Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Standing up to the millionaire Marxists'

Socialist Organiser no. 251, 7 November 1985 · scan pp. 8–9 · Sean Matgamna · about 1,410 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The WRP's attempt to use the surts against SO is an attack on ee speech, on free comment id on free debate within the bour movement. It shows what tle confidence the WRP has in s ability to make a political resonse to our comments on them 0 33).

Why does the WRP choose is course of action? Because D's outspoken comments on em threaten their central proct of the moment.

They are making a concenited effort to rebuild support r the WRP in Lambeth. In an fort to regain some credibility ey ave entered the service of e right wing and of Ted Knight 1o leads a big section of the ft in Lambeth.

They swung what weight they ve behind Ted Knight's foreomed policy of trying to fend f the Tory cuts drive by hiking › the rates and rents. Now they pport Knight's 10% general t - the proof positive of the inkruptcy of Knight's antiery policy.

Meanwhile Newsline, snarlg at the left, makes its characFistic contribution by spitting the e slander that we are Thatcher's people" : A Newse editorial seriously equated e Socialist Workers Party with e National Front because both Organiser no. 251 7 November oppose rate rises in Lambeth.

The WRP has set up one of their so-called Youth Training Centres in Lambeth.

But the Youth Training Centres are run by a political party which for the last 20 years has gained its only (transitory) successes from recruiting politically raw young people to its ranks.

Politically the WRP is today an unknown force to most labour movement activists, who would naturally incline towards toleration of it. The SO article argued against toleration of the WRP. especially as people fit to offer "training' to vulnerable young The result was a writ against the printer and against Sean Matgamna (who usually writes for SO under the anglicised version of his name, John O'Mahony).

Apology?

Why not make a formal tongue-in-cheek apology? For a number of important reasons. In the first place SO values its own repuation as a responsible and serious non-sectarian socialist paper.

In the second place, it is an important matter of principle for a working class newspaper like SO not to allow itself to be bludgeoned into silence by Ms Redgrave's money, which is being used on behalf of the WRP leadership, even though her money gives her an enormous advantage in litigation.

Equal?

Redgrave and ourselves are, of course, equal before the corts. But the libel laws are a rich person's option. No libelled striker or victimised shop stewards ever has, in reality, such an option, though it does exist in law. It is part of the general problem of formal equality under capitalism encapsulated in Anatole France's apt description: "The law in its majestic equality forbids the rich as well as the poor to steal bread, to sleep under bridges and to beg for food"* Free speech and free comment are vitally important for the labour movement. They are irreplaceable where its own affairs and the affairs of those who claim to be part of it are concerned.

Thirdly, the original article was a blow in a necessary and struggle in Lambeth. That conflict continues: the political health of the labour movement in Lambeth and perhaps other areas will be affected by whether or not the point of view of SO can be expressed and heard by the labour movement. We are not prepared to abandon our viewpoint or be silenced because the WRP is richer than we are.

And while a tongue-incheek apology would provoke a cynical wink from those in the know, it would add considerably to the problems of the uninitiated — young people in the Youth Training Centres, for example - in getting to know what's what. They are the people who most need the benefits of free comment.

Honesty

Fourthly, given that our real opinion is that SO should in honesty defend the article in court, to make an insincere apology would be to allow ourselves to be forced to tell lies under the compulsion of Ms Redgrave's wealth.

We are not prepared to tell lies to the labour movement or to the youth. That is in general a rock-basic rule. It is urgent to preach it and to live by it because for fifty years deliberate and systematic lying and other falsifications of truth have been a major movement.

Spreading outward from the totalitarian Stalinist state via the Stalinist parties, the politics of lies and double talk, of the double standard or none, of 'anything goes' for my organisation or for my faction, the politics of the numbed or dead conscience and of the supple spine - these have wreaked havoc with the political consciousness and the political morality of the labour movement. They are not the sort of politics SO exists to promote.

Not for nothing did Leon Trotsky preach and insist again and again that one of the first principles of revolutionary politics was 'to tell the truth to the labour movement and to the masses' We subscribe to Trotsky's principle. And we will fight for it.

Fifthly, while the WRP uses the courts and the threat of bankruptcy to present SO with the option of paying out a lot of money or denying its opinions by issuing a formal apology that would be a lie, the WRP's own press spews out its libels against socialist opponents of such a volume and at such speed as to deserve at least a nomination for the Stalin prize for mendacity.

Scan page 9

KENNINGTON Park Road, South London, last Saturday, 2nd. Four people are selling "Newsline' as they wait for the anti-apartheid march to come by. Two men and two women; all of them are in their late 20s or early 30s.

Suddenly half-brick comes whizzing through the air from the other side of the road and lands at their feet. It has been thrown by a burly man, also about 30.

The brick is only the start.

steady rain of stones follows the brick across the road, and soon the intrepid four take refuge in the rhododendron bushes.

Triumphantly, the bombardier then jumps on a wall, raises both hands above his head after the fashion of football fans, and chants 'Healy! Healy! Healy!' Then he drops back into the housing estate.

After the events of the WRP's week, it's a wonder they haven't been going for each with guns and knives! The picture of what Gerry Healy reversed the decision that Healy would retire. A minority led by Banda revolted and appealed to the Central Committee, whose majority backed them.

They decided on drastic action against Healy, and grabbed the weapons to hand Hence the charges.

For the Bandaites it was probably a matter of survival. Theirs is a world where nobody has the right to disagree with the caliph, where disagreement 1S heresy against the leader in his capacity as pontiff and treason against him in his capacity as monarch. To 'conspire' and lose, or to usurp and be overthrown, is to lose your head.

Healy has politically 'executed' other long-time associates for a lot less than forcing him to retire. For example, Tim Wolforth, leader of the US clone group for a dozen years, was purged because he was slow to join Healy when Healy denounced Wohlforth's wife as a CIA agent.

It Healy regained control his defeated opponents. would not have lasted long. So lapsed and fell apart the leadership of Ted and Jock Haston If today there s justice in his treatment at hands of his pupils, as essential truth in what say against him, that is measure of how degenera Healy had become.

Machiavelli might draw

lesson for him thus: 'He w rules by fear and terror should not live to get old an feeble' Politically the Bandantes are in a hopeless situation Everything they say against Healy condemns them 100 They were not rank and file activists or raw youth but Healy's close associates many, many years.

And what WRP traditio exists apart from the one Gerry Healy made and shaped for three decades? What do they know about politics except what he taught them? What have they ever been but Gerry Healy's stooges, deter ring when they felt inclime to take a view different from his?

Teeth Some of them may have

----- pull-quotes -----

unavoidable political conflict with the WRP arising out of the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 251

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →