South Africa in Revol Towards a Socia Darien
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
From page 5 its newspapers: where are the black workers? What does this talk of shopfloor democracy amount to?
Bob. There are a lot of white people involved in the role of educators. Partly the unions utilise academics from the universities. The scheme - I'm not sure how far it has developed - is that the cadre in turn will become educators.
But the number of whites involved in FOSATU is small, and it's a very big union. I went round FOSATU offices - there are a few whites involved, and they're very influential, but the organisers are almost all black.
Clearly white radical intelligentsia have played, and still play, anımportant role in FOSATU. But the union as a whole values the work of these whites. That's one of the reasons why the union is very hot on maintaining a non-racial position.
X. Yes. You have intellectuals — they happen to be white — but that's a good thing. It's up to the black workers to reject white intellectuals. Up to now they haven't. But I'd like to see black workers become educators.
Charlie. I think this issue has been overplayed by opponents of the unions - especially by people who shouldn't really throw stones. The fact that they use African names when they write their articles doesn't entitle them to condemn the unions. Checkers workers who struck many support black consciousness. And I think that some of the very top FOSATU officials in that area are Forum. think the overwhelming polit- sympathetic to the National ical presence, though, for better or worse, is the UDF I met almost no-one who thought that a workers' party was an immediate possibility. A lot of people felt that they were in a political vacuum. A lot of people were saying 'we have to do something political' but were not very happy with the options available. On the other hand - and this leads to a kind of paralysis — there's a notion that it's impossible to set up an alternative to the ANC — the symbols of the ANC are too strong, the tradition is oo strong - to try to take on the ANC would be big trouble.
Also within the trade union movement there is a very strong current which doesn't give top priority to the question of a party. Top priority is building a trade union movement. I suppose there is a syndicalist element there, which says that the party important but it can wait - it is always something for a future date.
So in the place where the best human resources for the building of a workers' party are to be found, a lot of those resources are still directed to the trade union movement and not towards a party.
The question of a workers' party is on the agenda, and ought to become more explicitly on the agenda. But there is a danger of a kind of substitutionism. The trade unions at the moment are not willing to go down that road, but it seems to me either a workers' party will come OUt of the trade union movement or it will not come out at all. If a group of individuals themselves workers party, they won't in fact be able to perform the functions of a workers' party.
Charlie. Yes, there is a danger of syndicalism, especially in the GWU, which seems to be very much inclined towards a simple position of just building up trade union strength rather than building a political party. But how do the trade unions relate to the community organisations?
Bob. I think the GWU have X. Towards the UDF?
Bob. No, towards an ndependen working-class politics. At the momen the strongest syndicalist c irrents seen to be in FOSATU in 1983 when a (white) worker was demoted. ness.
The trade unions' relation to community organisations is entirely different in different parts of the country. In Port Elizabeth, in the Eastern Cape, relations are disastrous. Trade unionists are fingered as collaborators. Trade unions didn't support the consumer boycott. When there was a call for a general strike in that area tor one day - from Boesak of the UDF I think it was - the unions objected. They said you can't just call on workers to do things - it's the workers who decide, not a call from on high.
In other areas relations are much better. In some areas community organisations are based in the unions.
I think the most advanced notion coming out of FOSATU is 'transformative politics' . This means that the structures built up by trade unions in the workplaces — solid, democratic, grass-roots structures - should be extended into the community, so that for the next period of time the unions can be involved in building community organisations. Also that the kind of politics that unions engage in in the workplace — the posing of demands on immediate questions: the right of access to workers, better wages, better conditions, end to discrimination against women - should be extended from the workplace to the community.
The idea is that in this way the unions will be able to develop a solid base in the community, as a step towards developing their own political voice. The problem, of course, is that the development of community organisations is not a substitute for the development of a party.
X. Joe Foster of FOSATU made a very good speech in 1982 about the need for independent working-class politics. But what worries me is that I don't see any effort by FOSATU since then to carry those ideas forward. It looks like a project abandoned by FOSATU. Bob. I think you're right. The speech was out on a limb, and very little has time to political action - was overtaken by events, in particular by the politicisation of their own members.
FOSATU has been drawn into politics on terms not of their own making, precisely because they haven't done anything to establish political organisation. One example was the consumer boycott campaign.
Everyone in FOSATU knew the problems with the consumer boycott campaign. The campaign was against white shops, and everyone knew that, however much you denied this, there was a racial element which the trade unions didn't like.
X. The Unity Movement makes that criticism, too.
Bob. Secondly there was the question of the black petty bourgeoisie charging higher prices. The people being called on to conduct the boycott live on the margins anyway - so that a tiny fare increase can lead to a bus boycott — so you can imagine what a ten, twenty, forty per cent increase in food prices means.
Thirdly, the conditions of the workers in black-owned shops are worse, probably, than those of the unionised workers in the big white stores. The workers in the big white stores were threatened with lay-offs.
And the demands of the consumer boycott were very general - end the emergency, troops out of townships, end apartheid.
All the trade unionists knew the problems. It's one thing to know the problems, another thing what you do about them. The trade unionists in some areas drew the conclusion that they should have nothing to do with the consumer boycott. Trade unionists in other areas drew the conclusion that it was a road they had to go down despite all its disadvantages, because they had to show a concern for what was happening in the townships and that was the only way available of doing it.
It was better to go down this unsatisfactory road than to go down no road at all. What seemed to me to be missing was a conception of what a satisfactory road could be. analogous to the situation here, where the immediate feeling among workers is to get rid of Thatcher. There the feeling is to get rid of apartheid, and the ANC represents the main force, like the Labour Party does here, for the immediate task.
Bob. Yes. One of the things I learned there was the strength of the ANC's appeal. In a way the analogy with the Labour Party is a good one — to the extent that we have to understand the strength of the Labour tradition here, and also the ANC tradition has important strengths which we need to understand if we're going to relate to it adequately.
X. The ANC has very strong symbols. But are these symbols visible to the population as a whole? Or just to the urban population? And not everyone in the urban population, but only the educated people, the ones who read newspapers?
I think the process by which the ANC is becoming visible to everybody is the mass funerals. The majority of the people at those funerals have come to bury a friend, a relative, a member of the community. But during the funeral - through the ANC colours draped on the coffin and so on - they are brought into contact with the ANC. The majority of these people will be people who do not read newspapers, But before these funerals, I wonder if the ANC reached the mass of people — the rural people, the farm labourers, the people in the resettlement camps, the migrant workers in the mining compounds...
Bob. I don't know. My impression is that the ANC's popular appeal is growing very rapidly. The organisations that are going to come out of this present period strongest, most unscathed, are not the AN organisations but the trade union movement. The problem is to translate that organisation into a political presence. At the moment everyone feels that power is on the agenda. And who are the trade unions when power is on the agenda? They chip away - better conditions here, a workers' organisation there - but they don't address themselves to the really central questions of power. And the ANC do.
THE ANC Charlie. It seems to me that there are only two roads for South Africa, over five or ten years. Sooner or later this regime must give way. The most likely thing at the moment is some kind of agreement with the ANC and the white bourgeoisie. The only other alternative is that even the Workers at Dunnes St handle South African union policy and refu went on strike with th In September the ! market chains in Irela ever, soon made clear Early in October it for refusing to pack C The dispute has ha workers will not have
----- pull-quotes -----
UNIONS AND COMMUNITIES