Why the WRP went bad Bald mass revolutionary
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
4,000 at Alexandra Palace rahy say Below: (abridged) text of appeal by SO after the WRP sued elow: (abridged) text of appeal by So after the WRe sued us for libel in 1981. Opposite page, right: letter from Banda to people who supported our appeal
For most Marxists active in
the labour movement, the latest revelations about the WRP are no surprise at all.
Groups and shades of opinion on the left regularly criticise and even denounce each other. But implicitly anyway many people on the left have long recognised that the WRP was something different.
Practically all other shades of left-wing opinion were able to work together in the miners' support groups during the 1984-5 strike. Not the WRP. It pursued alien, bizarre politics, as remote from Marxism as alchemy is from modern metallurgy.
How did the WRP become like that? Its pre-history dates back to the 1940s, when Gerry Healy became prominent in the then-unified British Trotskyist movement as an advocate of work in the In the late '40s and early 'SOs - with the cold war, a capitalist boom, and the expansion of Stalinism - the Trotskyist ranks were drastically thinned. Healy became the leading figure in the decimated movement because of his flair and energy as an organiser - unhindered by the theoretical scruples which paralysed many comrades in those difficult days.
For political theory the Healy group depended heavily on the US Socialist Workers' Party, led by James P. Cannon; and, despite. viciously undemocratic regime from the start and a correspondingly crude and primitive level of argument on many issues, it did some good work.
In the early 1960s it recruited fast in the Young Socialists. This success set it off on a sectarian binge.
At the same time it broke its international connections with the Us SwP, thus losing any restraint on Healy's characteristic use of "theory' as an instrument to be manipulated arbitrarily according to the organisational needs of 'building the party The Healy group pulled out of the Labour Party. It became more and more selfdeluding and sectarian, presenting all of politics as a single combat between itself and the rest of the world. Its proclamations of the collapse of capitalism became more and more hysterical.
Vietnam Milestones along this road were the 'Tate affair' - when a socialist selling literature outside a Healy group meeting was badly beaten up and Healy's denunciation of the big October 1968 demonstration against the Vietnam war as a plot to divert people from "building the party". RAL COMMITTEE OF The WRP's des James P. $ Cannon once remarked that small, isolated groups of socialists, closeted together in a room, can easily talk themselves into the wildest notions. The entire activity of the Healy group -from 1973 it was called the WRP - became like that closed room.
A whole ideological and organisational system cut it off from checking its ideas against reality. If the world looked different to you from what the WRP said, that was because you didn't think 'dialectically'. If things went wrong, that was because of the relentless conspiracy against the WRP of the Stalinists, reformists and "revisionlack of zeal by WRP members.
From 1969 the Healy group ha i a daily paper, the for libel in rent into crazy politics: Build the Workers Press. But what was once the most serious group of the tar lett was becoming increasingly marginal to the labour movement Rv the mid-70s it was no longer a factor in industry and the trade unions (except in the actors' union Equity!
Workers' Press
In 1976 Workers Press mysteriously folded, and shortly afterwards Newsline appeared. Although the WRP's once-impressive army of paper-sellers had dwindled to a scrappy battalion, the new paper was fatter and more lavish.
How was it done? The WRP's politics had also changed. In the early '70s they had denounced Libya's ruler Gaddafi (inaccurately) as a fascist. Now they hailed The daily paper that leads the fight against the Tory government varty' became the answer to each him as a great revolutionary. The new WRP press printed Libyan publications. The WRP-made film, "The Palestinian' toured Arah conntries. Many concluded that VUMIL the WRP's ample funds came not from any working-class support but from its relations with oil-rich governments.
Is it all the logical conclusion of sectarian, self-righteous, self-isolating politics? Yes - up to a point. A sect, however, may have serious and worthwhile ideas; what has distinguished the WRP is that ideas are utterly secondary to organisational selfpromotion.
Addled Rather than being the polar opposite to the t oad labour movement's mai line politics, its indifference and In Wadnasday's Workers Press Sid Harma-cy g 91795 200 Jobs-forwages tad and every question stoppiness about socialist ideas, the WRP has been an addled version of it. And its internal atrocities are no more inan an addled version of the bureaucratic domination and privilege which cripples the respectable mainstream institutions of the labour movement.
Rebound
Indifference and sloppiness allowed the WRP to make a limited re-entry into the labour movement in recent years. Socialist Organiser sounded the alarm when the WRP turned up in force at a cuts conference in early 1981. The WRP through Vanessa Redgrave sued us for libel. Many on the left advised us to make an apology. 'We know about the ted on the WRP presses on terms which have allowed it to survive as a full-colour weekly with no visible organised network of sellers, and with a managing editor long associated with the WRP. Many prominent figures on the left - Tony Benn, Arthur Scargill - have chosen to shut their eyes to the evidence of the Herald's links with the WRP, and to speak at its rallies.
In 1982 the WRP in alliance with Ted Knight hijacked the Labour Campaign for Palestine: Socialist Action went WRP went, alone sath the but it's not worth making a fuss?.
Soon afterwards Labour Herald' was launched - prinattacking those who fought to maintain a genuine Palestine campaign as Socialist Organiser sectarians.
Split Such behaviour by people on the left will rebound on them now, and will help our common enemies use the WRP scandal to smear the whole left. When we insisted on branding the WRP as a group alien to the labour movement, it was not 'sectarian but a necessary hygienic task.
The way to rid the labour movement of the poison of bureaucratism - in both its mainstream and its addled WRP forms - is clarity, honesty and courage in the battle of ideas.