Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[the Labour Party. So what w first time?…]

Socialist Organiser no. 251, 7 November 1985 · scan pp. 6–7 · Arthur Bough · about 3,101 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

the Labour Party. So what w first time? What lessons can Black trade unionists in South Africa are discussing the project of a workers' party based on the non-racial unions there. Some socialists say that such a party would inevitably end up like the Labour Party in Britain, with its own Kinnocks and Hattersleys. What truth is there to this argument? Tony Benn to re-found wrong the learned?

It was in 1905, eighty years ago, that the TUC Congress voted to support the Labour Representation Committee in the 1906 General Election, and thus effectively establish the Labour Party in its modern form. There had already been a long struggle for labour representation in Parliament.

MPs The first working class MPs were elected in 1874. Thomas Burt, MP for Morpeth and Alexander MacDonalt, MP for Stafford, were both miners. The number of working class MPs rose to three in 1880, 11 in 1885 and 10 in 1886. All of them sat with the Liberals - then a major party - and were known as "Lib-Labs"

In 1892, Keir Hardie was elecred to Parliament, and in the following year he established the Independent Labour Party. The ILP stood 28 candidates at the 1895 General Election, but every single one was defeated.

At this time, the trade unions supported the Liberals. Hardie set out to win the trade unions away from the Liberals. It was not easy. The nature of the trade unions was changing. From being rank-and-file based organisations, with a fairly ramshackle organisation, they had become large organisations with full time officials and offices.

Especially after the defeat of Chartism, the trade unions had reconciled themselves to the existence of capitalism, and was The result was a strengthsapping search for respectability. This especially affected the older craft-based unions like the Engineers. Frederick Engels wrote scathingly of the desire for acceptance in bourgeois society that affected even the best of them, like Tom Mann and John Burns. Top hat, frock coat and waistcoat were the uniform of even the most left-wing engineers' leaders.

The new general unions -like the Gas and General, forerunner of the GMBU, in which Karl Marx's daughter Eleanor played a leading role — were more radical. But even they were beginning to succumb to the conservatising influence of British imperialism in its heyAs Richard Bell MP said at the opening of the 1905 Congress, seconding a motion of thanks to the Mayor:

*There was a time when trade unions were not respectable enough to be welcomed by the Mayor". Bell looked forward to the day when they would be "respectable enough to be welcomed by the Lord Chancellor" and others talk about the n eed Cent be Most trade union leaders preferred to stick with the 'respectable' Liberals rather than associate with socialists. Socialist theory was seen as something strange and foreign.

But the socialist minority persisted. In 1900 a meeting in London with representatives of the ILP, trade unions, SIne Fabians and the Social Democratic Federation established the Labour Representation CommitTwo of its candidates, including Keir Hardie, were LCC. elected to Parliament that year.

The LRC sent reports on its progress to the TUC Conference Keir Hardie PELL The 1912 transport strike each year after its foundation. Increasingly, there was pressure for unity between the TUC, the General Federation of Trade Unions, and the LRC, in order to put forward candidates for the next General Election, which everyone knew could not be far off.

Attacks on the trade unions by the bosses, and the response to these attacks by the Liberals in Parliament, were forcing the cautious, respectable union officials to re-think their politics.

In 1901 the Taff Vale Railway Co. sued the Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants (forerunner of the NUR) for the loss it had suffered as a result of a strike by the union. The Courts decided that the union must pay large damages. The decision - overturning what had generally been understood to be the legal position until then — put every strike at risk. Any union calling action could be crippled by the courts.

The Liberals, wanting to conciliate the unions, introduced the Trades Disputes Bill into Parliament in 1905. But, as James Sexton said, opening the second day's business of the 1905 TUC Congress:

"The fate of the Trades Disputes Bill throws a lurid light upon the boasted, but absolutely fraudulent representative character of the House of Commons. For can there be a greater satire than is represented by the fact that a measure of this character, carried by a substantial majority of 122 in the House itself, was at the mercy of, and consequently destroyed by, 21 Members, most of them employers, interested in the Committee stage of the Bill?"

Offensive

Battered by the bosses' offensive, and disillusioned with the Liberals, the TUC threw its weight behind the LRC. On 16 February 1905 a joint conference between the TUC, the General Federation of Trade Unions and the Labour Representation Committee set up a permanent coordinating committee known as the Joint Board.

The conference also established an agreement on standing candidates in the next General Election. All candidates approved by the TUC Parliamentary Committee and by the LRC would receive the full backing of both organisations, and that the LRC would not be considered disloyal if it refused to support a Labour candidate adopted on any other platform.

However, the LRC had to make it clear that their national constitution did not require the abstention of any Labour voter where a Labour candidate was not standing.

Unaffiliated

This agreement was necessary because there were still a large number of unions - including the miners, then by far the biggest single union - that were still unaffiliated to the LRC and determined to support Lib/ Lab candidates.

The February agreement was ratified by the TUC Congress in autumn 1905 and the LRC then changed its name to the The debate at the Congress, however, foreshadowed problems. A resolution was put by the Stevedores' Union calling on the Parliamentary Committee to convene a conference of the TUC, GFTU, and LRC for the purpose of amalgamating into one body in order to be more powerful and effective. The idea was basically a sound one i.e. to fuse the industrial and political wings of the labour movement.

However, the Builders" Labourers' Union, who seconded the motion, had other motives. They voiced the opposition of a number of union leaders to the socialists in the Labour Representation Committee. They wanted unity in order to bring the LRC under the complete control of the TUC.

The majority of delegates were satisfied with the agreement reached at Caxton House and rejected the motion.

This led to the worst of both worlds. On the one hand the separation of the industrial and political wings of the labour movement was established. This has been a major problem for socialists ever since. Political discussion is often rejected in trade union meetings, and Labour politicians often sidestep trade union struggles by claiming that they are a "trade union" issue.

On the other hand the trade unions were still able to determine the basic objectives of the Labour Party, and part of their conditions for supporting the Labour Party was that it should not have socialism openly stated as one of its objectives. (Clause IV, part 4, calling for public ownership, was not adopted until 1918).

What the trade union leaders wanted, and got, was a political party which would act on the political plane in the same way as they did on the industrial plane. That is to say they wanted a party which accepted capitalism, and which reconciled itself to bargaining for reforms and improvements as and when available within the system.

But it need not necessarily have been so.

One of the organisations which participated in setting up the LRC in 1900 was the Social Democratic Federation, a supposedly Marxist organisation established in 1881 under the leadership of H.M. Hyndman.

As one of the founding organisations of the LRC, the SDF could have played a large part in developing a significant Marxist current in the Labour Party. The upheavals over Taff Vale were only the start of a growing militancy in the British labour movement which increased right up to World War 1, with industrial struggles reaching a very high level and battles for votes for women and Home Rule for Ireland contributing to the ferment.

Unfortunately, the SDF, like most British Marxists since. adopted a sectarian attitude towards the Labour Party. The SDF presented their Marxist programme to the Labour Party with an attitude of take it or leave it. When the Labour Party, not unexpectedly, decided to leave it, the SDF wrote off the Labour Party as politically bankrupt and withdrew.

As a result they not only cut themselves off from the organised working class and left the field open to the Liberal-reformist trade union leaders and the pacifist-socialists like Ramsay MacDonald, to determine the political direction of the Labour Partv.

The stance of the SDF went completely against the method of Marx and Engels. In 1886 Engels wrote to the American Marxists:

*Our theory is not a dogma, but the exposition of a process of evolution, and that process involves successive phases. To expect that the Americans will start with the full consciousness of the theory worked out in older industrial countries, is to expect the impossible.

"What the Germans (emigre German Marxists) ought to do is to act up to their own theory if they understand it as we did in 1845 and 1848 —to go in for any real general working class movement, accept its actual starting point as such, and work it gradually up to the theoretical level by pointing out how every mistake is made, every reverse suffered, was a necessary consequence of mistaken theoretical views in the original programme.

Grievous

"I consider that many of the Germans there made a grievous mistake when they tried, in the fact of a mighty and glorious movement, not of their creation, to make of their imported and not always understood theory a kind of 'only saving dogma' , and to keep aloof from any movement which did not accept that dogma."

Engels could equally well

Scan page 7

bour's politics Bute R Sr Cc Wu CB members were tried for sedition. have been writing about the attitude of the SDF in the In 1906 the TUC Parliamentarv Committee endorsed 51 Labour candidates, 15 of whom were not supported by the LRC mainly because they were representatives of the Miners' Federation. The Parliamentary Committee issued a manifesto for the election which was followed fairly closely by the LRC, with 10 point sil 1) The principles embodied in mmL the Trades Disputes Bill.

2) A Workmen's Compensation Act to make payments from the date of the accident.

3) A Truck Amendment Act to prevent all deductions from wages.

4) A new Unemployment Act to provide work at Trade Union rates of pay.

5) Abolition of Chinese labour in South Africa.

6) State pensions at age 60.

7) An extension of the Housing of Working Classes Act.

8) Adult Suffrage.

9) Payment of Returning Utticers tees by the excnequer. 11L_ TAL 10) Establishment of an 8 hour At the election the Tories were routed. The Liberals won an overall majority, but Labour won 29 seats. In addition to these Labour had the support of 24 more MPs including 14 elected from mining districts with the backing of the Miners reueration who finally adhered to the Labour Party in 1909.

Result

As a result of the election the Trades Disputes Bill was passed in 1906, protecting union funds from the threat of legal action by amaliane for laccac incurred LICULAN during a strike — the law whose provisions the present Tory government's anti-union laws have been gradually eroding.

The Labour platform in 1906 was not socialist. Yet in some ways the political arguments in the movement then - when the hold of bureaucracy was substantial, but not as strong as today — can teach us lessons.

Take for example the issue of immigration. Labour's record in recent decades has been disgusting. Harold Wilson's 196470 Labour government introduced the first set of postwar immination laure in 106R wai mungtauvi laws m 1700 and the 1974-79 Labour government administered the Tories' 1971 Immigration Act without any attempt to repeal it.

1905 was the year of Britain's first-ever immigration law, the Aliens Act, directed against Jewish immigrants from Russia and Eastern Europe. Cama tundo sulle taue umon caucrs were equivocal on this issue, but the 1905 TUC Congress opposed the Aliens Bill. TUC President James Sexton described it as an appeal to stupid blind prejudice" to gain votes at the next election. "It is claimed." he said, "that this Bill will relieve the sweated workpeople by prohibiting the introduction of cheap labour from other contries.

"The political dishonesty of the measure needs no other argument than the fact that while the promoters profess to shut out undesirables from the UK in order to help the British workmen here, they rushed a measure through to introduce the most undesirable kind of cheap labour into South Africa. " Indentured workers from China had been imported to the South African gold mines to make good the shortage of cheap black labour after the Boer War.

The trade unions attitude towards protectionism contrasts more starkly with today. Protectionism versus Free Trade was a major issue int he 1906 General Election. The Tories wanted protection, the Liberals, free trade. The Tories represented certain branches of industry concerned ahout competition from the US. Germany, etc.; the Liberals, other branches of industry and finance capitalists.

The TUC refused to be drawn towards either panacea. At the TUC the argument was put by Sexton as follows. "Protection will but bind our fetters closer, and give the monopolist greater advantage inan ever. rree trauc TunAn can only be developed in the true sense of the word when the freedom of produce has been secured, not for the benefit of the few, but for the benefit of mankind."

War After the First World War the Labour Party expanded massively, adopted a statement of socialist aims, and rejigged its structure in response to ferment in the working class. Lenin advised the British Communists to join the Labour Party and to work within it for their ideas in an organised way, as an affiliated party.

The CP's main forerunner — the British Socialist Party, formed by a left-wing split from the SDF in 1916 - had been affiliated to the Labour Party. But many enthusiastic young Communists could not see the point of affiliation. The finallv conceded Lenin's argument, but the Communist Party's request for affiliation was phrased in such a manner that was guaranteed to create opposition, and it was turned down.

Even so, many Communists held dual membership of the CP and the Labour Party for many years, and were able to bulla support through the National Left Wing Movement which had the support of a quarter of all Constituency Labour Parties before they were expelled.

The young CP's sectarian attirude to the Labour Party has been copied by numerous other Marxist' groups since, like the SWP today, who, having built a small following inside the Labour Party, have developed illusions of grandeur, written the Labour Party off as bankrupt, and gone off to proclaim themselves as saviours of the working class.

A warning against tnis kind or Li LinA f sectarianism was sounded by the Communist International at its Second Congress when it was still a revolutionary tion.

Zinoviev commented:

"As the experiences of the Russian Revolution teach us remember this in England and America! - the most important thing is to stay in the midst of the masses of workers. You will often go wrong with them, but never leave the mass organisations of the working class, however reactionary they may be at any given moment.

What the sectarians fail to understand, and what must be understood by anyone seeking to re-found the Labour Party, is that the Labour Party was created by the trade unions as a political extension of their already developed reformist ideology and practices. It was not the Labour Party that created reformism, but the trade unions.

In setting up the Labour Party the trade unions shaped it around its own reformist ideology.

Leon Trotsky, commenting on Stalin's support for, the Anglo-Russian Committee between Russian trade unions and the leaders of the TUC during the General Strike, said:

*the policy of the Anglo-Russian Committee was based on the fiction of trade union autonomy: the party of MacDonald and Thomas is one thing taught Stalin, but the trade unions of Thomas and Purcell quite another. The trade unions and the Labour Party, insisted Trotsky, were 'not two principles but a division of labour' "In England more than anywhere else, the State rests upon the back of the working class which constitutes the overwhelming majority of the population. The mechanism is such that the bureaucracy is based directly on the workers, and the State indirectly through intermediarv of the trade union bureaucracy.

Obviously the trade union bureaucrats and Labour Party leaders are not identical to the bosses, they do not have the same immediate interests. The top trade union officials and the Labour leaders balance between the bosses and the workers -forced to defend the working class to the extent that attacks on it threaten their own status and bargaining power, but at the same time doing their utmost to retain control over any working class action for fear that it will go beyond the level of just seeking reforms and compromises.

Re-found

To re-found the Labour Party we must first of all fight for the same kind of reforms in the trade unions as were won in the Labour Party in 1978-82, and to open up ine trade umons to poutical discussion.

We also need to build non-sectarian rank-and-file organisation with a revolutionary class struggle basis, using the Minority Movement of the 1920s as a model. Had such an organisation existed during the miners' strike it could have co-ordinated solidarity action that would have made the difference between victory and defeat. Such an organisation could also fight to ensure that the trade union block votes at Labour Party Conference really reflected the rank and file of the trade unions and that they were cast against the 11.. L 11. and amniont tha right wingers and sott letts rather than being their base of support.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 251

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →