For a united ire and
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
No democratic solution is possible within the Six County unit Socialist Organiser no.253 21 November 1985 Page 3 ... BRITAIN has sold out the Unionists because they could not defeat the IRA. Britain has given the Republic effective joint authority in the North in return for cooperation in defeatling the Provisionals..
That was John McMichael, a representative of the powerful Protestant paramilitary organisation, the UDA. He speaks from a viewpoint which is not ours, but what he says about the reasons for the deal is essentially true.
To undermine and suppress the Republican movement is the immediate goal of the Anglo-Irish agreement. If there are any gains for the constitutional nationalists in the deal those gains are a by-product of the Provisionals war against Britain.
To say that, and to say that as against the British army we solidarise with the Provisionals, is not necessarily to say that it makes any sort of sense from a Republican or socialist point of view to continue that military campaign. But it is to give the Anglo-Irish deal its proper parentage.
Back in 1882, around the time that the Fenian faction known as the Invincibles were conducting a small-scale terrorist campaign in Britain, Frederick Engels wrote: " All that is left to the Irish is the constitutional way of gradually conquering one position after the other; and here the mysterious background of a Fenian armed conspiracy can remain a very effective element... " (Letter to Eduard Bernstein, June 1882).
Who gains from the Anglo-Irish deal? The constitutional Irish nationalists - though that does not tell us whether socialists should support it or not. Under the deal, which will be a treaty registered at the UN:
• An Intergovernmental Conference of Ministers will be set up, modelled on the EEC Council of Ministers. Britain will retain sovereignty in Northern Ireland but formally binds itself to involve the Irish government in a consultative capacity and to seek an agreed common position where different opinions exist. The southern Irish government is thus given immense authority in the affairs of • The Conference of Ministers will meet regularly to discuss matters of policy and 'security" together with judicial matters.
The Intergovernmental Conference will have its own secretariat, based in Belfast.
• It will deal with all matters concerning the Six Counties now dealt with by British direct rule, until such time as responsibility is devolved to a future powersharing Six County government. If the Unionists continue to refuse to work such a powersharing government, they thereby leave control of the province in the hands of the British and 26 County governments.
• Both governments declare that the constitutional position of the Six Counties will remain as it is so long as the majority there want it to. Britain formally commits itself to Irish unity if the majority wants that.
• The two governments pledge themselves to support the setting up of an Anglo Irish interparliamentary body to debate British/Irish affairs, including the Six Counties.
• Immediately the Intergovernmental Conference will concern itself with "security" -that is with coordinating political and military activity against the IRA. High on the agenda will be a review of the British Army reg.
iment, the Ulster Defence Regiment, a 97 percent Protestant force with an evil reputation for anti-Catholic sectarianism.
Efforts will be made improve relations between the security forces and the Catholic community" as a means of undercutting the Provisional IRA.
Opponents of the Anglo-Irish deal range from the Provisional IRA through to the diehard Orangeists, Nationalists and Republicans say that the agreement means Southern recognition of partition and explicit agreement that no united Ireland is possible unless a majority in Northern Ireland want it. Yes, it does do that. But it isn't new.
That has been the de facto position of all the main southern parties, including Fianna Fail, for many decades. None of them, and least of all Fianna Fail which has ruled the 26 Counties for most of the last 50 years has any serious proposal for uniting Ireland.
British commitment to a united Ireland if the majority in N.Ireland wants it is not new either, though a formal and solemn declaration about it is. It has been Britain's position for decades: the strategic importance of keeping Northern Ireland British disappeared long ago. It has been said repeatedly in the last 15 years, most notably when a Northern Ireland referendum was held on the question in 1973.
However painful it mav be to Irish nationalists and those on the left who reflect their views to admit it, it is nevertheless true that the central obstacle to a united Ireland is not British opposition but the opposition of one million Irish people.
What is new in the Anglo-Irish agreement is that the 26 County government is being given a direct supervisory role over Northern Ireland, as Britain's partner. The 'consultative' role is less than the equal partnership with Britain by way of a condominium suggested as one option by the New Ireland Forum 18 months ago. But, with Britain legally obligating itself by solemn treaty to consult the 26 County government through a permanent structure on everything to do with Northern Ireland, it is the nearest thing to condominium - lacking only formal British surrender of half-sovereigntyFrom their own point of view the Unionists have a very great deal more to object to than Haughey has.
The new arrangement amounts to an attempt to circumvent the Unionist roadblock on progress in Northern Ireland by substituting powersharing between the British and Irish governments for the Catholic-Protestant power-sharing within Northern Ireland that they have found it impossible to set up since the Urange general strike smashed the Sunningdale agreement in 1974.
Support?
If the Unionists can be persuaded to share power with the SDLP, much of the power being shared by Dublin will devolve to a Belfast home rule government. But that may not happen, or not for a long time yet.
Does it follow that Neil Kinnock is right to give a cautrecognition of the rights of the Protestant minority to regional autonomy and democratic control over a wide range of its own affairs in a united federal Explicit But after the 1880s each Irish community was allied to one of the two main parties in Britain, when the British ruling class divided on whether or not to give home rule to Ireland - the Catholic-nationalists with the Liberals and the Protestant-Unionists with the Tories.
Instead of a democratic solution the country was torn apart. Ireland was partitioned — roughly along the line of cleavage of the two communities, but within the Six County state, built to accommodate and express the will of the Protestants, a 35 per cent Catholic minority was imprisoned against its will.
This was a bigger minority as a proportion of the Six County population that would all the Protestants of Ireland have been as a minority within a united The original problem of relations between the Irish minority and majority was transformed into a much more complex and intractable set of problems: relations between the Catholics and Protestants in the Six Conties; relations between the two parts of Ireland; relations between Britain and Ireland.
Partition has poisoned everything in Ireland, including the labour movement. It is not true, as Irish nationalists assert, that partition was the first cause of the communal conflicts. Partition was itself a result of the divisions history had created among the Irish people, and the exploitation of those divisions by Britain.
But partition did in turn itself become a cause of much evil in Ireland: it froze the antagonisms, it intensified the hostilities within the artificial Six County state, where the Protestants feared that their big minority, allied to the 26 County state, would replace their Protestant ascendancy with a Catholic ascendancy.
In 1969 the Six County state broke down into incipient civil war. The British army took control of the streets. In 1972 Protestant home rule was abolished. Since then, except for a few months in 1974, Britain has operated through direct rule.
Britain has firmly refused Orange demands for 'democratic government' in Northern Ireland because that would be sectarian Protestant government; the Protestants have treated Britain's demands for power-sharing with the Catholics with strong hostility.
Nothing shows up the inherent untenability of the Six County unit as much as this. On the one hand Britain defends the Six County entity as the proper, legitimate, and only possible expression of Protestant democratic rights. On the other hand Britain refuses to allow the Protestant majority within the Six Counties to exercise its democracy in majority Protestant self-governmentbecause that would be a restoration of the Protestant ascendancy which ended its su year lite in bloody chaos in 1969.
Hostility
It is absurd. lan Paisley and John Molyneaux have reason, justice and democratic principle on their side when they demand majority rule (and, now, a referendum) if the County entiry has any democratic validity.
The Six County entity does not express or embody the democratic rights of the Six County majority because the British government dare not let them
exercise those rights within it.
So at best democracy reduces itself to two vetos maintaining the status quo: the Protestants have a right to veto political progress or any move they think may tend towards a united Ireland; within Northern Ireland the Catholics (the SDLP) have a veto on "progress' to majority self-government. In both cases the veto is backed up by violence (the IRA's for the SDLP) or the threat of it.
Tinkering with the Six County system is no use. That is why it is wrong for Neil Kinnock to endorse the Anglo-Irish agreement. We cannot have any confidence in Thatcher. And the Labour leaders' endorsement of Thatcher is a commitment that the next Labour government will also work the Anglo-Irish agreement, and continue to repress the Catholics who fight against being an artificial, oppressed minority in the artificial state.
Wishes
The Anglo-Irish agreement merely tinkers with the sectarian bearpit Britain made out of the six north-east counties of Ireland when it partitioned the country against the wishes of a big majority of its people, 65 years ago.
What needs to be done is to end the partition of Ireland.
The Six County entity must be replaced by a united Ireland within which the mainly Protestant areas can have autonomy; and Ireland as a whole can then negotiate or establish with Britain whatever relations its government and people think best serve the age-old goals of Irish reedom fighters: freedom from foreign oppression and freedom for Ireland to develop in its own way and according to its own lights.
It maybe that once Ireland has solved its British question' the Irish people will choose to establish close relations with Britain, relations which express and continue the close ties that, for ill and good, that bound and mixed the peoples of the two islands for nearly a thousand It may be that an Ireland which had finally solved its British question would choose to adopt Karl Marx's programme for Ireland, which he expressed thus in 1869:
*I have become more and more convinced... that [ the British labour movement] can never do anything decisive here in England until it separates its policy with regard to Ireland most definitely from the policy of the ruling classes, until it not only makes common cause with the Irish but actually takes the initiative in dissolving the Union established in 1801 and replacing it by a free federal relationship..." (Marx to Ludwig Kugelman, 29 November 1869).
Right now, however, as for centuries past, everything is snarled up by Britain's rule in Ireland — the rule of the brutal power which partitioned the country and created the artificial Six County statelet within which nearly 40% of the citizens suffered as an oppressed minority for 50 years before they revolted.
No real progress is possible except by undoing the partition of Ireland and removing British troops. The only framework for a solution, the only democratic programme that the British and Irish labour movements can fight for, is a united Ireland with regional autonomy for the mainly Protestant areas.