Where is China
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
State pressure through 'moral incentives is being partly replaced by financial incentives Is China going capitalist? Or has it discovered a new form of socialism? Martin Thomas looks at China's new economic policyDeng Xiaoping calls it a 'second revolution' - a drive to modernise socialism in China. The business magazine "The Economist' calls it the retreat from Marx' "The centrally planned economy of Marx, Stalin and Mao is to be stopped in its tracks and put on the market road; the traffic, if good intentions hold, will now be regulated by profits and prices rather than by bureaucrats in Peking"
What is the truth? China has never had a working-class socialist system. The revolution of 1949 was made by a peasant army entering the cities and, as it did so, issuing warnings to the workers to stay at work and not to press any demands of their own.
Monopoly
The Maoists soon established a Stalinist-type state. • Those who fought for working-class socialism, the Chinese Trotskyists, were jailed. Stage by stage, the capitalists had their property taken over by the state (with compensation); but the working class was allowed no independent voice. The bureaucracy had a monopoly of information, of communications, of politics.
Now the command economy is being drastically reshaped. The Ronnamict exaoberates however: DULLIOL China is not likely to become a free market economy. It is undertaking the same sort of changes as some East European states, though more abruptly and turbulently.
Between the collectivisation of agriculture in China, in 1958, and 1978, the Chinese economy was highly centralised. 80% of industrial production was in state enterprises (the remaining 20% being in enterprises run by regional and local government). All important prices were fixed by the state, the main ones centrally. Practically all enterprise profits went directly to the state budget, making up the ereater part of public revenue. and the central bureaucracy then allocated investment funds.
The communes in the countryside had rather more autonomy than the industrial enterprises; and centralisation on paper could conceal all sorts of make-shifts and black markets in reality. But, despite the vast size of China, and its underdevelopment and poor communications, the economy was probably more centralised than the USSR's.
It was also as isolated from the rest of the world. In the 1960s, exports were only about three per cent of China's output; in 1976, still only 5½%.
Dismantled Since 1978 the state monopoly of foreign trade has been dismantled: regions, cities, enterprises, individuals are free to trade. Foreign trade has risen fast.
Foreign investment has been encouraged, especially in four Special Economic Zones set up as free-market enclaves within China and in coastal cities. The free play of profits and prices, rather than central command, has been allowed much more scope in industry. In the countryside, the communes have been replaced by individual enterprise.
80% of China's people live in the countryside; 75% of its labour force is in agriculture. That is where the changes have been most dramatic and most successful.
From 1979 the economic functions of the communes were progressively transferred to small groups or to individuals, and food prices were raised to encourage peasants to produce more. From 1981 the communes began to divide up their land among house holds. Initially, each household got a three-year contract on their land these are now being replaced by contracts for 15 years or longer.
The communes were abolished in 1983. And this year the govern ment has scrapped the system of compulsory state purchases from peasants: it now relies on market incentives to buy what it want: from the peasants.
Some individuals producing cash crops have become quite rich, and the new system certainly has an inbuilt drive towards increasing differences between rich and poor But tensions have been relieved by a very rapid overall increase ir agricultural production.
Ill-equipped
Between 1952 and 1979 Chinese agricultural output rose by some thing over three percent per year Between 1980 and 1985 it has riser by over 9% per year.
By international standards, 3% : year is not bad, especially consider ing that China's land has long beer overcrowded and Chinese industry is ill-equipped to provide fertilisers tractors, and other machines. 9% per year is dramatic.
The 1949 revolution clearer away the landlord and usures classes, who were a drain o1 productivity. But the forced-marcl enlistment of peasants into com munes in 1958 was terribly costly It had nothing to do with Marxism wheh advocates gradual and volun tary collectivisation in agriculture especially in underdeveloped coun tries. It served only the interests o the bureaucracy, enabling it mor easily to squeeze resources out o the peasantry. The state is still th overlord of agriculture: but th relaxation of its prematur *barracks communism' has great boosted productivity.
The new economic policy h had less clear success in industry.
The major measures were f
Scan page 7
going!
According to the Financíal Times, only one foreign investment venture in China, a Hong Kongowned hotel, is actually making profits. Foreign capitalists complain that China's roads, railways and ports are inadequate; the phones do not work; power supplies are erratic; workers are unskilled; and the bureaucracy is difficult to deal with. The Chinese bureaucrats, for their part, complain that their deals with foreign capitalists are not bringing in the up-to-date technolDomestic Chinese industry has grown quite fast under the new policy, with output increasing by over 9% per year between 1980 and 1985, and a particularly big boom in 1984-5. Light industry has grown especially fast, modifying China's previous strong bias towards heavy The communes have been dissolved and China's agriculture returned to individual households TED TUVE VECTE MISJUICE UTEN thousands of contract workers, The economic changes in mainly to the Middle East - pock- Eastern Europe have generated eting well over 50% of their wages great tensions. What are the prosBut 9% per year is slightly for itself. It has also been seeking slower than China's overall average profits from Chinese investment There is more or less open rate of industrial growth since the abroad. The Chinese government opposition to Deng's reforms withearly '50s (about 10% per year in owns some $6 billion of invest- in the bureaucracy. Deng and his 1952-79, despite the effects of dis- ments in Hong Kong, and others in sothinkers have set out to purge the ruption in the Great Leap Forward the US and Australia - the total is Communist Party and slim down and the Cultural Revolution). And possibly bigger than that of foreign the armed forces, but with little the government has had great problems regulating the recent The Chinese Trotskyist journal So far the conflicts within the through in October 1984. Enter- October Review sums up the issues bureaucracy have led to one small prises now keep their profits (after Consumer-durable output has like this: "China should make use opening for the mass of the people almost the whole amount to the tax) rather than handing over vastly exceeded plans - in 1982 there were 60% more factories of foreign captial, borrow loans from abroad at low interest rates - in 1978-9 when, to rally support, Deng's faction briefly allowed relagovernment. The old system of dual Preslucing bicycles, sewing mach- (without any political conditions), tively free expression on Demomanagement, with the appointed break from the self-isolation of the cracy Wall'. The wide-ranging factory manager supervised by a allowed for in the state plan, Mao Zedong era introduce democracy movement which grew Party committee, has been replaced by the rule of single managers. A versions - and a lot of investment because of unauthorised plant con- advanced technology and equip- ment in a planned way, learn out of that brief period was even- tually crushed in April 1981, with big range of prices has been left free funds have been directed into foreign advanced experience and to float according to the markets. private or local authority building management methods (but not The state has emphasised its Factory managers are being encour- aged to increase wage differentials, projects. Billions of dollars have been siphoned off by corrupt methods to exploit the labouring cularly in the 'anti-crime' campaign repressive power since then, partito gauge wages according to pro- officials; one particular racket had of August 1983 to January 1984 when some five to ten thousand ductivity, and to sack workers more freely. New scope has been allowed made $1.5 billion, and this year some 9,000 private businesses interests of the labouring masses must be protected, they should be people summarily convicted of to private enterprise, and 20,000 illegally run by individual bureau- mobilised to intervene in politics murder, rape, or embezzlement ted in the three months October to new private small busınesses sprou- crats have been shut down. In 1984 the deputy director of and supervise and restrain capitalist death are still paraded in front of were executed. People sentenced to December 1984. There is talk of the State Statistical Bureau com- The bureaucracy does it differ- mass rallies before being taken privatising small enterprises plained that "In recent years we ently. After 1949 the urban employing | a total of 54 million could not guarantee investment on workers were given a relatively Presumably because of the rapid key state projects because there favoured material position, with job overall growth in incomes, the big was too much investment through canunits - the iron rice howl' The price rises of recent vears have as bureaucracy tried to enlist the fast- yet caused no open revolt as in China's foreign trade has risen growing industrial working class as Poland. It is not clear how much very fast, about 20% per year its social base, and drew the new working class resistance there is to between 1976 and 1983 - from recruits to its own ranks from the The four Special Economic 5½% to 9½% of national output.
Imports of consumer durables from Now a self-reproducing, "technoZones, in which specially favourable conditions are given to foreign Hong Kong and Japan have risen cratic' bureaucracy has consoliinvestment, were set up in 1979. especially fast. But corruption is dated. The new scope for market They are modelled on the free trade forces corresponds to the interests improve, industry workers.
The government has been trying to encourage foreign investment since 1979. Not only central government, but regions and cities, can licence investment. which see small opportunities for immediate profit but want to get a foot in the door in case prospects ogy that they want, Slower investments in China.
growth of industry.
machmasses). "However the rights and activities...
scounty self-raised funds. TEETECE O the attacks on egalitarian wages :
According to pects in China? government-run t Shenzen Special over 20 industr taken place ther years, but "due 1 of the trade unio of labour-capital success so far. fied". • In 1982 t which previously on paper was for a new draft of Ch Re-emerge But there ca that the democra a big wave of arrests. October Review:
"The demor saluted Solidarn asm, reproducing and the Charter ... The vanguar of young work aware of the ne to the masses of for their politic focused on dem away to be shot. democracy and v production and c manner of the Par socialist alternat distinct from th ments which hav Soviet Union, for job security scales. the head of thi rade union in thi Economic Zone ial disputes hav te in the last si to the conciliatior n... not one casi dispute intensi he right to strik / existed at leas mally abolished i tina's constitution n be little doub itic movement wi Chinese Trotskyist L a recent issue a cratic movemen osc with enthus: 3 the 21 demand of workers' right d, mostly made u ers, began to b cessity of turnin the people ... A al programme, i lands for socialis vorkers' control o distribution, in th ris Commune. Thi tive is absolutel e dissident move re appeared in th example"
----- pull-quotes -----
re-emerge. As a ( Li Si, puts it in