Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[rav but" were eventually expelled. recrundred per cent…]

Socialist Organiser no. 250, 31 October 1985 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 667 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

rav but" were eventually expelled. recrundred per cent, of the labour of Martin. To turn to the question of international solidarity: the main way this question is posed is the ANC's approach, which is pressure on governments to impose sanctions. But what do workers in South Africa think is the best form of solidarity?

Bob. I came across a debate on the disinvestment programme. There was a debate while I was there between Schlemmer, an academic at the Buthelezi Institute for Social Research, and Alec Erwin of FOSATU.

Alec Erwin distanced himself very sharply from people like the Progressives, but he also said that the assets that the multinationals claim to own in "South Africa are the product, the hundred percent; of the labour of South Africa are not giving their support to the South African socialists. Socialist Action has swung behind the ANC.

All this happens at a time when you have socialist consciousness emerging in South Africa. Part of international enlidaritu chould he to make TO SAAGAR links with those socialists. We may disagree with them. We may think it is wrong for them to be outside UDF or inside UDF. But we should make links and discuss these things with them, and give them as much support as possible.

There's so much money going into UDF and ANC - no money going into the socialist groups that are emerging in South Africa. In some cases I think what is still between those groups and, the mass movement is lack of international support.

Scan page 9

-The Poundswick striki Don't attack teachers. Unravelling pute has developed will be a Ipo the issues The school students' anger must be focused. Strike against YTS, April The way the Poundswick dis- The way the Poundswick dispute has developed will be a disappointment to trade disappointment to trade unionists and socialists alike. unionists and socialists alike. The Tories and some right Tha TAriAc and come richt wing heads and deputy heads have made the dispute into a reactionary one about standards and a return to disci-pline in schools.

However the article in SO 248 has done little but antagonise all concerned and blinded us to the initial issue involved and the immediate response of the teachers.

The classroom teacher's job has become increasingly difficult in recent years. In a society where hope is running out for the young, school has become another focus for their anguish and opposition to a system which is undermining their future.

- Teachers, on the other hand, are faced with cutbacks in all kinds of equipment and resources.

Inner-city

-1985. Photo: Stefano Cagnoni, SIRENE LHE LANAR But if they are transThere are, I think, several issues to be unravelled in the Poundswick dispute.

First, justice for the five boys whom the teachers want removed from the school. Removing a child from school often means throwing them on scrap heap educationally. It is ho small matter, and it seems to me quite right that some public body outside the school should pass the final verdict and do so with great concern for the students' rights.

Manchester council says that it's not proved that the five boys did the graffiti complained of. Even if it were, and however disgusting the graffiti, being thrown to the margins of education is a drastic punishment.

And it would be a pretty hypocritical one. A big part of everyor less effective ti group into a high-stress exercise in child-minding. Most students find that oppressive, as well as teachers.

Throwing out disorderly students - except in the most extreme cases — is no answer. Carried through as a policy, it would lead to mass purges in many schools. Quite substantial numbers of black students, in particular, already get removed from some schools: -Both teachers and students face an impossible situation. Enormous youth unemployment; an education system entirely geared to exams, but offering only a small minority success in those exams; illdesigned curricula, and an education structure alienated from everyday life; inadequate

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 250

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →