At They Say Fein
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Assembly and reduced to seemingly impotent demonstrations and threats.
Britain would put in money to nurture, sustain and ultimately give autonomous life to its creation. Jobs and patronage at the disposal of the executive would help it build up support. In four or five years, before the next election, things would change.
The transplanted political organs would take and hold in the County body politic. The sectarian state would be transormed into its opposite. Intercommunal democracy would be substituted for the drum-beating Orange supremacist democracy of the Northern Ireland state s first 50 years ('the Protestant majority rules -OK').
But it was like transplanting the heart and brain of a man into the body of a dog.
The Six Counties was designed for sectarian majority rule so long as the Protestants wanted it - and no other democratic system was possible there.
In the event the British minrs' strike smashed all Britain's hopes of a new start a mere matter of weeks after the powersharing executive was set up. Trying to browbeat the miners, prime minister Edward Heath decided to go to the electorate with the question 'who rules, the government or the miners?* The Tories lost the election in Britain, but that didn't matter too much to the ruling class beACCORDING to Sinn Fein, by agreeing to a Loyalist ver on a united Ireland and by formally recognising the Northern Ireland state, Garrett Fitzgerald's government "has torn up Articies 2 and 3 of its constitution"
The "cast-iron guarantees" given to Loyalists showed that Fitzgerald had "capitulated" to Mrs Thatcher's rejection last year of the Forum report.
Sinn Fein's statement continued: "Mrs Thatcher's inter est is to stabilise the Six County state and to neutralise Irish nationalist aspirations through a mixture of appeasement and ongoing repression to which Garrett Fitzgerald has committed the Dublin government.
«The reaction of outrage from Loyalists is as predictable as it is stupid given Thatcher's assurances and Fitzgercher's assurances and Fitzger ald's agreement that their veto remains and is to be copper-fastened in a 'treaty" at the United Nations.
"Sinn Fein believes that the claims of progress made by the Dublin government, and which will undoubtedly be heralded by the leadershil of the SLP, are hollow claims. The formal recognition of the partition of Ireland is a disaster for the nationalist cause and far outweighs the powerless consult ative role given to Dublin.
"Garrett Fitzgerald insult: the long-suffering nationalist people of the Six Counties when he tells us in Gaelige that we can now raise our heads. It is because we have raised our heads and made sacrifices for our civil and national rights that the running sore of British involvement in Ireland has been
Scan page 5
irreformable bly. The election allowed them te conduct what was in etfect a referendum on power-sharing. And they won 11 out of the 12 Six County Westminster seats.
A shattering blow was thereby struck at the executive, and the die-hards were immensely encouraged. The situation inevitably become more and more explosive as Faulkner and the SDLP tried to press on with the Sunningdale programme.
The spark that blew the new structure apart was struck in May 1974 when the Assembly majority voted to activate the Council of Ireland provision in the Sunningdale agreement. A general strike was called by the UDA and the Loyalist Association of Workers', an unofficial trade union body which had much support in the Belfast shipyards and other Northern Ireland industries.
Due to anti-Catholic discrimination in employment, Protestants dominated most of Northern Ireland industry. As early as the beginning of 1971 workers from the shipyards had marched to demand internment, led by Billy Hull, a one-time Northern Ireland Labour Party candidate._ Now — perhaps learning from events in Britain — the Orangeists were playing the industrial card, attempting to use one of the most powerful weapons in the arsenal of the working class to bring down power-sharing and the Council of Ireland and to restore majority rule - that is, Protestant Ascendancy.
At first response to the strike was tepid. Intimidation by the UDA and other militants was necessary. But intimidation alone could not have produced the tremendous strike movement of bitter opposition to power-sharing and the Council of Ireland that now rolled across much of Northern Ireland. The British authorities responded weakly, and soon ne whole was at standstill.
The reactionary Protestant -acklash had found its weapon:
the revolutionary general strike.
und used it for its own purposes.
Like Republicanism in Wolfe fone's time, the die-hard Orange cause too was now reduced to reliance on 'the men of no property'. And the Protestant men and women of no property faced the Catholic men and women of no property, glaring at each other murderously, guns and bombs in their hands, across the sectarian divide.
Caricatures
Everything in Northern Ireland politics is a nightmare world of caricatures, ghastly parodies and hopelessly scrambled identities: Loyalists who organise rebellion against their own government; reactionaries who use the general strike; Republicans on whom circumstances have stamped a mere Catholic nationalist identity: and now Official Unionists who accuse Mrs Thatcher of running a 'colonial administration' in the Six Counties to the disadvantage of the majority community there!
Early in the 1974 general strike the TUC attempted to organise a march "back to work' in Belfast. A few hundred immensely brave workers marched behind TUC general secretary Len Murray. But the TUC had no weight or support. And the government continued to do next to nothing.
Some commentators have talked of politically-motivated refusal by sections of the British Army to act against the Orange strike. Others explain the government's passivity by its inability to run the power stations with troops alone. Whatever che reasons, the Labour government did not try to break the strike.
After two weeks of paralysis the Faulkner Unionists resigned and the Labour government capitulated. The Faulknerites were to blame the inactivity of the Labour government for their inability to carry or and for their own subsequent political destruction.
The attempt to graft powersharing 'pluralist' political structures onto the Six County entity which had been deliberately carved out, weighted, balanced and designed to be run by an entrenched Protestant majority had failed. Northern Ireland society had rejected the alien structures. It was back to direct rule.
The Labour government had run away from the Orange chailenge. But it chose to spend the subsequent 18 months pretending it hadn't allowed all hopes of power-sharing to be smashed in May 1974.
Sunningdale had been a deal between political parties and governments. Labour announced that there would be a new approach. A constitutional assembly would be elected which would meet for as long as it liked and thrash out agreed proposals for Northern Ireland's political and constitutional future.
Britain insisted that any new political structures would have to be according to the principle of power-sharing. But it was a foregone conclusion that any such assembly repre senting the people of the Six Counties could not come up with proposals that would meet Britain's minimum conditions. The venture was a dangerous exercise in helpless procrastination.
The constituent assembly sat through 1975 and into early 1976, and finally produced a majority report which called for majority rule. There were serEverydav lite in Ireland. Photo: Camerawork. hunger strikes, in 1982.
An assembly was elected and told it could be a powerless talking shop or cumulatively acquire control of government departments according as it could agree to power-sharing in any of them. This was called 'rolling devolution" restant-Catholic power-sharing.
If the Protestant and Catholic leaders in Northern Ireland want it to, the existing assembly can take on most of the functions now in the hands of London - with Dublin admitted in a consultative capacity. The well be much fiercer than opposition to Prior-Tebbit. The odds are heavily against them at present, but the Six County Unionists may make Northern Ireland ungovernable.
And then what?
What the Anglo-Irish deal