Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

List Movement

Socialist Organiser no. 250, 31 October 1985 · scan p. 7 · about 1,512 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

bres in Dublin have been on strike for 15 months because they refuse to goods. The dispute started when one worker, Mary Manning, followed ed to check out South African goods. She was sacked and the workers e support of their union, the IDATU. finister of Labour, Ruari Quinn, fixed up a deal with all the major supernd whereby they would 'phase out' South African produce. Dunnes, howthat this vague promise meant nothing, and the strike continues. spread to Dunnes Crumlin branch when a worker there was suspended d wider effects. A number of Irish stores have made agreements that their to handle South African goods if they don't want to, and in Derry the has decided that any body on which the council is represented will th African products or services. Anti-Apartheid posters will be displayed democratic demands of the Charter can finally be realised only through something completely different a workers' party.

Bob. Part of the problem with tne Freedom Charter is that the means are so disconnected from the ends. There's a loosely-defined democratic vision, but that vision is entirely abstracted from any means of getting there. Without some democratic element in the means of getting there, you'll never get democracy.

Martin. There seems to be a contradiction in the way the ANC conducts politics. The immediate slogans put forward are fantastically militant -"make South Africa ungovernable' , no education before liberation' ', blank opposition to everything. On the other hand, there they are lobbying governments, trying to persuade governments to put on sanctions, talking to the capitalists, and so on. And the social programme they put forward is in fact very moderate.

The explanation, I think, is that the ANC's vision is not one where a new South Africa will be created by the people taking control; but the role of the mass of the people is just to be disorderly and to put the government in a position where the government then has to negotiate with the ANC. The whole thing takes place over the heads of the people.

This approach has dangers, it seems to me, not only in the long term but also in the short term.

Oliver Tambo in an interview with Newsweek said that he could see the downfall of apartheid maybe in ten years, being optimistic. The perspective of making South Africa ungovernable might be a good tactic if you think that the government is going to fall in a few months: but ten years? To pursue that sort of politics cannot but create divisions among your own people: people become exhausted and frustrated by the disorder. The logic of it, despite all the ANC's calls for unity, is to fragment and divide. Which from the point of view of the ANC is not necessarily a bad thing: it ensures that the initiative remains in their hands.

Charlie. If the present situation in South Africa is, as they say, organised by the ANC, then why do these outbreaks of violence take place in different areas at different times and not simultaneously? Why do they allow the people of the Eastern Cape to struggle by themselves, and then it moves to the Vaal Triangle, and then to Cape Town? If they really want to make the country ungovernable, they should be able to prevent the state concentrating all its repressive apparatus on one spot.

I can see a Northern Ireland situation developing, of continuous resistutspan oranges.

and schools. ance which the state to some extent.

Bob. Yes. I don't think the uprisings take place in the townships because the ANC called for them.

They take place because of the extraordinarily difficult conditions that people in the townships face. The problem with the ungovernability slogan is that it does not offer any sense of what a workers' government would consist of.

When the students and the people in the townships throw their bodies against the police, the ANC doesn't so much try to organise that as to use it as a bargaining weapon.

Charlie. Most of us, myself included, have firmly believed that in South Africa capitalism can't exist without apartheid. I'm not so sure that still holds true today, with more sophisticated industry in South Africa.

The problem, of course, is the mines. The low productivity of Rand ore still demands cheap unskilled labour to make those mines profitable. But they can create a black aristocracy of labour and still have a mass of unskilled workers on low wages. Martin. Isn't it a fact that wages in the gold mines, after declining or stagnating for 80 years, have risen consi derably since the early '70s?

It seems to me that the problem for the government in dismantling some of the special features of South Africa and turning it into a more normal racist capitalism is not so much some economic impossibility in the abstract as the difficulty of dealing with their base, the white population. Bob. Is capitalism possible without apartheid in South Africa?' In a sense it's the wrong question. Theoretically we can argue it until the cows come home. What we have to be warned against is that certainly capitalism without apartheid is what a lot of people are trying to establish. Whether it is in fact established will be deterined not theoretically but in practical The Progressive Federal Party and the capitalists are putting forward a definite anti-apartheid position. It's just not pro-socialist and not pro-democratic. They want a kind of federal power-sharing which will guarantee bricks, bottles and petrol bombs against private enterprise.

A lot of people say that the government is just perpetuating the old apartheid system under a slightly new guise. I think that's probably right so far, but it sufficient pressures are put on the government I wouldn't put it past them to pursue a programme of reforms to a point where the major planks of apartheid are eroded. In its place you'd have a military-bureaucratic dictatorship, partially deracialised, that offers us nothing at all, no improvement on apartheid.

We have to be aware that there kinds of 'anti-apartheid' that have thing to do with democracy and thing to do with socialism:

X. It is in the context of these changes that a workers' party has meaning.

It seems that capitalism in South Africa is capable of de-racialising moured cars. itselt. I'm not happy with the theories that say capitalism is inseparable trom apartheid. Theoretically, from an abstract point of view, that may be very correct. But in terms of practical day-to-day politics an understanding like that can turn itself into ultraleftism, where you do nothing because the struggle is not against capitalism.

It is only through a workers' party that you can have a combined struggle, a permanent revolution. In the context of the changes that are taking place you need a workers' party to defend the workers' interests, to carry on the workers' struggle. You're not going to get socialism overnight. If in the context of these changes the ANC comes into power, either alone or as part of a coalition, you will need a workers' party that will stand in opposition.

Charlie. If the ANC comes into power, will a workers' party be allowed? X. If you don't start organising and thinking about it now, then it may be too late. You'll find yourself in a situation like Zimbabwe, where it is practically impossible to emerge as workers' party.

Charlie. What did you see of the influence of black consciousness, of the National Forum, or Azaps Movement - still very much caught up in the old rhetoric. There were thousands of people at the meeting I went to, and a terrific atmosphere, but what the speakers had to say was entirely in terms of criticising the consumer boycott, criticising the ANC, criticising liberalism, collaborators, and so on. To me it didn't add up to a positive programme. It was a wasted meeting - all those thousands of people, very tense, and the programme put forward was entirely one of negative opposition to what was already going on.

The Unity Movement seemed to me to have some very educated and fine comrades inside it, but as an organisation it belongs to a current of socialism in South Africa that defines itself in terms of opposition to the Freedom Charter and opposition to liberals. X. My impression is that there is no streak of socialism in the New Unity Movement. As you say, it is very much in the tradition of the old Unity Movement. In the old Unity Movement there was explicit opposition to socialism. A number of people were expelled from the old Unity Movement because they were trying to espouse socialism.

The Unity Movement stood by the Ten Point programme [of democratic demands]. The New Unity Movement also stands by the Ten Point programme. I believe they are going to update it, but my impression is that they are not going to update it by moving in a leftward direction only making the

----- pull-quotes -----

CAPITALISM APARTHEID

NEW UNITY MOVEMENT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 250

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →