Control-but by whom?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Big loopholes nationalisations or class struggle company identifies "ample 'radical break' from traditiona in the period immediately before Among themselves, however, *any new legislation Socialist Organiser no.252 14 November 1985 Page 4 "A radical break", "a massive advance", "a light year ahead of any popular economic pamphlet produced on the left for a very long time" . Socialist Actic devoted its centre pages last week to enthusing about Andrew Glyn's pamphlet A Million Jobs a Year' The great virtue of the pamRoy Hattersley thinks that his scheme for manipulating financial institutions' tax concessions is a brilliant way of getting plan-. К нашим манисал non nod invoctmont without and or anything of that sort. phlet, Socialist Action argues, is that it understands that nationalisation must flow from a struggle for "control of capital".
It is true that revolutionary nationalisations generally do come out of a struggle for workers' control: Portugal in 1975, where workers first took over the running of their factories, then financiers are pointing our that won't work In the November Monthly Investment Report' , an investment ernert from an incuranoo scope to develop loopholes in demanded nationalisation, is ınla But what Socialist Action misses — and it's hardly a mino point - is the difference between workers' control of industry and government control of industry.
Sometimes the two may converge, where it is a workers" government accountable to the working class. But al a time when Roy Hattersley is touring bosses' conferences assurinatham that ă lahana niramn ment will "listen to indus- g tient that d Laooul governtry" more than the Tories, it is foolish to suppose that the next Labour government will be any such thing.
The Glyn policy, with the gloss that Socialist Action puts on it, is in fact a stateaphansi poncy. rar from being Labour Keynesianism, it is a: radical version of it. Healy's talk of building a revolutionary leadership.
Perhaps Foot's article helps to explain why, despite all its absurdities, Healy's group was able for so long to recruit many of the best revolutionaries in the movement — and so criminally to mislead them.
Stress Unemployment makes you ill. A survev by a team of doctors of the medical records of workers at a Wiltshire factory which closed in 1982 and their families has shown that after they lost their jobs they visited doctors 20% more often, and hospital out-patients' departments 60% more oiten.
Rates of illness also increacer the closure when the workers were under stress.
Scan page 5
Last month, a new socialist journal, 'International", began publication, founded by a group of comrades disillusioned with the latest turn in the politics of "Socialist Action'. In this open letter to 'International wA lonk at the maior issues confronting the Left.
Moring towards Kinnock: Ken Livingstone Theorising the drift: Tribune editor Nigel Williamson ROY HATTERSLEY is touring bosses' conferences assuring them that the next Labour government will "listen to industry" more than the Tories, and that Labour leaders believe in *the importance of high profits".
Meanwhile Neil Kinnock declares brusquely that any promise that Labour will create a job for every school-leaver would be "a lie"
Kinnock and Hattersley feel firm ground under their feet to promise a safe capitalist administration partly because the miners' defeat has inevitably depressed and demoralised the labour movement.
But the depression and demoralisation is very far from total. Strike figures are already beginning to increase again. The confidence of the working class. will revive.
The question is: can the left make sure that the labour movement does better in the next big struggle than it did in the miners' strike? Is the left doing what is possible now - regrouping. building on the crash political education that thousands received in the miners' strike, stiffening that education with a core of Marxist ideas, consolidating?
Depression On the whole it isn't. On the whole both the broad left and the would-be Marxist left are suffering from, rather than limiting and combatting, the general depression in the movement.
There are some positive developments, however: and we see your break from Socialist Action as one of those. That is why we are writing this open letter.
The Marxist left is more isolared than it has been for some time. Large sections of the erstwhile Bennite left have run for cover. The local government left, having submitted to Thatcher, is also submitting to Kinnock. Even honest socialists who were mobilised in support of the miners can see no option but to knuckle under to the Kinnock strategy for the next Labour government.
The socialism of managers rather than tighters, socialism 'from above' , Is still central to the left, despite the lessons of the latest local government fiasco and decades of Stalinism and Fabianism. It can mislead and hamstring even the bravest class fighters.
It affects even the avowedly anti-Stalinist groups.
MillanES uisasuuus vurcaucratic tactics in Liverpool, focusing everything around the prestige of the "socialist council' rather than the mobilisation of the workers, are a fresh example.
The Socialist Workers' Party proclaims socialism from below.
But through their sectarian abstention from the struggles in the Labour Party they bear a large responsibility for the success of Kinnock's programme of socialism - or rather, mildly revamped capitalism - from above. Their only answer to the buttama of the lahaur movement 1s get out and SWP!
What of Socialist Action? A drift to semi-Stalinist politics internationally has gone together with an increasingly sectarian style but minimal content in their politics within the British labour movement.
They accept a monopoly for the ANC over the struggle against apartheid. They reject any notion of independent working-class politics in Cuba or Nicaragua. More and more, they see world politics as a matter of struggle between progressive and reactionary power-blocs. and their role as identifying and tagging along behind the leaders of the progressive bloc.
Scenario
They have adopted the same method in British politics. Arthur Scargill is declared to be the Daniel Ortega, the Fidel Castro, or the Gerry Adams of British politics - the leader of the next wave of History. And all specific questions of class politics are dissolved into this scenario.
What is the role of Socialist Action in the scenario? They are the philosophers who thanks to deep "theory' know where the next wave of History is going. And thus - like many another devotee of socialist fatherlands far away — in practice they are often sectarian and ultimatist.
That they denounce practically all the groups of the Labour Left, even the broadest, as 'ultra-left' does, to be sure, make them a bit different from more ordinary sectarians who would denounce those groups as reformist. But the practical result is much the same.
Your break with Socialist Action is, as we understand it, due to these trends in their politics. You reject their semi-Stalinism. Without resorting to the politics of self-regarding denunciation, you reject their frantic selfabasement before whomever they find to be the leaders designated by History. You insist on a serious intervention within the Labour Left.
These ideas we have in common with you. That is why we have written to you proposing discussions and joint work, up to and including a joint weekly paper (through giving your group an equal say on the editorial board of Socialist Organiser).
For such joint work we will need to work out political common ground and our differences, to be defined precisely and discussed in a comradely fashion.
We should, therefore, outline the main issues which seem to need discussion.
Your work in the Labour Party is oriented heavily, indeed centrally, to Briefing. We too are in favour of participating in Briefing. But we think a political demarcation from the Briefing tradition is necessary.
Briefing was launched as the result of a split from Socialist Organiser by those wno supported rate rises as a response to Tory cuts in local government. The experience of recent years. which we analysed in our pamphlet Illusions of Power' has condemned that strategy conclusively. Yet the leading people in Briefing do not draw the necessary lessons. In fact, at every crucial testing-point in the evolution of the local government left they have been inadequate, muddled, or clearly on the wrong side.
This issue of assessment of Briefing is connected, perhaps. with a more fundamental one: socialist economic policy, and our relation to traditional British 'socialism'.
Briefing has never really discussed the basic ideas of socialism. In our view it has obscured the differences between working-class self-liberation and "state socialism' with its mystical and mystifying slogan Labour take the power"
Similar confusion, in our view, is evident in the document circulated by the Campaign Group of MPs and written by Andrew Glyn, entitled 'One million jobs a year'. . This document has at least opened debate on economic policy. But it calls for state controls over capital; it advocates, essentially, a revamped version of the classic policy of Keynes, "a somewhat comprehensive socialisation of investment".
Pamphlet
Vague talk of worker "involvenent in decision-making' is far sutweighed by the fact that the pamphlet everywhere talks of nore control by the existing itate, and clearly indicates (by alk of increasing capital gains axes, etc.) that the capitalist class would remain in place.
only subject to more state regulation.
We were not surrised to see Socialist Action applauding this pamphlet with customary extravagance. We were somewhat disappointed that you comment approvingly:
... once you make planning agreements compulsory... and change (company) boards of directors, then private ownership would increasingly become a legal taction. The process taking Piace is really the nationalisation of the monopolies"
Statist
You call this "the so answer to the NEC distance yourself from the Photo: Andrew Moore rromising a safe captranst aur ualist. statist implications only with the warning that the ruling class would try "every means to bring the government down"
So if only the government could get away with it, that would be socialism? It is not likely that any .government, workers or capitalist, in Britain will ever attempt Glyn's programme; but programmes very similar have been carried out by many governments in the Third World, for example Egypt and Syria. Are they socialist?
To build an adequate Marxist movement in Britain we need an adequate world perspective on socialism. And in that respect too we find the first issue of your journal disappointing.
Your actual position on South Africa, as we understand it, is close to ours (we advocate a workers' party based on the non-racial trade unions, independent cialist from the UDF). But your jourand nal contents itself with a brief grad- article on the Stalinists and a SETUELUTE. nnock rather bland declaration by th USFI.
Nicaragua has been central t the political evolution of Socia ist Action, and the whole inter national current of which it i part, over the last six years. Ye on this central issue your journ is non-committal: "it is possibl to agree or to disagree" yo write, with the Sandinistas all ances with the bourgeoisie.
To learn the lessons of Socia ist Action's turn away from Tro skyism towards blind imitatic of the Sandinistas, it is nece sary, we think, to see this ep sode (and the pro-ANC turn d South Afiica) as the latest devi lopment of a long-standin method.
Time and again the Sociali Action current has identifie with a vaguely-defined proce of "Revolution' - classles nameless, self-propelling seeing working-class action only a desirable contribution 1 that process. Yugoslavia, Chin Algeria, Cuba, Vietnam - ti precedents are numerous.
Socialist Action is applyir the self-same method now to l ish politics. Shutting its eyes the fact that the Six Coun Catholic community includ only 10% or so of the Irish wor ing class, and that Catholic na ionalism cannot and will n mobilise the Southern workir class into socialist revc'ution, mystically identifies Sinn Fei with its militant base among ti Six County Catholics, as bearer of an irresistible drive 1 History towards socialist revol tion. The actual flesh-and-blo Irish working class (over 20 Protestant) disappears from ti picture in this vision of res lution.
We understand that you rej the extravagances of Social Action on this question. regret that your journal does ! include any statement on su a central question.
Today is a time when Marxist left needs to regroup, reassert basic socialist ideas :
ainst an adverse tide, and educate comrades for the futu We believe that you and could work together on this ta We need to discuss seriously.
Socialist Organiser no.252.14 November 19851