Why Israel can't be reformed
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Socialist Organiser has been carrying a discussion on socialist programmes for the
Israel/Palestine conflict. Here we print a contribution from Lenni Brenner, author of the recent books 'The Iron Wall, and 'Zionism in the Age of the Dictators'.
The Palestine question is of the profoundest importance revolutionary internationalists"Israel" and a "democratic secular Palestine" are not squares on an American Monopoly game board. Human equality, legal, economic and social, is at stake. The slightest accommodation to Jewish chauvinism in Palestine will, inexorably, lead to similar capitulations in principle to communalism in other parts of the world.
Classic Zionism was unabashedly colonialist, and never concealed its aim of converting an Arab land into a Jewish, state. However, lacking the power to seize Palestine on its own, Zionism perforce developed under the often grudging patronage of British imperialism, until it was able to take advantage of the unusual conjuncture of political factors in the post-World War Il period to establish a racist regime. The near-Apartheid system in the territories conquered in 1967 is an extension of, rather than a departure from, the herrenvolk order created in 1948.
Nothing Can Israel be reformed? No. The Zionist state also discriminates against Jews. Jewish women cannot initiate a divorce, testify in such cases, nor sit on the religious judicial benches, which have exclusive jurisdiction over all Jews in marriage matters. Nor can Harry Cohen - Hebrew for priest — marry a convert or divorcee.
For yea, verily, the Lord will yet restore His Temple in His holy city, and Harry, today a butcher-baker-candlestickmaker would be defiled by sexual contact with such unclean creatures and couldn't perform the ritual animal sacrifices on that grand and glorious day. Their children would be bastards, and Zionism's medievalist rabbis will not marry them, year unto the tenth generation.
Anyone who expects a movement so fanatic in its official discrimination against Jews to ever grant legal equality to any mere Arab is a certified idiot.
There are those who would concede that Zionism is both sectarian and racist, but see an Israeli nation in place, and conclude that it has a right to its own state, sans racism.
To be sure, Zionism has creared a Hebrew nation, and that nation, as with the Afrikaners, is entitled to linguistic equality.
However no right of self-determination is acquired in today's world by conquering another nation, denying it self-determination in any part of its land, dispersing much of it, savagely discriminating against the national development of the remaining natives, and then bringing in middle class Jewish biblebashers from Brooklyn to usurp their remaining patrimony.
The Palestinian refugees were driven from their homes by Ingum Stern Gang Lebanese victim of Israeli shelling Lydda. They and their descendants are fully entitled to return to every inch of their homeland and live there as equals.
Further: equality means that Arabs from the surrounding region have as much right to immigrate into the country as any Jew. But a Jewish state. Zionist or otherwise, would only have legitimacy for democrats if Jews are a majority within its borders. Eventually those borders would have only one purpose: to keep the Arabs from demographically annexing the country, which is exactly the situation today.
And in fact a successful revolutionary upsurge in the Arab world, which is an historic inevitablity, would find itself in instant conflict with such a racist crusader castle, which cuts the territorial bridge between the Asian and African Arabs, and which is eternally linked to imperialism, because such a state, like the imperialists, will always be the sworn foe of Arab unity.
Those who call for a two state solution do so as a concession to the prejudices of the Jewish population. They forget that it is the oppressed who make revolutions, and that only a portion of the dominant caste in such striated societies as Israel, Ulster or South Africa will ever come over to the side of the oppressed, regardless of what assurances are given to them.
What demoralizes the opressed is always to be rejected and it is obligatory to stress that recognition of Israel can never be a Palestinian rallyıng cry.
The formula for success is an alliance of the majority of the Palestinians and the progressive Jewish minority. Without winning over that minority the Palestinians can never — repeat -never win.
Fanatics
But it must be clear to that minority that they must come over to the Palestinians and not the other way round. That minority must grasp that it is sociologically impossible for them to emancipate themselves from the sectarian and capitalist nature of Israeli society without that alliance.
There can be no illusions Israeli society 1s teemung slums of Tel Aviv are the Shankill Road of Israel. Only a minority can ever be won over to the revolution from such reactionary "po' white trash" communities. The doctrine of equality is universal, but it is never universally received. Similarly. only a minority of the Ashkenazi intelligentsia — as with any intelligentsia - can be won over. The bulk of the educated will stay loyal to the system that gives them privileges, and the liberals amongst them will stay loyal to the Labour Party as the lesser evil.
Minority About 20% of the Jews are religious fanatics and cannot be won over, except in the rarest cases. Even among the women, only a minority of progressive women can envision anything more enlightened than a Labour Alignment government, sans the Likud. That is to say that most liberal Zionist women are prepared to accept a government of the criminal party that took , away the right of civil marriage which the state had inherited from the British Mandatory.
An alliance with the Palesfinians, the 17% Arab minority of Israel's citizens, the Palestinians of the territories conquered in 1967, and the progressives of the surrounding Arab states, on a programme of a democratic secular socialist Palestine in a democratic secular socialist Arab Middle East, is the only way forward for the Jewish left.
But, in their July 3 Socialist Organiser article, John O'Mahony and Martin Thomas maintain that the implications of "the slogan, democratic secular Palestine' are: full conquest of the Israeli Jews by the Arab states"
Which Arab states are they talking about? Egypt? Lebanon?
Jordan? Morocco? In fact only a few Arab states can be thought of as resisting Zionism.
Libya, for one, does not accept the slogan, it calls for an Arab Palestine, but it has no following among the Palestinians. Syria backs the Amal gangs against the Palestinians, and by now 1s opposed to Israel only in so far as it holds the Golan Heights.
Algeria is nominally opposed to but the struggle is andly a priority for the bureaucrats there.
And South Yemen says nothing that could be thought of as seeking a chauvinist solution.
Contrary to the two writers, in today's Arab world, the democratic secular notion is profoundly revolutionary in its implicatons, and an indictment of the bankrupt regimes. Within the PLO, we have seen the same phenomena.
The Arafat clique long ago abandoned the notion of a unitary Palestine, and for over a decade its entire diplomatic effort was on behalf of precisely the sort of mini-state Socialist Organiser's two writers SO cherish. Now the full implications of Arafat's retreat on principle are clear: he is completely demoralised and hopes for nothing more than that Reagan will pressure Israel into agreeing to a bantustan firmly attached to the Jordanian police state.
There is no more communally oppressed group on this earth than the blacks of South Africa, yet the ANC is open to whites, unlike the PLO, or even its most left element, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, for all its Leninist pretentions. Everyone who is intimately involved with the Palestine question knows that the entire PLO is ideologically stagnant, and it said with certainty that it, or even its left wing, will remain stultified until they transcend their reflex nationalism, as have the black comrades within the ANC. All know this - except the two writers.
For they, in their own backwardness, have done nothing more than reinforce the dead end nationalism of both the Jewish and Arab left in Palestine. In so doing they have committed a grave disservice to them both, and not merely to them but to the international revolution. For every word they wrote against democracy and secularism and bi-nationalism was argument against Marxism.
Nation
We are for democracy or we are for nothing. We are for secularism or we are for nothing. We are for the unity of the workers of both nationalities, and all nationalities, on the basis of an uncompromising solidarity with the oppressed - and no one else -or we are for nothing. Disciplining working class youth?