Fusing art and action?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Agency to coordinate and opposea, but the resolution was enforce environmental laws (and carried by a two to one majority.
It also voted for a commitment conference, TGWU votes helped year 2000 and for a "hazard" half a million votes. This year its nuclear waste reprocessing seconded the crucial composite plant. which was carried by 3,902,000 The most momentous change to 2,408,000, missing a twonuclear power. Hitherto, while thirds majority by only 300,000 rejected the Pressurised Water Thus, despite an emphatie Reaction design from the USA, vote, the policy will not necesthey have supported the British- sarily feature in the next election designed Magnox and Advanced manifesto. We need to camThe key to the change may it be included and also that have been the growing realisa- Labour's environment spokes(the difficulties of coping with-n Cunningham, be replaced.. tion in the labour movement of person, pro-nuclear John Young plotters prepare for action in one of Mishima's stories Socialist Organiser na. 251. Z. November 1985' Pagè 10 What is the relationship between art and politics, between an artist and political activity? 'Mishima: a life in four chapters' examines one artist's answer.
In 1970, Yukio Mishima, a Japanese writer, occupied a military headquarters with four members of his private army, and then committed ritual suicide.
By L Most political parties pay lip-service to the environment these days — including the National Front ("'Grey squirrels go home!"). More interesting to us is Labour's claim that its "commitment to the environment is well-known"
As 1 pointed out last week, this isn't saying much. However, all that could change following the Labour Party Conference.
Most important was the historic break with nuclear power (see below), but the party discussed and decided other important environmental policies.
SERA members must claim much credit for raising and pushing these policies in CLPS and trade unions, well as arguing for them at Labour Party conference.
Policy
For example, there was a large number of motions on fuel policy which were composited to make a strong statement against nuclear power, for measures to remove sulphur from coal (reducing the acid rain problem; for research into oil-from-coal; for research into alternative renewable energy; for energy conservation and recycling of waste and for planning alternative employment for workers in the nuclear industry. This got nearly four million votes (over 60%).
Conference voted for an Environmental Protection for a Minister for Conservation).
to cut acid rain by 75% by the enquiry into the Sellafield of direction for Labour was over Labour Party conferences have votes.
Gas-Cooled Reactor designs.
Edward Ellis reviews "Mishima: a life in four chapters', , now showing the Lumiere cinema.
Through this act, Mishima used art and action: death to revent the decay of his own beautiful body', and s i symbolHearn radioactive waste. The policy of dumping it into the sea (particularly the Irish Sea) has become more and more unpopuTar and at times it has seemed as though Sellafield was incapable of even getting the waste that far, dropping it instead on nearby beaches.
The National Union of Seamen has led the trade union wing of the attack on sea-dumping of radioactive waste, with land transport workers following. However, trade unions have generally supported the nuclear power industry on grounds of defending jobs. Revelations of higher rates of deaths from radiation-linked diseases among nucler workers has weakened that support.
The links between the nuclear industry and bomb duction have also weakened support, At the TGWU's September conference, SERA supporter Colin Aherne moved a resolution calling for the closure of nuclear power stations on the grounds that nuclear power was dangerous, expensive, unnecessary. required infringements of civil liberties and was intimately bound up with production of nuclear weapons. It also called for alternative work for nuclear workers.
Carried
As in previous years, the NEC At the 1984 Labour Party defeat an anti-nuclear motion by votes went the other way.
SERA supporters moved and paign and argue and insist that prothat ically preserve an achievement far greater than 'mere words', and a gesture of traditionalist revolt at the moral decay of postwar Japan.
Ideologically, and in practical politics, Mishima was fascistic, it not plainly fascist (1 know too little about him to judge). He believed that Japan had lost its "spirit; that the army should be its spiritual salvation and that the route to spiritual salvation lay through a revival of the cult of the Samurai and worship of the Emperor, He created a private army, the Shield Society, bonded together by a mystical cult of masculinity. And the purpose of his final dramatic action, at the overtly political level, was an attempt to rouse the army into revolt.
It is possible to infer also that Mishima's ideology included a typically fascist anti-capitalism'. based in his case in defence of the imperial state.
Mishima's view of art shapes this ideological persuasion, shown in the film through dramatisations of three of the writer's novels. One story follows an attempted anticapitalist' plot by a group of young soldiers. The plot tails, and the main character kills himself in the traditional way.
Another story concerns the discovery by its central character of 'art' via a brutally masochistic relationship with an older woman, who buys his life and body in return for writing off his mother's debts.
The film skilfully weaves these stories into an account of Mishima's own life. From childhood weakling he transformed himself into a healthy adult through body-building, which became a preoccupation fed both by his fascination with martial art, and his homosexuality — tascination with the male body. There is some hint of childhood repression as the source of later preoccupations, artistic, political and sexual.
Scant
Unfortunately, Mishima's widow insisted as a condition for the film to be made, that scant reference only be made to Mishima's sexualitv. As a result it is an obviously central theme that remains unexplored A clear danger with such subject matter would be to glorify it, to portray Mishima as the noble hero surrounded by spiritual mediocrity. I have read criticisms to the effect that both Schrader and his producers who inelude Francis Coppola and George Lucas are oversympathetic to Mishima. They may be: I don't know. But this is not the impression left by the film.
It keeps a distance from Mishima and his ideas. The dramatisations of Mishima's stories are highly stylised theatre pieces. Flashbacks to his own life are filmed in black and white.
The film attempts to unravel Mishima's concerns and obsessions, to uncover the rationale behind his bizarre death. But it attempts to explain Mishima's actions at the artistic, rather than political level. The political Mishima addresses the army conclusions flow from a preoccupation with the relationship between "art' and 'action'; a relationship that for Mishima could only be consumated in death. His political ideas were infused with, and inseparable from these philosophical ponderings on aesthetics.
Imperial
It is this artistic focus that explains the film's political detachment. And in terms of this focus, it is successful. Mishima's ritual suicide is convincingly portrayed as an artistic triumph (though a political fiasco).
Perhaps Mishima's apparent derangement can be explained in the context only of his art. I am not qualified to judge. But I am not convinced.
"Mishima ' gives little insight into the social and political background in post-war Japan. The social conditions that cave rise to the Shield Society - which, apparently, was at least tolerated by the Japanese establishment — are not explained. It is all posed at the exclusive level of the artist's individual psychology. And especially given that the film, despite its Japanese cast, is made for an English-speaking audience who will not know much about these conditions, this is unsatisfactory.
But it is an impressive film visually stunning and with an excellent score by Philip Glass. It is to be hoped that it will be shown in cheaper cinemas than London's 'Lumiere'. It deserves
Scan page 11
While the NUT and AMMA