Liverpool: the truth
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Sociallet Organiser a0.254 5 December 1985 Page argument was that this heiped keep down the rates short-term, would Increase the long-term debt of the city which future generations could not repay quote, from the recently published book Liver Richael Parison, is bitterly ironic in light of the crents of the past fortnight.
Who is to blame? The Tory government has been immovable, prepared to see Liverpool down the pan socially They have consistently refused to return any of the central government grant taken from the city in recent years but necessary to meet the real needs of the first deindustrialised city in Britain What it gives with one hand, in grants, it takes away with a vengeance with the other.
Undermine The national Labour Party leaders have also made every effort undermine the attempts ot the Liverpool Labour council to maintain services and to develop modest house-building programme without an increase in local taxation (rates) which the working class must pay.
The Kinnocks, Straws and Cunninghams have done the dirty They don't live in streets where al most everyone is on the dole It is always Ok to recomnend suffering if you're not he one who has to suffer.
However. there is an old Yorkshire saying to the effect that them that's never done anything wrong. have never one anything right"
or was it possible, given the Tories evident culnabil ity, for them to appear to be innocent by-standers in these events? Way Kinnock able to Labour Party conferepo 01 what amounts to the launching of a purge of Liverpool Labour Party when two years o ne was very circumspec riticising Liverpool? Why were national and local trade union leaders able to con vince most Liverpool council not to support the uncil's stance, if as the council leadership claimed, it would mean losses across the entire workforce?
These questions also give Bas Hardy reports from Liverpool mise to s much more formidable one In May 1984 the Liverpool lahour Party steved is biggest cher elec coral victory on the basis n its confrontationist. antibuy ucket. 11 3150 had wide pread support in the unions.
Al that time oren the NUT.. the least class conscious se Honor the councils workforce — narrowly voted down a motion for a one-day strike in support of tac counci Why, now, do we have a totally destroyed Incal coy. cuters oms shop stewards committee? Why now is the Labour Party in Canner of wooed at te polls next Mav?
Some of the biome must he put down to the sectarian and bureaucratic behaviour of trade union support for the Council's stance. They throuch confusion or design, semi gangsterist politics develop the Town Hall. They played into the Labour Party Rote Kind the hands of the Tories nockiles. They created a rou not only for their own backs, but for everyone else who takes a left wing stance in the Our Town Roll Marxists or US. 1 cross between the Jehovah's Witness and The Cosa VostTER The Hatton factor is onc ad symptom of this. Hattor 185 рівусс the medis in orac establish himsel national political Sgure extens put are tente guard him as the sole repro entative of Liverpool Labour Kinnock of dayclopink a per sonality cult, if you are doing exactly the same thine When the Leader of the ouncil, John Hamilton, Talks diversion ail and telephone calls and surveillance. something is clearly wrong.
This with paraphernalia flash clothes, Mash cars, etc. scom, crabla non-mabcious observers, to have some subitance to them, The Hatton style has led many voters to believe that there is a grain of truth in the Tory press lice The present administration EXIONS much Of the wrong! of the Braddock ens:
Jobs have been given to poopie wine in toe Fondcuey or willing to kowtow to it across 1 wide range of counci employment. notorious exsmple of Sam Bond, we have teachers promoted. union others men 83002IX33 councillors included or excluded from he council on the patronage system.
Patronage
The syster of patronage is the maior cause of disunity among the workforce. The GMBATU has benefited con siderably in terms of pay and working conditions. a fact that in itself is not unde however, been seen made to be seen, granted at the CAPARS other sections of the counci workforce.
The other big blow to trade union sourdarity was the dreadful and seemingly higstre decision to issue redundancy notices to the 31,000-strong workforce!
This cactic was treated with hostility and suspicion by many honest trade union. ists. Could it be that some of the councillors did not want to be barred from office? The redundancy notices were egal device to stay within the Las but such legal niceties only placed fear and uncer taints in the minds of the workforce, The unions have generally been viewed as a sucacivicat appendage of the council. Because the employer was the socialat couricil, union disputes pocatism itself. Sine hot of pursuing union grievances represented white collar workers. and such petty BOlTECOLs workers were denounced, this gave an opportunity the trade Leaders bostile to the council's fight to lead their out of the Many workers who broadly supported the council gradwally became demoralised in 1985. felt like a stage army, there to be-winet on demonstrations. but never patty to decision mak ing.
The contempt with which the council leaders held the workrotec was Cleatly sown by the way in which the current crisis was solved. The council had agreed the bank alancing deal in August, yel it continued to tell the work. force for further two months that there aptron, apart from the Tory covernment climbing down been negotiated hour Tary Disconne nonmen! Baker being aware of it? The Tories knew that the bankruptcy treat more than a charade, and a poor effort at brinkmanship tootsoldiers of Micant have yet to sce it this They are used to acceptne a line, handed down from the gurus at the top Militant took over the council it had no idea how to operate in real-life politics Political activity consisted of passing tortuous resolutions for socialism. The LPYS was controlled by them in fashion to nermetically seal iron ou nor in tene itting off any possibility of • LPYS developing into a se youth organisation.
is spilled over into the way in which they dominated he city council. Decisions ere taken by a small group at the top, Hatton, Mulhearn. Militant, 4, Tony Byte, The line woutd then be absorbed by the aparachniks who would then pass it on to the broad, politically uncducated mse resulted in Milltant hrecoming isolated and exposed in Liverpool, Suca a situation does then o good in the long term although they nay he able w ow a tor moe sup porters in the next few weeks.
Militant have succeeded in tw sombenrof ww.reczuits.
cound an anti-Tory political gut reaction. In doine.
failed to educate them on a number of important ideological issues, such at race.
These people are conserving for socialist poliMilant on Mess bee cont tinues on its sectarian trajectory.
Militant supporters should think about the possible mistakes they have made if they are to wit back support. There should be discussion around the following agenda!
*Removal of Hatton as che main poofinite need exits DLP de-nersonalise Liverpool Labour Parcy's stance.
The removal of Samson Bond race relations advisor.
If the council is willing to make CORCHOES 1o SWiss bankers. then surely some concessions to Liverpool's black communty are in order?
*Reconstruction of the Joint Stewarde Cont mittee: council must take positive steps to and reunite the local gor ernment workforce, *Re-establishment of demacracyinside the DLP. This should be used as a forum for democratic and a an arena for the pilloryof individuals who dare to dissaree win ine une
Candidates chosen
Labour Party wards who critical of aspects of Liverpool Party policy should not be barred from the panel of candidates, The Kinnock bureaucracy is more powerful than Militant -Tendency one.
запаскіль Militant the Kinnockites are inserting the thin ead of the wedge!
They be stopped From turning the labora Party Into machine T kind of SDI Mark II. The non-Militant left austa.not-allew the bureat atic activities of Militant a stampede them toto toc carap of the witch-hunters After all, what has been going on in Liverpool is par for the course in councils un and down the country . Liverpool has been singled out ~cause the unbour leader. ship happens to disagree with the policies being pursed there.
Socialists on Merseyside have to close ranks attemots by NEC to destroy • genuine, organined response to capitalist living and services for the working class. We must also be firm against attempts to bijack working class protests down various sectarian and bureaucratic highways and byways.
'Starved, battered, defiant: magnificent miners". An aralysis of the miners strike. 75p plus postage.
Blusions of power: the local goverument left 1979-85', 60g lus postage Workers" Liberty" on Sout) Atrica: 730 plus postage. Workers Liberty' on Trarsky. ists today: "Uoder Whoee Flag? 60p plus postage.
Socialist Forum no.1, The Beitish Road to Nostiere', 50p plus postage Socialist Forum no.2. Ireland 1969-80, 50p plus postage. Socialist Forum po.3, onl Afghanistan Sop plus postage.
Wrize to 214 Sickert Count London NI 2SY.
Scan page 6
Geoff Bell, author of The Protestants of Ulster' and other books on Ireland and Hackney North CLP delegate to this year's Labour Party conference, replies to John O'Mahony on the debate at that conference SOCIALIST Orgaliser of 170etober gave ever three pages to attacking myself and three other movers and seconders of the resolutions on cland at the in replying to this. the Boss admission I would make is that 1 about doing so. I find it rather difficult seriously John 0 Mahony's renew a the irish deb are at conference.
It is reminiscent of those old SURICS about theatre review veitten by someone who spent performance of the play theatre barLike O'Mahony that may have read the script — and O'Mahony repmdaced but more to plays than the script. And there is more to debates a Labour Party oaference Than what actually said However, Betame begin by questioning anony s methodology. in askine who asserting that, the Tor inic in our movement he says that those seek explanation for this can begin by looking at the debate at conference and at the weak argument put over by those who made speeches there.
Absurd
lalise analysis would recognise, the reason the mon cader ships are hostile to Beitish with drawal is bocause of their membership in Noethemn Ire. land, the vast majority of whom are lovalists and who would they believed their leaderships ere wring pro Republican res Labour. Parts conferences.
Add to that the faer the unions Socal baderships Northern Ireland have, in some been themselves accused perating discriination against Catholics by the ratt Emploment Apency and you begin to get a material. istic esplanation for the unions' attitudes towards Northere Treland. rather than sume idealistic notion that it is all in peopie's heads and if se put the right argument over we will win the With that in mind, ler me just conclude by making a couple of remarks as to we car scop change tres Sita bon The work of building up sappoet fee British withdrawal front treand wime the tank ami fl of the unans is an abvious priority, and one way in in which, in future the matens teterests of ine bureaucracy could be devaled. And we are all agreed that to win that support means gobs octed troops Durew Unconditional Where the real dispute lies. 1 suspect. is just exactly where do myseif. the goding Tomica mee as taat socials insist that Batish withdraw From Ircland is unconditional.
ro spel tais our neither the British government, the Labour Patty cunference noe even Soc alist Organiser can place condinOns on best wandrawal: The principle af seif-determination means that they have no right to
----- pull-quotes -----
the Militant leadership on Merseyside. They cut away