The WRP proves us right
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
You have signed a statement unions and the broad labour these statements have nothing to which Vanessa: Redgrave has happened in the WRP is now reasonably clear.
The organisation has split down the middle. The Healy faction's claim that they have the majority of the members of the old organisation on their side may even be true. The bourgeois press credits the old WRP with five to seven thousand members, but was probably not more than one-tenth of that.
So when the Bandaites jeer that Healy only has 250 supporters, they are admitting. that he has something like half the organisation.
The Healyites have declared their expelled Central Committee minority to be the WRP, and claim to have held a special conference which "rejected" Gerry Healy's expuslion and instead expelled Michael Banda and the other "conspirators' who raised their hands against the great leader.
Their resolution explicitly gave Healy a special place in the WRP, making it an article of faith to believe Gerry Healy to be "the outstanding leader of the world Trotskyist movement in the post-war period". They have brought out one issue of their own "Newsline' (eight pages and without any sports section -which undoubtedly points to a propagandist deviation by them away from mass work) and an issue of 'Young Socialist'. They have launched an appeal for £250,000 to bring out their 'Newsline' daily from next January.
Gerry Healy is accused of sexual abuse of 26 and more women. This salacious 'red-inthe-bed' stuff has been spread all over the tabloid press for the last week. But by far the most important and interesting developments have been the other charges that the Bandaites have laid against id violence to coerce young omen comrades into sexual tivity with him. We were ed for saying that the orglisation 'exploited' raw sung people. 4. Newsline now denouns the Healy faction for havg a morality of 'anything es for the organisation'. 5. They challenge the ealy-Redgrave faction to sue em if what they say is not ue. "In the days when they Luc. ›minated the Workers' Revutionary Party, newspapers, ›litical opponents, trade nionists and individuals who appened to cross them were lowered with writs" (Newsne 5.11.85). You can say lat again!
Paranoid
6. Banda describes Healy "a classic case of schizoid aranoia". Classic case or not, e has been publicly paranoid ›r at least a quarter of a entury.
7. Banda denounces ealy's works on dialectical iaterialism, long the bible on hich WRP members were ained, as "an outrageous iece of charlatanism"
8. Banda denounces Healy or justifying the execution f Communist Party members y the vile Ba'athist regime in ag. Reports have appeared L one bourgeois paper that lilitants from Iraq who came › the WRP school were later urned over to the Iraqi gime, which killed them. anda is quoted as saying nat the motive was to get bags of money"
It is not clear whether this true or not, though people within the WRP claim to h evidence that at least • person was so denounced the Iraqi government.
Explosion There are also some political shifts by the Bandaites, adding up to a small move away from the lunacy of Healy and towards a slightly more realistic appreciation of the world they actually live in. It is still too early to assess this, because many things are bviously being said tor nect, and the anti-Healy WRP has not settled down politically yet.
The probable reasons for the explosion and its dynamics are now pretty clear also. Healy had agreed to take a back seat or retire, no doubt under pressure, but apparently with the agreement of some who are now his supporters. But Healy is a halfcrazy - and sometimes completely crazy — old man, who would not find that congenial.
There may have been political differences or nuances in play, but that would have had no autonomous weight. Healy seems to have been forced to sign a written agreement to retire. But the Political Committee bloc that had pushed for his retirement then began to break up, Two prominent WRP leaders, Mitchell and Torrance, seem to have changed sides, and perhaps others did too. The Political Committee Banda and his allies acted as Healy had long taught them to act: brutally and without concern for decency, credibility or consistency.
The WRP's atmosphere was satured with incipient or actual violence, intimidation and terror. The organisation was a cult, built on the leader principle around Healy. Within it Healy did more or less what he liked.
It is as certain as anything is that in that organisation sexual exploitation, and where necessary harassment, intimidation, or worse, would be part of the great leader's way of life.
In one notorious case know the people involved Healy beat up a woman comrade, a full-time organiser, because she wanted an abortion rather than to have his baby. (This is probably the case that got to the Control Commission in 1964 - she had two brothers and a husband in the organisation, one on the Central Committee.
But nevertheless it is also true that a considerable part of the ballyhoo against Healy's sexual antics is both frame-up and an appeal to backwardness. Insofar as anything was voluntary in the WRP, many of the 'harem 26' must have acted voluntarily.
Revolutionary
Despite the political and personal weaknesses and inadequacies that over 20 years ago turned Gerry Healy into a bitter enemy of the Trotskyism he set in in his youth to fight for, Healy was once a revolutionary. He was one of a small group at the end of the '40s and the beginning of the '50s who had the courage to set out to rebuild the Trotskyist movement when it colgritted their teeth , at variows times - but if so, that's al they did. Whether or not th WRP turned would-be com munists over to the Ba'athist execution squads in Iraq, the WRP's public justification of the execution of CPers by the Iraqi government was there in black and white in 'Newsline?.
And 'party discipline' is no excuse for going along with Healy and the WRP across the class line - in glorifying the Iraqi regime, or Gaddafi for example.
Banda's attempt to 'blame Healy' is already going to preposterous lengths. Did Michael Banda and others beat up a Central Committee member in the north-west last June? Yes. 'But Healy told me to', says Banda!
Nobody who went through Healy's 'machine for maiming militants' will fail to find some satisfaction in the present explosion. Public vindication for Socialist Organiser's stand against the WRP is, of course, satisfying.
But if the Healyites and Bandaites eat each other up like the Kilkenny cats, that won't undo the damage they have done to the Marxist movement and to the name of Marxism in the British labour movement.
We can only undo the damage by building the Marxist movement.
Honest members of the WRP can take the word of the Banda faction leaders for nothing. They should study the record, debate the issues that have divided the WRP from other leftists - like those who support Socialist Organiser - and break out of the WRP ghetto and into discussion with other socialists.