About the Deal
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
addressed at all.
"Today's agreement amounts to the total abandonment of SDLP, Fine Ga and Fianna Fail assurances that they would not accept any internal Six County arrangement.
'Sinn Fein's position
remains clear. We will continue to give principled leadership to the nationalist people We reject British involvement in Irish affairs and we reaffirm that real peace can only be achieved through British disengagement and the Loyalists coming to tert with the rest of the irish (Source: Irish Times)
SDLP JOHN HUME, leader of the Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP), the constitutional nationalist party in the Six Counties, is considered the originator of the process which last Friday produced the Anglo-Irish agreement.
The Anglo-Irish agreement could therefore be expected to find favour with the SDLP In fact it looked for a while as if a serious rift had appeared in the SDLP over the terms of the agreement.
Deputy leader Seamus
Mallon was reported to be in step with Charles Haughey's criticisms of the deal. In fact Mallon as well as Hume welcomed the deal, saying that it gave some hope to Northern nationalists that " last the closed and shuttered doors of Northern Ireland have been slightly prised open.
"The statement in the agreement that the British government would bring forward legislation to establish Irish unity if and when a maj ority in Northern Ireland so wished goes further than any previous statement by the British government on this issue"
Mallon added that Fitzgerald had indicated that the Dublin government would not ratify the European Convention on Terrorism until changes had been made in the administration of justice in Northern Ireland. ious fears in 1975 that the constituent assembly majority would declare itself a provisional government.
Early in 1976 Britain dissolved the assembly and settled into a long period of direct rule. It was stalemate and stasis. The constitutional nationalists in the Six Counties (backed implicitly by the IRA) had now got a veto on change within the Six Counties to parallel the Orange veto on change in the relations of the Six and 26 Counties.
From 1972 to this day a 'temporary' 'Act of Union' has been restored between Britain and Northern Ireland. Thus the British government registered, without admitting it, that Northern Ireland on its own is a nonviable political entity, on any basis other than sectarian majority rule The long period of direct rule was to see the Labour government take back concessions made by the Heath government to the political prisoners and set in motion the chain of tragic events that led Republicans, refusing to comply with new prison regulations designed to emphasise their status as common criminals, to spend years filthy cells wrapped only in blankets. This culminated finally in the deaths of ten hunger-strikers in 1981 The next attempt to graft alien power-sharing political structures onto the sectarian bearpit state came in the wake of those The assembly has existed for three years how, sitting in the old government building at Stormont. Both the revolutionary nationalists, Sinn Fein, and the constitutional nationalists, SDLP, boycott it, and it is no more than a Protestant talking shop. The UDA recently made the demand that it should set up a provisional government, but the assembly counts for nothing.
Depend
The Anglo-Irish agreement is a much bigger structure into which the assembly may eventually fit as a subordinate part.
The essential feature of the Anglo-Irish deal, compared with the approach tried at Sunningdale, is that it does not depend on agreement between the Northern Ireland communities, nor on any agreement between a representative elected body in Northern Ireland and the Dublin government. The big two in Dublin and London have dealt directly with each other, acting 'in loco parentis" for the two Northern Ireland communities.
Power-sharing has now become power-sharing between Dublin and London. If it is eventually paralleled by power-sharing 'on the ground", well and good. But it does not need to be, for now. The deal does not depend on it. It will not collapse without it. Anglo-Irish powersharing can survive without Proexception is 'security' , included in the agreement for Dublin consultation, but not open to be taken over by the assembly.
But the deal does not depend on the assembly doing anything. Even should the Orangeists manage to achieve something like the 1974 generstrike, there obvious target they can hit, no locally-based vulnerable keystone to the whole edifice like the assembly-based power-sharing executive was in 1974.
Decisive action against this system will be very difficult. The main weakness of the structures now being set up will probably lie in the South: Charles Haughey's opposition is more likely to smash it than Protestant direct action is -though Haughey's opposition may less hard if he be comes form a government in to 1987.
Flexible
The parallel is with the PriorTebbit anti-union laws, which were drafted to be far more flexible and to offer fewer targets for direct action than the CarrHeath anti-union law of the early 1970s.
The decline in working-class militancy stopped the Prior and Tebbit laws from being put up against the sort of working-class direct action that smashed the Carr-Heath law. Militant opposition to the Anglo-Irish deal may shows above all and yet again is that the Six County entity is a nonsense. After 13 years of (rightly) refusing to let the Six County majority whose democratic rights the Six County statelet is supposed to express and protect, exercise those political rights to self-government there, Britain got together with the Irish government and decided on a version of power-sharing which dispenses with the consent of the majority of the Six County population! Their formula is inter-state power-sharing over the heads of the people and against their wishes. They. are not too far from Bertold Brecht's fable of the government which "elected' a new people when the existing one displeased it.
Geoff Bell, author of The Protestants of Ulster' and other books on Ireland, who was Hackney North constin ency delegate to Labou Party conference, has written a reply to John O'Mahony's article assessing the debate on Ireland. This will appear in the next issue of