Rallying to author
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-31Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Increasingly teachers, particularly in inner city areas are confronted with an intolerable nervous pressure, one which comes home with them at night and which can make their lives a misery. -No socialist can claim that workers ought to put up with that kind of pressure in the name of defending a broader argument against a return to reactionary standards, especially when they have suffered gross personal insults of a racist and sexist nature.
Indeed it is misleading to equate the actions of teachers whose sensibilities have been severely attacked with the right wing 'standards' backlash peddled by the Tories.
The refusal of the Poundswick teachers to teach the five was a simple gut reaction, a feeling that 100 yards of school wall daubed with obscene graffiti involving sex between named teachers and their partners, was about as much as they could take. It was not a cry to reintroduce canine' victorian educational other values.
Children attacking teachers in this way is no more justifiable than teachers caning pupils.
Manchester City Council sent the teachers home without pay, sacking them in Ian McCalman casts aside his anti-Stalinism as casually as a teacher tossing away a failed exam paper to rally to the cause of authoritarianism in the shape of the Poundswick High School dispute (SO 249).
Why he rides in on his habitual hobby horse of the teachers" "18 month campaign" for a pay rise is far from clear - unless he shares the SWP's syndicalist fantasies that strike action in itself suffices to sweep away ingrained prejudices.
effect. It would be an odd situation if a socialist council sacked bus drivers for refusing to drive late-night buses because of physical Difficult But according to the article in SO 248 it was "difficult to see what other action could be taker " in the case of the Pound swick teachers.
His endorsement of summary lynch-law "justice" — it has not even been proven that the youths committed the acts attributed to them - is itself an endorsement of the original article's reference to the evaporation of liberal values amongst teachers.
lan's authoritarian leanings are clearly the product of childhood repression. It would therefore be wrong to be too hard on him. Personally, I blame his teachers.
STAN CROOKE Accepting the principle of sending teachers home who refuse to be grossly abused seems a rather strange way of developing a broad-based class struggle which must include teachers workers.
The simple solution with this logic must be to reinstate the pupils and return them to a situation where they have nothing but negative feelings for both school and teachers. ferred to another school it will be seen as a victory for reaction, even if the other school provides a less intimidatory atmosphere.
This kind of thinking reveals a complete misunderstanding of the classroom situation. It assumes that teachers are always oppressive and pupils always oppressed. This is not true. Even socialist teachers are the target of some pupils, particularly those who are overtly racist and sexist.
In any case, to transfer the fight to another school is not necessarily a recommendation that they be whipped 18 imprisoned or have their character and personality further condemned.
This last being a. distinct possibility if they remain where wey are The way forward is not for one section of the working class to attack another The task of making teachers into a working class force will only be done through consistent principled work inside the teaching unions and the labour movement generally, not through veiled attacks on teachers as the weak link in the class struggle.
LIAM CONWAY Nottingham day life in many schools is abuse and insults against students by teachers who, relative to those students, are in a position of wealth, power and security.
Parents But we need to have more to say to the teachers, and the parents and students who support them.
To want orderly education of a good standard is not at all reactionary. Students who are violent and hurtfully abusive to teachers will often act the same way to other students. This may be rooted in class oppression, but it's not progressive. It is a fact that two or three alienated and frustrated students can transform a class from a more The article on the Poundswick teachers' strike (SO 248) was both ill-though out and narrowminded.
Anti-sexism and anti-racism is the issue: the typical macho shit which tends to feature in graffiti is offensive, to condone this graffiti is to condone the attitudes held by those who write it.
For socialists the issue is not so-called 'morality" or "saving buildings, educational materials, and numbers of teachers — all blight the spirit.
To support teacher authoritarianism is no answer, but neither is celebrating school disorder as working class protest. We should try to direct teachers and students towards a common fight for a better system, and in the first place for more resources and facilities.
As for the SWP: articles in Socialist Worker argue something similar, as far as l can see, to what I've suggested above. But comrades in Manchester tell me that the SWP's practical attitude on the ground 1s different.
MARTIN THOMAS Islington standards" (as some see it) but a clear case of combatting racism and sexism.
In the past Socialist Organiser has condemned racism and sexism, so why should a dispute over these be considered "reactionary"?
To brand striking over racist, sexist graffiti as "whipping the working class back into line" is wholly wrong.
GILL STEEL