Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Battle of Brittan

Socialist Organiser no. 251, 7 November 1985 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 2,323 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

-Socialist Organiser-no: 251 - 7 November 1985- Page 4 Amnesty for terror Or at least they reject it for British miners. But listen to what Margaret Thatcher says about Nicaragua.

One of her conditions for an agreement with the Sandinista Brass Tacks' (Thursday October 31, BBC2), had film of the police attack on students at Manchester University during a visit by Leon Brittan, then Home Secretary; and a police video of their own tactics at Orgreave.

Police actions at the 'Battle of Brittan' have been described by the inquiry panel set up by Manchester Police Monitoring Committee as "unreasonable, unjustifiable, and...highly irresponsible.

Nearly all the 102 witnesses who gave evidence to the inquiry confirmed police violence, and 48 said they were assaulted. Of 36 charges brought against 38 arrested, 17 were dismissed by magistrates and three more on appeal.

On the programme itself, students involved and witnesses testified to high levels of police brutality. Students were thrown down steps and hit and kicked by policemen.

Two students have suffered police harassment. Sarah Hollis and Steve Shaw both had their flats burgled: photocopies of witness statements and a file on police technology were stolen from them respectively. And they both experienced considerable personal intimidation from police — with or without superfor officers' knowledge sent it is not known.

The film of the event screened in 'Brass Tacks' was clear as an indictment of police actions -although the programme itself was marred by its attempt to establish the validity of the students' case through demonstrating the respectability of their social backgrounds.

Official police video recordings of the 'Battle of Orgreave' at the height of the miners' strike was equally clear. The police have been adopting the riot-control techniques of British colonial police. Contrary to the supposed tradition of the British police, the colonial police used (and still do in places like Hong Kong) high levels of physical violence to disperse 'seditious' crowds.

An instructor to the Hong Kong police gave the flavour of this style of policing. Telling his students that they should warn the crowd of any impending attack, he commented that it was up to them how loudly they gave the warning...

These methods are being introduced into Britain, with all the hardware, like CS gas and plastic bullets.

What is certain is that the battles' of Brittan and Orgreave are no more than dress rehearsals for war to come - unless new police powers can be stopped and the growth of their power rolled back.

Scan page 5

AFTER OVER a year of 'secret negotiations between top British and Eire civil servants, a new Anglo-Irish agreement on Northern Ireland will probably be announced this week!

The deal is likely to consist of the following:

* A joint 26 County/British commission or Council of Ministers tc oversee the running of Northern Ireland, Sovereignty will still lie completely with London.

* The establishment of a permanent secretariat consisting of representatives from London. Me tefan elf the RUC and of the locallyrecruited - and almost entirely Protestant - British Army regiment, the UDR.

Following from the deal could come devolution of power to a local assembly in Belfast - if the Protestants accept the deal.

Behind the negotiations is a promise of massive US aid. Figures ranging from $200 million to $1 billion have been talked about.

Republicans and Loyalists alike oppose the deal - the Loyalists more fiercely than the Republicans, who plausibly claim that any concessions to the Catholics contained in the deal have been won not by talk but by their military campaign over the last 14 Both Republicans and Loyalist paramilitaries expect that the deal will be accompanied by increased repression in Northern Ireland. Sinn Fein expects that a concerted move will be made by Dublin and London to ban the Republican party. The leaders of the Protestant UDA have announced that they are going into hiding for fear that selective internment will be introduced to stifle opposition to the deal.

Internment is probably unlikely because of the sympathy it would evoke from the Republicans. The banning of Sinn Fein - legalised only a decade ago - is far more likely, though that too would carry a high political price for both the British and Dublin governments.

It would also bring great advantages. When Sinn Fein was illegal, the only nationalist Catholic party was the cooperative SDLP, at whose expense Sinn Fein has gained enormously since the hunger strikes of 1981.

The British government have other pressing reasons for banning Sinn Fein. 15 district councils in the Six Counties have now adjourned indefinitely because Unionists refuse to tolerate their elected Sinn Fein colleagues. The teeble structures of Northern Ireland local government are being wrecked.

Unionist delegates who have met Tory minister Tom King have come out announcing their impression that 'something' will be done.

It Orange opposition to the Dublin/London deal is not to wreck it before anything can be done to implement it, then the authorities must do something to sweeten the Orange population. A concerted Dublin/London drive against the political wing of the IRA would be such a sweetener, as would any agreement on additional joint Dublin/Belfast militarypolice action against the IRA.

The government's chances of sweetening the Orangeists are not good, however. They threaten to 'go all the way' in opposition to the deal, beginning with a challenge in the British courts as to its legality and going on to strikes and military resistance.

Thatcher has pledged to 'stand up to' an Orange backlash, and she may have to. The two main Unionist parties, the DUP and OUP, have formed a united opposition movement to resist. The Protestant paramilitary UDA claims 10,000 members, and has set up a specialist fighting force, the Ulster Defence Force.

Listen to some of Orange representatives:

Peter Robinson of the DUP says: "The day the Republic of Ireland is given any role in the governance of Northern Ireland, that same day I cease to recognise or respect the validity or authority of the United Kingdom government". . To Dublin he declares: "All the time you are in that role, Unionists will planning your destruction"

DUP chief whip Jim Allister states: "Unionists demand a veto over any changes in the structures and processes of Northern Ireland, and if we are denied that veto, then we will implement it ourselves"

The UDA - a legal and almost entirely working-class body which shelters assassination gangs like the outlawed 'UFF' - has called on the powerless assembly in Belfast, elected three years and boycotted by the Catholic parties, to set up a provisional government. "Those who encourage or protect [26 County] involvement will become the enemy, no matter who they are or whose orders they obey"

John McMichael of the UDA declares bluntly that ... more and more people believe that there cannot be a political solution. It may be that this country has to go to the very verge of civil war before a compromise is reached.

"There is a belief that Loyalists must get together, plan and organise. There is general recognition of the need for a strong army, a defence militia, and our emphasis is now more and more on the paramilitary side rather than the political side".

The UDA wants a written constitution, guaranteeing the Border and with a two-thirds majority needed for any change, and a Bill of Rights.

The politicians, Molyneaux and Paisley, wrote to Thatcher in August: "Any proposal to increase Anglo-Irish cooperation must be suspect given the Republic's claim to the territory of Northern Ireland which is a repudiation of Northern Ireland's right to self-determination.

"This being so, we call upon Her Majesty's Government to challenge the government of the Republic to withdraw its territorial claim and recognise Ulster's right to self determination as an essential prerequisite to greater friendship, cooperation and understanding"

Thatcher's reply stated: "I mean first that Northern Ireland will remain part of the United Kingdom for as long as the majority in the province so wish; and secondly that whatever may emerge from our discussions with the Irish authorities, responsibility for the government of Northern Ireland will rest with United Kingdom ministers accountable to parliament?

But the Orangeists are not reassured. Paisley promises to fight to the death.

The slump has hit the Protestant working class terribly hard, and the effect may be to weaken the combativity of the Protestants and make any repeat of the 1974 Orange general strike difficult. The prospect of massive US aid may placate some of the Unionists. But all the signs are that they will resist fiercely.

There is resistance in the South too. The constitutional nationalist Fianna Fail is in opposition, and its leader Charles J Haughey has denounced the government for preparing to sell out the cause of a 32 county Ireland. In fact the government has done nothing of the sort.

Foreign minister Peter Barry states: "We would not now accept any new obstacles which might make the achievement of Irish unity more difficult.. in the future"

But Barry has also said to the Unionists: *We accept and acknowledge your Britishness. We respect your reas ons for opposing Irish unity".

This is one of the two sharply contrasted approaches to Irish unity which exist within constitutional nationalism. It says that unity is desirable, but unity by consent as a result of a growingtogether of the peoples of The other view, that of crude 'territorial nationalism' has been brutally put by Neil Blaney, an independent Fianna Fail TD [MP].

"Beware of any sell-out on our claim to the territory of all this country, because that is what our forefathers and patriots fought and died for, and their struggle has continued for 800 years".

Others in the South, like Labour senator Mary Robinson, have called in connection with the Anglo-Irish deal for guarantees for the rights of minorities in the South.

But Charles J Haughey seems set to win the next 26 County elections, and therefore if Fianna Fail is serious about scuttling the deal it will be able to.

What the deal proposes is an extremely limited concession to the demand of the Northern Ireland Catholics and the all-Ireland majority for a united Ireland - no more than a say in the affairs of the North for the Dublin government. But to the Orange diehards even that is the beginning of the end.

The deal's practical meaning will most likely be a big stepping-up of repression against the Republicans. And even then the Orange backlash may scupper it - if Haughey doesn't.

Over the last weeks gardai posts have been heavily strengthened along the border in the expectation that Orange paramilitaries will strike at the South. A bomb set off without warning by Orangemen in Dublin in 1973 killed 22 people and wounded scores of others.

Perhaps the last word should go to Enoch Powell, a bitter opponent of the deal. He says it is a multiple double cross.

Britain, he says, promises constitutional change that it cannot deliver. Dublin offers cooperation against the IRA that it cannot deliver. Each is out to cheat the other, and both are out to cheat the US tof its money cEa The decision by the Botha regime in South Africa to ban foreign reporting on the 'unrest' except under very strict conditions — is transparent in its intent.

The racist state neither wants us to see what it is already doing every day to black people in South Africa; nor - even less — wants us to see what it has got in store.

It indicates the extent to which Botha is running scared of international opinion, which despite Mrs Thatcher's sterling efforts is against him; of the mass resistance to apartheid; and of his own white supremaccist base, who want yet firmer action.

Last week's by-elections were bad news for Botha. His National Party scraped through in four of them, but with big losses to the far right; and it lost in one to the ultra-bigoted Herstigte Nasionale Party. (The HNP is not: just in favour of 'unleashing' the army against blacks. They are also against Jews, Catholics and English-speakers). The results suggest that Botha is failing to convince the Afrikaner whites that his policy of attemting to buy off the revolution will pay off.

The HP, and the similar Conservative Party, represent the base for mass-scale white racist reaction in South Africa. They are firmly opposed to even the slightest concession to the The ultra-reactionary laager mentality of the far right makes a mockery of proposals by the liberal Progressive Federal Party and Zulu chief Buthelezi that all parties to the conflict get together round a table. Such negotiations are utopian in the extreme.

Of course white South Africa is not a single, reactionary force. The editor of the Cape Times has risked imprisonment by illegally publishing an intcavic with Oliver Tambo, the exiled ANC leader. It is illegal even to quote ANC members in South Africa - though prostatics are erratic: while the Johannes burg Star' was recently successfully prosecuted quoting Tambo, Botha himself has publicly got away with it....

The Cape Times editor Tony Heard, has stressed the ANC's willingness to discuss peaceful solutions - if the apartheid state first SaDunouaJ violence.

The South African National Union of Mireworkers (NUM), the largest of the country's independent, non-racial trade unions, last week won a case in the Industrial Court for the reinstatement of workers sacked during its legal strike im SeptemberFor the first tame, South African workers mow have lega protection against airtirrisatir for strike action. Before mow, workers could be sacked with impunity even for legal strikes.

This follows a legal wrangle over the Industial Court's night to judge in such matters. Angh Vaal mining come, taken to court by the NUM last unonth for the dismissall of four workers unsuccessfully chalk-ged the Industrial Court's right to judge.

----- pull-quotes -----

John forthcoming Du ster deal land.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 251

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →