Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Education and African famine

Socialist Organiser no. 252, 14 November 1985 · scan pp. 9–11 · Edward Ellis · about 2,177 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

The famine in Africa has aroused more public concern in Britain than any other Third World issue.

As a group of people involved in development education, the major question of us has been how far the response to this preventable "natural disaster" has gone in identifying and attacking the long term causes of the famine and preventing a repeat of it in the future? We spent the past school term working with children in West Yorkshire schools on the Ethiopia issue to try to illuminate some of the deeper questions.

The focus of the public's response has undoubtedly been Bob Geldof's Band Aid/Live Aid project. Their collected funds could soon surpass the tory government's miserly contribution to Ethiopia this year.

Most kids in the Yorkshire schools we visited thought that everyone in Ethiopia was starving. When we asked them to write down their images of Ethiopia, they were invariably 100% negative: "dirty, dying, starving...

They have been taught that the problem is Ethiopia's people - pictured as helpless wretches in contrast to competent Westerners - rather than the system.

The kids were shocked to discover that only a quarter of Ethiopia's 40 million people are seriously affected by the famine and that the majority of the population is still supporting itself in fertile areas and producing food surpluses, part of which ends up in the overted Western countries through the exploitative cash crop system.

Throughout the whole Band Aid campaign there has been no discussion of the real reasons for the drought's devastating effects. Much of Ethiopia's best land is used to grow cash crops such as coffee, cotton, fruit and vegetables. The Ethiopian government uses the cash from this to pay off their debts to rich countries, and it allows us to have our luxuries cheap.

'Surplus"

Ethiopian vegetables are still on sale in Bradford market while EEC 'surplus' food mountains rot in warehouses.

Band Aid have been praised for saying that Ethiopia needs long-term aid such as transport and irrigation systems. How ever, while the export of cash crops has continued, western nations, including Britain, have refused to give long-term aid since the 1974 revolution. Geldof has claimed that the "Russians are doing nothing" , but the fact is that the USSR is the only peuntry to have funded longterm aid projects, including irrigation systems and a dam, in Ethiopia.

The cause of the famine which consistently provoked the greatest anger from children in the schools was the revelation that considerable resources in Ethiopia are being channelled into the civil wars in the provinces of Eritrea and Tigray.

Obviously the Ethiopian government has to bear some responsibility, but there is a deafening silence over the consistent meddling by the superpowers in local conflicts. Both the USA and the USSR badly want influence in the Horn of Africa because of its proximity to the Red Sea oil routes. Hence both superpowers have made huge purchases of arms the price of their support for Ethiopia, Eritrea and other coun tries of the Horn. Geldof's arrogant and ignorant message to the Ethiopian government to "get its act together" can now be seen in its full context.

The famine is just the latest incident in a long history of inequality, exploitation and manipulation in Ethiopia. Even a three year drought doesn't automatically lead to a famine. inequality leading to impoverished people overworking their inadequate holding of land must also be there.

That is a continuing process which can only be understood within the context of a corrupt and unequal world economic system which keeps the vast majority of people in Third World countries in absolute poverty. This grim picture is used and manipulated by western rulers to keep their working masses quiet and grateful for what little they've got. Geldor doesn't seem to want to talk about this!

Philanthropy

The most galling aspect of the Band Aid affair is the denial by our philanthropic rock stars that they are anything to do with the problem. With no discussion of the causes or issues, obscenely overpaid, posturing rock stars have exhorted us to give money.

Our money mind you, not their millions. Wham! and Duran Duran tell unemployed working class kids that they have a duty to help Ethiopia!

The economic system which sells arms to Third World states while exploiting them through the world trade system, is the same system which produces greedy, egotistical pop starts. Michael Jackson probably earned more money last year than some African contries did. Bruce Springsteen donated his expensive stage set to the Live Aid. concert. Bid deal! ' Springsteen has earned$34 million from concerts in the past 12 months.

Some of them may feel that they can use their position of power for good, but we see postions of power' and gross wealth as a major part of the problem.

Socialists must be prepared to be much more critical and aware of the implications of Geldof's project than they have previously. Socialists should demand that all schools consider the implications of the 'Schools for Africa' programme very carefully, and only participate in it if it is part of a much larger teaching programme which focuses on Third World problems, the concepts of fairness and distribution, and our connections to the famine in Africa.

If there is to be a genuine change in the fortunes of Ethiopia and other Third World coun tries, socialists must be much more active in campaigning on aid, the arms trade, and the built-in exploitation of the trading system.

The Labour Party's record on these issues is sadly little better than the Tories, and it is high time that many socialists put their internationalist ideals into practice.

PAUL THOMAS Leeds Development Education Centre (personal capacity)

Socialist Organiser no.252 November 1985

Scan page 10

Stalin goes Brookside Edward Ellis reviews 'Letter to Brezhnev', a film by Chris Bernard. Whatever you do, don't telephone anyone between 8.00 and 8.30 on Mondays or Wednesdays. Even your nearest and dearest are apt to say 'B..... off! I'm watching Brookside'.

Imprint

And no amount of protesting that you are stuck in a phone box in the freezing cold doing vital work for the Revolution will make the slightest imprint upon their consciences.

"Letter to Brezhnev' would therefore seem to have a ready made and very large icience Mood-altering drugs are very much in the news these days, with the panic over heroin and cocaine and the quite justifiable concern about the over-prescription of tranquillisers.

The discoveries of biochemistry have shown us how such drugs work. Put simply, morphine, valium, etc., mimic matural substances produced in the body. Thus the brain makes its own painkiller, called endorphin, which explains why people can suffer massive injuries and feel no pain.

This natural system does not work as readily as we would wish, so people have tried to find artificial methods of killing pain Acupuncture and hypnosis eve this by encouraging the aal ase more endorphin, piate dru s replace the audience, written as it is by a Brookside scriptwriter, directed by a Brookside director, and starring Petra (so that's what happened to Petra...) whose real name is Alexandra Pigg.

Great, right, dead good, d'you know what I mean?, thought, and off I went.

What we get is Brookside meets Bill Forsyth ['Gregory's Girl', "Local Hero' etc.J. but grossly inferior to both. It is a whimsical, fairytale-like love story.

Love at first sight can move mountains, and indeed the heart of the President of the USSR, who takes a momsame one is frequently used for several different purposes. Endorphin is also found in the intestine where it has the effect of slowing the movement of the bowels. One of the less dignified consequences of opiate, addicton is chronic constipation.

Physical exercise seems to encourage the body to release endorphin, resulting fin feelings of euphoria (pleasure), although I can't say I've noticed it. It is even claimed that some joggers are literally addicted to their sport.

Religion

Perhaps profound religious experiences also involve the release of endorphin, causing euphoria. Religion may really be "the opiate ofthe masses.

Addiction. opiates - is explained as The bodi ent off from his usual business of counter-revolution to send a free plane ticket to a young woman in Kirkby who wants to abandon everything for her ene-night-stand fiance in the Ukraine.

Escapes

Our heroine, Elaine. escapes from petty-mindedness and long-term unemployment simply by having the courage of her romantic conviction. She ignores the prejudice around her, all the anti-Russian words advice, and stands by what she knows in her heart. It is a scaled down Romeo and takes some time for the production line to be re-started, during which time the body experiences more pain than usual (while the intestines make the most of their new freedom to move).

The major tranquillisers, such as Valium, also seem to affect a natural system in the brain. This seems to consist of two chemical signals, one a "stress" or "anxiety" substance, one a "calm" substance. These are normally in balance, but conditions of over-crowding, poverty, insecurity, etc., induce the brain to produce more "anxiety" substance, resulting in feelings of anxietyThe natural response indicated by such feelings would be to change one's situation. In this society, this is often difficult, so doctors prescribe balance calm system. Juliet with a happy ending.

There are, of course, some snappy one-liners, such as when Elaine is propositioned by an obnoxious Liverpudlian lad who suggests that they go off together to have a good time in a four-poster bed. 'What? When there are dogs in the street? she quips acidly.

Or again when she instructs her younger sister to go and play with her acne.

And Elaine's best mate lisers can occur, something that has only been recognised in recent years, but which I predicted in my first scientific article (written for the now defunc magazine Women's Voice).

Now, I've already mentioned the body's "principle of parsimony" - that of getting one substance to carry out several functions in different tissues of the body. The "principle of parsimony" seems to apply to the "calm" substance, as shown by American researchers into natural opiates and other chemical signals.

Monocytes

iney showed that mult tes a part of 1978 cell, called - monocytes. These are a sort of refuse collector, swallowing foreign debris and cancer cells. Valium seems to enhance their attracTeresa, who packs chickens by day and impersonates a Sunsilk advert by night would brighten anyone's Jerk But all this is far outweighed by the film's overall dreadfulness. The Russian sailor, Peter, [Peter Firth last seen in an uncannily terrible film about extraterrestial vampires], has an impressive Russian accent, This opens up some exciting possibilities. the natural "calm" substance has the same effect, this may help explain psychosomatic phenomena, where the mental state seems to have a direct effect on the physical health of the body.

For instance, stressed people are more prone to infections, perhaps because their monocytes are less efficient. Similarly, shamanism, faith-healing and placebos (inactive substacces believed to be genuine medicines by a patient) often have a real effect on the health, perhaps by encouraging the brain to produce the "calm" substance.

Finally, studies seem to show that stressed people are more prone to cancer, perhaps because the moriocytes are less out the cancer cells.

Once again, modern biochem- Henr ical research shows that there is scientific explanation for phenomena that were either dismissed or endowed but is a patronising jerk that anyone in their right mind would drop in the Mersey with a brick tied to his feet before they'd fall in love with him.

Elaine is able to fall in love with him as a result of severe brain damage, it seems, such that for the second half of the film she is able to utter few responses to any questions other than 'I just know 1 luv him, that's all' Set against her desire for defection are friends and family - not unreasonably. you may think, if like me you are a heartless beast who finds the notion of life-long love after a night in a disco a little hard to swallow - and the Foreign Office, inexplicably so concerned to prevent her emigration that they produce [presumably] forged photographs to convince her.

Naive

Underlying all this ridiculous nonsense is the film's naive political message. Elaine, unlike everyone else, doesn't believe what she reads in the papers. Bread queues, cold winters, repression in Russia: how do you know? she protests. And anyway, it can't be worse than Kirkby.

Cold-war Trotskyist I may be, but this strikes me as toned-down Stalinist propaganda. True, I've never been to Russia, never seen a bread queue there, nor witnessed genocide in Afghanistan.

On the other hand, I've never been to Kirkby either. Im still prepared to accept it's Bratty miserable, even pith without Eleine wardering about moping, aping,dreamv-eyed Russian sailor, know what h right?

Scan page 11

bers at 14 provincial dailies owned by Maxwell's subsidiaryAt present the Mirror crisis

----- pull-quotes -----

•Reviev to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 252

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →