Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Yes, socialism is on the agenda

Socialist Organiser no. 253, 21 November 1985 · scan p. 9 · about 1,742 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Unemployment is basically avicto en ton will the class Socialist Organiser no.255 21 November 1985 Pal tions and groups of workers, supported either the Tories or others, and in places like Liverpool defended the Tories on the basis of Orange Protestantism.

There have also been splits in unions before, such as the Notts Miners' (Spencer) Union in the 1930s, but in those days they did not have the SDP bolt hole to look towards.

Because of the decline of older industries, like the docks, shipbuilding and ship repair, shipping, engineering steel, textiles, mining, the railways etc., the numbers of union members in those industries has declined and with it the organised trade union support of the Labour Party. They were after all rather tightly-knit working class groups, living mainly in tightly-knit communities.

It would, however, be wrong to draw the conclusion that because of such a decline the working class is no longer there. It is, but to some extent it is a different working class...

It is eitner unemployeu, or has gone into local authority or service industries of one kind or anotner. 10 what that extent, its class consciousness is slightly affected. That, however, can be restored and developed, providing the movement realises what has happened to the class and does something about raising its consciousness. The important thing also is for trade unionists to ensure that service industry workers are properly organised.

I believe we must not accept a coalition with the SDP/Liberal Alliance. They are the other side of the Tory coin. On most political issues like the trade unions, they are just as reactionary as the Tories, as they are on issues such as defence and the pubLicly-owned industries. The Alliance may be slightly less reactionary in certain areas, but they are dedicated to the maintenance of the capitalist system which David Owen calls the "Social Market"

In any case to talk about a coalition government before an election is to suggest that Labour cannot win, a proposition I cannot accept. I do not accept either the argument advanced for proportional representation. I know the Communist Party, Stan Thorne MP and Arthur Scargill do, but I believe under British conditions they are wrong:

I take the view that it is only with socialist policies with a majority Labour government advancing a socialist programme, that can deal with the crisis of British and Western capitalism. That is why public ownership, based on Clause IV, of various types (not just nationalisation), democratically controlled, must be an essential part of any *Broad Left Strategy" Photo: John Harris a product of the capitalist system, and it cannot be totally eliminated unless capitalism is destroyed. Therefore, any Broad Left Strategy must be based on the struggle to eliminate, not only Thatcherism, but also the capitalist system.

That does not mean that we should not seek allies further afield than those who are part of the labour movement: Clearly, under Thatcherism, small businesses have suffered. Those involved can be recruited as allies. It is important that small business people are brought into alliance with us against the big business interests.

The struggle for women's rights has always been part and parcel of the struggle for the emancipation of the working class. In the days of the suffragette movement, it was Keir Hardie and other Labour and socialist stalwarts who were involved in the struggle for women's rights. That is especially true today.

Also, all groups who suffer under the present system, gays, lesbians, blacks and Asian people, are natural allies of those who are struggling to end capitalism. They suffer because of capitalism. They have special problems which are there, but which are exacerbated by the capitalist system.

The class struggle involves all those who are discriminated against in capitalist society.

It is wrong, because one accepts that the road to socialism can be democratic, parliamentary and hopefully peaceful, to believe that the class struggle is dead. It is not, as long as class society struggle exist. It cannot be wished away.

whether some like it or not, is basically a class Party, so if we are talking about a realignment, we must talk about a realignment of those who basically accept the need for class struggle in order to get rid of the capitalist system. I have always taken the view, we must be firm on principle, but flexible in application. The Broad Left must be a Left who accept the need for socialism, not a coalition of disparate groups, who accept not welfare capitalism, somethi which in any case has future. The days of welf capitalism are numbered.

It is my view that should not accept any Stal ist or narrow so-called 'Den cratic Centralist' approa Elitism should be a thing the past. We need a pol which I would call 'revc tionary reformism'. That seek a revolution ing we icy sluary socialist society by consent, hopefully by Parliamentary reformist means. At the same time we must defend our democracy, which has been fought for over the generations, by every means, including force, it we have to.

What I fear is that in order to get Thatcher out, some in our movement would abandon their socialist concepts. We expect the Right in the movement to do so, because they have never really accepted socialism, but if the so-called leftwingers do so, then we are in serious trouble and in the long run we could not win.

The struggle for socialism will be long and hard. There cannot be any short cuts, and neither can it be secured by Sectarianism or right wing concepts.

Clearly, in the movement as a whole, a period of reappraisal as well as revisionism is taking place. It natur ally arises out of the Labour defeat of 1983, the subsequent defeat of the miners, and the retreat by most Labour Councils from the policy of non-compliance with Tory legislation.

Revisionism should not be dismissed out of hand. Most revisionists are right on something, if not on everything. No-one should remain in entrenched positions, certainly not, if the enemy has either passed by or over them. Looking back at history, everything that Bernstein said was not incorrect, everything that Kautsky said was not incorrect, and in the British Labour Party everything that Crosland said was not incorrect. But enough was wrong not to accept the bulk of their arguments.

Sometimes modification is acceptable. What is important is to know what is a modification and what undermines the basic principle.

I fear today that some of the modifications proposed are hitting at the basic principle of socialism, as for example some of the economic arguments and policies being advocated by Roy Hattersley, and the weakening of class concepts by some if not all of the Euro-Communists, What sort of realignment are we thinking about? There are those who say, what is required is a new realism. That what is required is a Broad Left" front of the CP Euro-Communists, and the Tribunites in the Labour Party. There are others who say we need a realignment of those connected with the Morning Star, the Campaign Group of Labour MPs and others surrounding various newspapers, but excluding those around Militant, etc.

There are others who look at "The Left" on a very wide basis, a Left which would include the Labour Party, the Communist Party, CND anc various other groups, anc even the Liberals and the SDP.

The fact that the "Left' should look for alliances ir my view cannot be disputed It has always been necessary for the Left to seek allies. Bu if we are talking about a rea Broad Left, then it must hav a number of basic principles Such a Broad Left shoul exclude no-one who accept and agrees with these prir ciples.

I would say that means belief in democratic socia Bloc, a belief in and support of those in Nicaragua and Chile, in fact in all countrie fighting for liberatiom am seeking to establish a democratic society free of US control, a belief in democratic free elections, in freedom of speech, freedom of publica tion, thought, etc., a democracy going beyond bourgeois democracy.

That means being profess to criticise the Soviet Umion etc., over human rights much as we do over the lo of human rights in right-s countries. The struggle against all imperialist policies essential for those who believe in a new alignment on the Left.

That of course creates problems, because if we look at the recent divisions in the Communist Party, both sides are right and both are wrong. Those who are in favour of almost uncritical support of the Soviet Union are wrong, but also are those who are opposed to class politics. *hat is required are friendly, omradely discussions, not 1ame-calling. There are lonest opinions on all sides.

put if one accepts certain principles, then one must decide where one stands on those principles.

I repeat, I believe, a Broad Left Strategy must include the type of propositions I have outlined, and that must including accepting principles, not individuals. The cult of the individual is as unacceptable in Britain in the Labour Party and the Unions as it is in the Soviet Union or elsewhere.

There is a danger at the moment that because of the defeat of the miners, because of the right-wing position of most of the Shadow. Cabinet, because of the drift towards rightist concepts by those on the NEC of the Labour Party, that others will find it necessary to trim, to vacillate and move increasingly to the right. So I urge all who are genuinely seeking a Broad Left Strategy to ensure that the strategy is left wing and ian, Stalinist or so-called 'democratic centralist" , but that it accepts pluralist concepts and at the same time it accepts the class struggle without ignoring the lack of freedom that exists in the so-called socialist countries.

Socialism and democracy are synonymous, one without the other is impossible.

Let us have a Broad Left Strategy for the end of Thatcherism, for socialism, a strat egy which does not accept the cult of the individual, one which believes in a critical examination of all issues based on socialist principles not expediency or imag building.

----- pull-quotes -----

"I believe we must

accept a coalitior with the

"The struggle against Thatcherism is also e struggle for socialism"

socialist, not social democra- tic. Also, that it is not sectar-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 253

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →