Independent Unions: Preparing for Unity
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Black workers and the struggle for liberation in South Africa OUT 75p plus postage NOW from 214 Sickert Court, FROM SO London N1 2SY Plans to unite the majority of South Africa's independent non-racial trade unions into one major federation are far advanced.
This report from the October issue of FOSATU Workers News (paper of the largest federation at the moment) describes the preparations.
There are less than 30 days to go before the launch of the largest progressive trade union federation this country has ever seen.
Thirty-six trade unions, with a total signed up membership of close on half-a-million members, are moving swiftly towards the Inaugural Congress which will be held in Durban over the weekend of November 30-December 1 On the Sunday, December 1, a rally will be held in Durban to celebrate the federation's launch. Tens of thousands of workers will be bused in from all areas of South Africa.
For the first time in South Africa's labour history, there will be a federation which will really cover all areas of this country.
Judging from an assessment of where the membership of the unions is located, there could be as many as ten regions . although the federation is likely to initially start off with less than that.
The major goal of the federation will be to form one giant union in each of this country's industrial sectors.
And in order to achieve this as speedily as possible, the credentials committee has drawn up a list of industrial sectors and meetings have been held between the unions in particular industries to discuss the possibility of mergers.
At the Inaugural Congress each union will be represented on the basis of one delegate for every 500 members up to 20,000 and then thereafter one delegate per 1,000 members. At future congresses this will revert back to one per 500 members.
The major function of the congress will be to accept the draft constitution, elect the office bearers (all of whom will be workers) and general secretary. and then debate the various resolutions submitted by the unions.
The congress will also have to decide on a name for the federation (at the moment the firm favourite is 'Congress of South African Trade Unions*) and select the symbol. And the right wing press said this proves there should be life imprisonment for riot.
The point of the plot is that the new Public Order Bill is to create a new statutory offence of riot (which it is hoped will make it easier to secure convictions from juries — an especially urgent need since the failure to do the miners for riot) but at present the proposed potential sentence is "only" ten years imprisonment.
The new Public Order Bill will be a "Mark 2" , an addition, 50 years on, to the existing Act of 1936 which was supposedly brought in for use against fascists but was first used against striking miners and has been used against the labour movement and anti-fascist protesters ever since.
The White Paper on Public Order Law published in the summer paved the way for the proposals in the Bill. Despite its bland civil servant language it is a hysterical and paranoid document. Its basic premise is that peaceful demonstrations can be distinguished from those where the demonstrators' "real aim in demonstrating is not to persuade others of their point of view, but to prevent them by force from doing what they have a lawful right to
Scan page 7
lew powers for Old Bill POLICE Police occupy Broadwater Farm estate io, or simply to foment disorder."
It starts by an emotive comparison of hese sorts of demonstrations with hose by fascists in the 1930s. By the and of its proposals it is however clear hat all of the following would certainly se included by the government in the "coercive" category: animal rights protests, the Stop the City demonstraions, and mass picketing at Grunvicks, Warrington and (inevitably) in he miners' strike.
There is also mention of the 1979 southall demonstration, Greenham Common demonstrations and demontrations by the "anti-nuclear" (or ree adopted is peace er le mena adopted Is narches by the National Front and botball hooliganism are lumped in too.
The paranoia is traceable to that A new campaign against the Public Order Bill has been set up and welcomes new members and aveliations. Contact the Campaign op the Right of Assembly and Dissent (CROWD), 35 Mount Pleasant, London WC1V OAP, tel 01-833 2701. Affiliation fees are: Groups, £7; Individuals, E2; Unwaged, E1. Tottenham, Photo: Andrew Moore speech of Thatcher's when she said that democracy was being threatened by pressure groups and people who disagreed with the government; and displays the same sort of logic.
Apart from new statutory offences of riot and affray, the Bill will create a number of additional offences. The new offence of "violent disorder" is to become "the normal charge for serious outbreaks of public disorder". But the White Paper adds that: " ...it will be capable of being applied over a wide spectrum of situations ranging from major public disorder to minor group disturbances involving some violence"
Offence
The new offence will cover three or more persons using or threatening unlawful violence against persons or property, and will carry a huge potential prison sentence of five years. It will cover Greenham Women cutting down fences; animal rights protesters freeing animals and almost any occasion when three or more people come into conflict with the police in one incident, whether on the streets of Brixton or in a demonstration.
it is quite clear that the intention is to start sending people arrested in these circumstances to prison in much POLICEgreater numbers.
Another entirely new offence which is to be created is that of "disorderly conduct" punishable by a fine of €100 and aimed at "hooliganism on housing crowds" da "te hang or, phe haps, hava. ing a haircut the police don't like. The new offence is so vague that the White Paper admits that it will be difficult to define!
Its effect will be to criminalise working class youth out on the streets. It will result in them being arrested for precisely the sort of incidents which the police should (in the name of community policing) be being made to deal with without playing at Starsky and Hutch' It is a measure of the Labour Party's total lack of courage or understanding on the issue of policing that Gerald Kaufman has actually welcomed the creation of this new offence. This means that there is no opposition in Parliament to it.
There is an urgent need for someone to point out that the new Bill is not just about "football hooligans" or "demonstrators" , it is about giving increased powers to the police in general.
The unbalanced nature of the White paper is even clearer in its treatment of picketing. During the miners strike the police were widely criticised for reviving an ancient criminal offence of "watching or besetting" under an 1875 law (s7 Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act 1875). The phrase "watching and besetting" appears to mean no more or less than picketing.
Despite the Paper's frank admission that it was used in the strike against pickets as well as those demonstrating outside private houses, it simply claims that: "the circumstances of the miners' dispute have shown how important it is to have an offence penalising conduct of this kind.
Arrest
Important, one may well ask, to whom? Clearly it is imp ortant to the government since they propose to make it arrestable and to › increase the maximum penalty from three months imprisonment or a fine ( ›f £100 to six months or a fine of E2,000 If this seems like a knee : jerk reaction to the experience of the n niners' strike, it is as nothing compare d to the new powers proposed to be given to the police to impose any condition on pickets and static demo instrations as well as marches, as to ni umbers, location and duration.
At long last the police a re to be given the power they wanted so much in the miners' strike, to restrict the pickets to six in number and disperse the rest. The "voluntary" Code of Guidance on picketing under the 1980 Employment Act is to be voluntary no more. Anyone who knowingly fails to comply with conditions imposed by the police will be subject to a maximum fine of £400 but organisers and 'incitors" of mass pickets which break conditions will be subject to a maximum penalty of three months imprisonment or a fine of £1000.
It is not too far off what the unpleasant Tory MPs baying for Scargill's blood wanted. It means that organisers of community protests will have to go "underground" and disguise their identity.
Picketing The tests for the imposing of conditions on marches and pickets will be firstly serious public disorder (including damage to property), secondly "to prevent serious disruption of the normal life of the community" and thirdly "to prevent the coercion of individuals" • In relation to picketing the third test is crucial.
During the miners' strike the courts decisively rejected the idea that any mass picket, however peaceful, could be non-intimidatory. In his judgement in Thomas and Others v NUM (South Wales Area) and Others (a case which created a new civil wrong of mass picketing) Mr Justice Scott stated that: 'sheer weight of sufficient numbers on the picket line would be sufficient by itself to be intimidatory" . He rejected the submission by Counsel for the South Wales NUM that: "a large number of sullen men lining the entrance to a colliery saying nothing but simply standing and glowering would not be intimidatory.
He also presumably rejected a similar submission made at the same time (to which he did not refer in his judgement) that the non-violent resistance movement led by Gandhi in India could not have been intimidatory. His judgement means that there is no such thing as peaceful mass picketing recognised by the courts.
The claim in the White Paper that the police will have to be reasonable in imposing conditions on pickets because their decisions can be challenged in the courts is therefore meaningless. The new power is no less than a blanket licence to the police to stop a large number of people exercising their right to demonstrate or picket.
Forcible dispersals of demonstrators - such as have recently been seen outside the South African embassy - will be wholly legitimised.
Finally, march organisers will have to give seven days notice to the police or again face being arrested. This will criminalise spontaneous community protests and give the police enormous power and control over protests generally.
The similarities between S.Africa and this country are no longer just in in the pictures we see on our television screens; they are beginning to be reflected in the laws themselves as well as in the practices of the law enforcers.
Scan page 8
Socialism is not just a vague and m is not just a vague a working-class answer to the pi lems posed by capitalism now argues Eric Heffer in this artic taken from a speech delivered Cambridge on 2 November. *Nicaragua must survive: a The results of contra activity: a cooperative destroyed in 1984 history of US destabilisation CE ME Is a Broad Left strategy possible? I believe it is, but the first question surely must be what is meant by a Broad Left?
There are those who argue that socialism is not at present on the agenda, that it must be postponed until we have a Labour government, possibly in alliance with other Parties, in order to defeat Thatcher. It is a view I do not hold. To me, the struggle against Thatcherism is also Communist Party divide. the Morning Star no k under Party control, and - number of leading munist Party members Ken Gill expelled.
The problems are enough to talk about diagnose; the answers, ever, are much more dif to work out.
We must begin, I w suggest, with a perspe that it is essential, in vital, to get rid with anger with Comlike easy and howficult vould ective fact this
----- pull-quotes -----
Breaking the chains