'Britain out' is principle No.1
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Sacatin Organte: so 294, 3 Degember 1985.P8gc5 Thes k very sug The movers of the reso utions have live mintes sech the seconders and other speak ers three any individual to make a detail ed, theoretically-sound, answer ng-all-possible-objections-that light-be-raised type of sprec in that time is absurd.
This is especially the cas issue concernco Monken and a 550c0 nually distorted or neglected by labour buresuericy. No, all we an do when speaking to resolu ions on Ireland at the hope to couple of polemical points, cornoons and super danie informarion which 1 perhaps. just nechaos may start the nod aole. yate thinking afresh about the Trish issue. intentions bit i do sure that Thece may modest John O'Mahony is rather naive the beeve that is sheech s at Labour Party conference chich win or lose debates tlien As am sure he knows the was majority of votes are decided beforehand at caucus meetings of the unions!
What informs theie discussion on Ireland 1 will discuss shortly ut to give over three pages of Sicklis Orealiser to discussing four or five minutes each elevate the of those, possible effect they could have to a level they do not warrant But if John O'Mahony wishes 1o do that at cast let hm get off his metaphorical theatre sar stoe, buy a programme and sec what the play was called. The hast the sackie soman needs to be re. placed by a broader sgitatior which would make "Troops Our " one element in a cahesent pre he see delegate And that 15 why, totally con Tary to the impression given b ociatist Orgamser, the resou croms way. way beyond Troops Cut' O 'Manoey ants a coherent nopeirune So dome ahich is why in the resolution I moved we silin nhe lust ne or ite neal Labour government, as Socialist Organiser reported, but also for the working our of la detailed policy for British withdrawal". granne er a detailed policy maners Bric-wase coes nisite is they amourt to the same thing.
Cerlainly we did nor detail is policy or programme, alough the scoond resalation Keperea-su possibic colponents of it — the ending of the PTA. plastie bullets and strip arching — but what we did de. in the wording of our resoluons, was to suggest that the orking out of this policy/ propamuk wa ou suca otostatd: Ascese on det a ide agin movement to flesh it out.
That is what the resolutions called for, and for John O"Mahony to tr 3id parade nss Troops Out simplétons is a seccarian distortion.
And, if 1 may, I will adda personal note bere. John is kind cough to say in his articie that have aritten works* on Feland. For that. thank yvu, but it he had read one of those works mone closely and — he would know that in he conclusion l arguc for and all a cohereat programme for The Labour Committee on IreFand also argue the importance estahishing a programme fo ithdrawal. All of which under lines the importance of not jumping to too many polemic conclusions on the basis of what is said in a couple of minutes of speechifying af Labour Party Opinion As to the 6f those speeches seeks to denigrate that is.
* opinion of the Irish Post.
- Instance, the Irish case was ut most cloqueady at Bourne south — the best ever presen ation and all who spoke in favour of those resolutions must Now he tra la nil may not possess the theoretical wisdom or Marxist analysis of Socialist Organiser. but there is one reason for taking its views a good deal moore scroasty than those of John O'Mahoy: its coverage of the trish debate at conferenee concentrated on attacking the disgracelal, incoherent performance of Mer Kir the spokesperson for the NEC.
Thar, for me. was a much more important - the carpet the labour bureaupresently must share the responsibility for British misrule in Preland — than that of thea left crities such as mysell and the others who spoke in the debate in favour of ending that Beitish miscule!
Mention of the labour bureaucracy raises s further point concerning the debate in the trade wns on reisoe and the teis denship of chis to discussions O Makony bokel Pat i The Troops-our-of-reland current so (ceble in the British Jabour moverent?" he was not only mastien in chascienaap us a simply "Troops-out", he was aiso arong in his assessment of our strength pean ve hae tet the par fie supporting. рарст. Irish unity: secured promises epeal the PTA and stop the use of nast bullets. ann defrater the NEC on the ending of the puryless courts and strip-search ing. apport toe our. position a the CLPs has aise the Ireland has been debated at sonforence for the last five sCars.
Majority
rould also argue that we w have nsajority. if not averCLA in sugger of Brissh with aval. Where we lack suppe in the trade unions and it mel bres sole which has con Sistently ensared our withdrawal motions are lost.
Why have the unions adopted is actitude" k it because.
ban O'Mahory suggests, the trade union de estons tam rence ane wotried about the sospect of a blood bath il Beitain leaves?
They nay be worried abour this, and certainly the quesneeds serious discussion, A but uggest this is what informs the unions" opposition — on that of the NEC — to British withdrawal is to ascribe to these bureaucrats — as many of them are - a degree of concernand empascion for the poor trish tholics of which, quite frankly. there & as mach evidence as there is of snow in hell No-as any half-docent-marees insist that the trish constract their state in this or that ast before Britain leaves.
That is why I object 15 Jolm O Mahony'• pructioc this article and others coupling British withdrawal with the advocact of 1 federal let aDo It wich there would be considerable autonomy for the Peotestant North, Those no intention of earrin into this argument hete because I do not accepe the prime re sponsibdity of British socialists at this stage in the irish struggle is to sit around and commutate debates at Labour Party conterences one day and construct constitutional arrangements by which Ireland will be garchied the seat.
Our job is to work for British withdrawal from Ireland. In the course of that work we can supgest ways and means of lessen ing threat of a bloodbath - for instance the disbandment and disarming of the - 3nd se can include these measures in a wider and more detailed progtamne foe British withdrawal That: however, is an entirely different process than the Irish priority Socialist Organisee has Chosen 10 20 or 10 the 33s couple of years — arguing in Britain for a Federal Ireland.
It all conjures up an amusing vision. we sto tec ocosre.so the Labour Party; a socialist government prepares to withdraw from Ireland: Johe O'Mahony parad. es up and down Whitehall with the banner Troops Must Stay Until Protestant Rights Are Secured This. of course. is a caricacure. The poior I am making is that. foe me, any theoretical dis. cussion the nature of loyalism which we in Britain have is best for unconditional British drascal. Once that context agreed. then can get away from both the type of тероптадо Socialist Organis et used for the is debate ni conference and the type of reply which was ecessitated by thai reportage.