Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The struggle Capitalism is the problem'

Socialist Organiser no. 254, 5 December 1985 · scan p. 2 · about 921 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

The Freedom Charter' is the most famous document of the liberation movement in South Africa. But what sort of document is it? Is it sufficiently democratic? Can it be a useful focus for working class struggl These and other issues were discussed at a debate between an executive member of the United Democratic Front (UDF) and an organiser from the Metal and Allied Workers Union (MAWU). The text is fror 'Arise! Vukani", the bulletin of 'Action ' Not our idea of document is the but the domination Charter makes demands like free speech bur these are ted as they do not address continct in society contlict between capital and Charter talks foc the but are there not differ crests among these Charter nor anticapitilist the ause atmattoo does not coustit ocialism, Production relations Sure emands of the Charter to orking cans 7 We Chaner is relevance r the workine class in every sPben the Charter was drast ben the charter was drawt p. the South Alinican Coogress Trade Union existed We Stand that in South capitaliom has taken on a Black people sn appressed as a nation and as a ss. be c suse in the charte peonic shal meet refore shoves that From page 1 *Cosatu gives Botha six months to get rid of passes said Barayi. *I want to g P.W. Botha a last warning let rid of the pass laws ai o withdraw the troops frc the townships, bafore the Until recently, the tran unions were wary of overtly politice campaiana, anxio build up their shop-flo renath. The Federation South African Trade Unio Fosatul. the major preder to the new Congres had begun to take up cal paigns against repressi and the State of Emergency aver the past yoar, and mi Cosatu's defiant stand mat a further big step towar the clear politicisation union struggles.

While participating in t Youth class interests are primary.

Thee mintee sure mg class interests, burgeois interests, hecatse tis anti-imperialis mate. MA WU Some Charter are relevant to the workne cass bar they are imiten • The UDF. Urganisatoas TUDE which support the Charter, and dominated by the middle class and cannor ensure the libera tion of the working people. What mie has the class jo implement the demandi in south Aton the work ine cass is in the BROKeN entral role of the working class must be tought for. Because of repression, the Charter had to he couched in a certain manner. The Charter is representative of all the strata in South Africa MAWE Bourgoois democratic ights and addressed in the matter but bo weeking cas: mancipation. Capitalism is the problem - the Charter does not adance tits With Charter working-class_ dominanoe is noc quaranteed Are chiss abnunces ir the Charer sili veubile?

BDF Class alliances ure important. The wicking class canno he We must broade ap and micake the mode class, Fue exatapie. the stert Cane Train" Associa insisted in the MAWG: Alliances Working cass mustesab l future suctety cevisaged in the Charter compatible wih casperalisme?

UDF: Becauser of the nationalisation clause. the Chaner is not emspatible with capitalism. The Charter is fot s sacisikl docu ment, but neither is it a capitaldocument. Society is ina state of transition and the Chartalism and this is not in the MAWU. The Charker can t. Al modated by capitalism. testif is ustal democranic-bı not secialist. Nationalisation clause does not eyuale suclalism. In Britain, for example, key sectors of the erosomy ane natBritain is selsloge cansel kay workers moverse there. The wit: le awww. to this we lAct FRE He Cogre Am ty was wot straggling orgare cagic alism THE FIRST problem ve hase with the Freedom Charter is its smbiguity i that is, it can be interpreted differently by dittierent pecole.

For instance, the clange The people shall goveen" and the clause with the mines and the land has been taken to mean that the society envisaged * the as the contract (rOa tion or state control of sections of the economs does not equal ocialism. Many countries hav nationalised key aspects of their economies but the sufferings of Workers still don't bave control vec decisions.

The position of workers in Bri tain and Poland shows that ever though the state in these coutries ontole much of the rco nomy, the workers still lead miserable lives.

A respected leader who supnons the Charter sialed the Tor owing when writing about these that anding the nationalisation of the banks, the gold mines and the land, the Charter strikes a fatal bow ar the financial and gold mining monopolies and Carine benea This Is Action Youth's critique of the Freedom Charter', reprinted from *Arise! Vukani:

ratisation of these monopoties rill open up fresh fields far the developmen of a prosperous Non-Burube in-hourpers cuse For the first time in the history of this country the Non-Europcan bourgeolsic will have ape and to mines and fac ories, and trade and private enterprise will boom, flourish as never before"

So what we see bere is a denial that the Charter implies thc overthtow of capitalism. In fact, it is pesitively interpreted ax a programme capitalism.

Racial The secund major problem with the Charter is that # accepts the government-imposcd critera of national groups' and 'races"

The supporters of the Charter agree that there are four natons" or "races" in South Africa su-called "Coloureds". "Afrie ans" "Indians and "Whites'

----- pull-quotes -----

Black rke eW owel

er neflects this. It is adventuris. to talk of a single stage

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 254

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →