracy.
They pushed that question in ways you don't usually hear it pushed here - with respect to the accountability of officials, the education of a cadre of workers, what kind of education and what kind of cadre, and what the relation is between that cadre and rank and file workers, As the new Federation [embracing FOSATU, NUM, and a number of other unions] becomes a possibility, workers are discussing ways in which they will be able to extend the democratic structures that already exist into the new Federation. Organiser editorial board.
A lot of workers drew a close link between the structures of democracy in their own unions and wider questions of democratic organisation inside South Africa. So for example one of the ways in which workers would address the character of the UDF is to ask: what structures does the UDF have? to whom are their leaders parts of Africa? accountable? what kind of education does the UDE provide for its members? Bob. heard that as well, a number of what possibility is there of recaul.ot times. Ine question or ine relationsmip their officials? between democracy and socialism: is nationalisation also means democratic control of industry by workers? There is strong emphasis within the trade union educationals on workers' control in industry.
The problem of Eastern Europe also came up a lot. A lot of workers had followed the progress and defeat of Solidarnosc - there were a lot of articles in the trade union newspapers — and there was a strong belief that socialism without free trade unions was a contradiction in terms. 1. How widespread is this discussion?
Is it confined to the top layers, the leaders, the shop stewards, or do you find it at shop floor level?
Bob. My impression is that the discussion is not just among leaders. It percolates further than that. The education programmes in FOSATU and most of the other unions is oriented to building a cadre from shop steward level.
Beneath the cadre of shop stewards education is very informal. Some of it percolates, some of it doesn't percolate. But there are a lot of shop sation, but is along those lines - stewards, and the structures for elecownership by the people of the mono- ting shop stewards are fairly democrapolies. The trade unionists asked them- tic. So it's quite a broad spectrum that is heine educated. sewes the quesnon: wnat nas nauonal- The education is much broader than isation got.to do with socialism unless, trade union education here. All kinds of political issues are taken up. But there's no attempt to counterpose directly the politics being established within the trade unions to the politics of the ANC or orthodox nationalism. There's an implicit counterposing, but no explicit counterposing.
X. How does the education take place?
Bob. In a variety of ways. There are regional schools, some of them lasting two weeks. The union negotiates release for workers for two weeks. Other schools are weekends or just evenings or afternoons. Different unions have different structures. FOSATU's education course is by far the most developed. The sessions that I went to varied from a small group of about eight shop stewards taking a course about the economic crisis to a beginners' course in CCWUSA with maybe 150 to 200 people.
X. What about the criticism often made of FOSATU that it is led by white intellectuals? I don't share this accusation, but it is often said that FOSATU is a white-led movement. Look at its educationals, look at its schools, look at Continued on page 6 socialist Gaganise a vas on zines