An alliance for what?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Subscribe Socialist Action's 'Alliance for Socialism' weekend event on 16-17 November marked a new phase in their degeneration towards Stalinism.
Socialists, they told us repeatedly, are defined by whether or not you are with people in struggle, with the Sandinistas against imperialism; with the people of reland; with the ANC against apartheid Socialist politics is thus dissolved into middle class populism. Of course, socialists are 'with' all these struggles. But SO too are many radical liberals - so, too, certainly, are many people who are not revolutionary socialists. Socialist Action, in fact, are not merely 'with' the struggles: they are 'with' the present leaderships of those struggles.
This leads them not only to their characteristic apolitical fawning towards those leaderships. It also leads them to tell lies about the world and to utterly miseducate their own comrades.
The big rally on Sunday morning included a speaker from the ANC - reasonable enough in itself. Yet this ANC representative was permitted to speak without barely mentioning the existencet never mind the struggles South African workers with complete political endorsement from Socialist Action.
In the debate on South Africa, John Ross (editor of Socialist Action) and Brian Grogan (leader of the ultraCastroist minority in SA) denounced the very idea of an independent workers' party.
The ANC is the force leading the struggle, said Ross; the AN's Freedom Charter defines the issues; and so trade unions should affiliate to the UDF A workers party might sound like a good idea, said Grogan. But look at Ireland! There a workers' party was advocated by those who oppose Sinn Fein.
Noticeable also in discussions with individual Socialist Action comrades was the way that Ireland has been used as a training ground for class collaboration. People are first educated in the notion that a working-class political alternative to Sinn Fein is unthinkable, because Sinn Fein represents revolutionary nationalism, and that is what the struggle is about. They then find easy to swallow alignment with the ANC, the Sandinistas, etc.
Yes, a workers' party will be needed eventually, said Grogan when I talked to him afterwards. But it will come out of the ANC. 'In Ireland the forces for a workers' party will come out of Sinn Fein, and anyone who does not understand that will be Get SOCIALIST ORGANISER each door by post.
RATES: €8.50 for 6 months. E16 fol 255.21 November 1985 Page 2 smashed - including comrades...
This concept of politics lining up uncritically behind whatever big battalions are in the field, and seeing a workers' party as something to emerge at a future stage must have its effect on Socialist Action's concept of socialism itself. Many if not all SA supporters see Cuba with no free trade unions, no right to form workers' parties or publish papers, no free political debate, etc. - as a model of socialism.
Its political results for Socialist Action, and in particular what is left of their youth, are catastrophic.
The concept of 'critical support for liberation struggles - a concept absolutely basic to independent, working class socialism - is utterly alien to them. For socialists, support for middle class nationalists has to be combined with a fight for the political independence of the working class.
Socialist Organiser were condemned as "an echo of the Washington Post" for criticising the Sandinistas' banning of strikes! Echoing the Stalinist Friends of the Soviet Union' in the 1930s, they lectured us pompously: *we support real leaders of: real revolution. You people just criticise from the sidelines. The question is are you with he Sandinistas? etc., etc., etc...
Slogan In British politics SA's current slogan is 'An Alliance for Socialism'. This means drawing specially oppressed groups into the labour movement and defending their rights. So far, so good. Only the 'socialism' that the 'alliance' is for is so vaguely defined - Ross gave 101% endorsement to Andrew Glyn's recent pamphlet, 'A Million Jobs a Year' , which defines socialism basically as a series of government controls over prices, trade, investment, etc. that the 'alliance for socialism' beUNFORTUNATELY we have been forced into a position where we have got no option but to go to court and bow