Workers' unity is the first principle
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
cutey brought at Wister Continution Defence Committee our boro the areers to atteck the Civil Right merebers Here they sow a nick throth Armegh with aticks bit dohn O'Mahony replies to Geoff Bell, and takes further some of the arguments developed in his analysis of the Labou Party confersnca debate on Ireland in Socialist Organiser no. 248, Troops Out, he argues must be used not as a self-sufficient slogan but as part of a coherent programme for Ireland.
DID I rattack? Geoff Bell and the others whose spooches at Lab. so and couscated upon in SO our Party conference 1 summari. 2487 Certainly 1 criticised them pretty severely, and I suppose 1 La bit unkind Sarah Roelofs, whose writings on ireland in Labour Briefing sum up for me much of what's wrong with much of the left.
But to disagree is not necessarily to attack? I consider myself to be on the same side those who spoke for Troops Oul at hour Party conference.
1 presented full summaries of the speoches in order to avoid giving the impression of triggerhappy factional sniping and to give the reader the chance to orm an independent judgment! i solicited Gooff Bell's present reply because I believe a scrious debate within the left on the question of Ireland is onc of the most urgent tasks we have to tackie Geoff Bell declines to discuss most of Having summarised and catcally analysod the arguments used by Troops The left Jost the argument at this year's Labour Party conferençe.
With the partial exception of Geoff Bell the left did not even seriously attempt to cuswer the (emphasis idded). Was tright or wrong!
Geult Bell is of course right that there is more to the our Party conference play than the mere script, the speeches. alone embodies or can The pressures and vested interests bite outsec word overshadow the debaces, giving their precise meaning and weight to the sentiments and ideas expressed there and sometimes predetermining the vote without regard to the speches and argumcars mar coetke a conference.
Geoff is right that it is a weakBess in scoter or the debste that I didn't underline and bring but the stamincange of Kitson's recreace walca 1 ched 1o the TGWU's 200,000 trish membets.
but my sao ce was the schpl i.e. the arguments. The absence of comment on the trade union bureaucracy's vested not to upset the status que is s weakness in my article but not s decisive one unless you want to say that the arguments are irrel.
Arguments
T itemised the three arguments on which the opponents of Troops Out base themselses, would be followed immediately by sectarian civil war, and therefore: repartition and to trie united Ireland but ang. Thac Northern Teeara Te some seet of legitimate expression at the nems ofthe Protest: ant communice, which can only e changed fundamentally with their consent"
My summary of all the points the chattie tot that caly, tu deal with any argu-Geoff Bell tonk up the bloodbath argument.
The rest of the arguments were not muched at all by any of the left speakers. That was most striking feature the debate they didn't ins to argue. In terms of the argu ments it was almost a non debate because the left simpl defaalted on the arguments.
I I'd seized on this or that hasty speech and said the cquivalent of tiero accident comrades, that comrade Xin his peech about rate rises in Tour Hamiets neglected to deal the wass character we the Com munist Mongolia of Cuba and Outer be unreasonable But what happened in the concrence debates need an explan ation stronger than Geoff Bell's charge that I'm enguging in factional sniping Because movers of the resolations have only five minutes. says Geoff Bell, and seconders three.
Individual to make a detailed. theoretically sound, answering all - possibie - objections - that might-be-raised type of speech in that time is absurd"
Moreover, though "the question of the bloodbath needs serSous discussion" "any halfdecent materialist would (that) the reason the union leaderships are hostile to British withdrawal becaus of their membershit in Northern Ireland, the vast maj ority of whom are Loyalists and who would quite their unions if they believed their leaderships were voting pro-Republican resolutions Labour Parto conference this suggests) a materialistic explan tion for unions" towards kirthern Ireland rather than some idealistic notion that it is all in poople's beads ank I We DUl argument over we will win the debate"
the argumeuts don't matter? anyway aut very But the arguments do matter and 1 they cont. why waite atticles and books bother o nake speeches at all The urguments hac an impoetan outsice the meatre wate confereno -they went out live (V channels Was tise minutes not endure? That wouldn't explain the virtual absence of even attempts might have to be hi the ctr tieg stances aggens. nor oces iE explm tae fact that in an anticle about 1800 words be much less than the comnent part of my aricie - Geoff Sell still doesn't attempe to •Bonet anvot te Boabts, Perhaps nur disagreement:
hen. is about what the argu.
Well then, stat ane they? in the movenient nte?
in fact Geoff Bell's posinon ents to be not that the arguments don't matter, they ae different from what BRORSS smch Marins (noe in mar cun cave trish Marxists who live in Britain) have any right to cuss the isues. Our political fights cen go no further than the right to repeat, as oflen we can muster the energy and conviction, the single relevant slogan, Trops Out Now, with ло qualification.
Response
Badly tree Got deny nat Txx taken on board the mai point I made, about the need foe Troope Out as one ele. ment in a coherent pe His response is "that the resolumoved and seconded went wat beyond Troops Out. the WHOOPIE but also * the working ouf of la detail ed policy tritish withdraw. al Corthy, wo did nor detail chis policy or proposal, although the second resolution menticeending of the plastic bullets and strip-searc ing - bat what we did do to suggeir... that we needed a Wide-ranging discussion within the labour dest his progranite out.
"detailed policy, he understand a deraied poles loc how to withdraw the troops, not a proposal for what is to replace the present structure which depends for its survival on Beitish troops.
My entire argument was and said it expiritiv that • is counterprixtuctive. li begs questions -bloodbath issue whica 11 000s for answer and which can only be answered by programme for how Irelan chould be with Troops Out as part of it. I said hur programme should be "self-determination for Ireland as e hole and within that auto umy for the Protestant areas "Even swing 50% of the responsibility to the opacky of able that waiting. it is stil seem able to take in the point.
let alone reply to it.
in fact he explicitly refuses to discuss issues be federalism n a profane publication like SO in a foreign ountry. Ours is not to reason why.
We are all agreed that to wir that suppert and Trop On in ere he real dispute lies. I suspect, is just where do we go. For myself, the guiding political ciple is that socialists insist tha British withdrawal foom Irelan is unconditional"
To spell this our neither the British govemment, the Lab. cur Purts conference or even can pace conditions Beitish withdeawal. The principle of self-determination means that they have no richt to that the inch construct their state in this on that way beiore Beitin leaves...
But with all due respect, this is metaphysics, pat politics of Rockinesh class politics. You cle- sort and enta not selt determ absolute prisciple ainst which everything eise measured and to which every.
che is if necessary acrifices ow I'm for a unitod feders Ireland tany other foemn of united Ireland is simply inconceivable) But I don't start out from the Idea that Runted reland. ven an independent Ireland, i the goal itself, an anquestion able axiom.
Tarive at support for a united Ireland ns a result of asking other questions. How can the Irish working class be united? Hi won the plast the paralysis of the What are the conditions in which the Irish working class likely to separate itself political ly from the Green, Orange, and Green-White-and-Crange segnents of the split and divideo Irish bourgecisie?
I arrive at the belief that a united Ireland is necessary be cause I believe a federal united Irciand in winch the democratic of boxh sections of the people will be protected isthe necessary way towards inother goal. working-dinss unity consider a higher coa and: Tethere be made, a far moe important goal!
Ercieet the politics of ABC agitation combined with abstract socialist propagan other groups because it simply way of relating to the nate the life of the Six County 26 County workine cossa and grip ceality.
But if 1 thoucht the working the unresolved and festering queston, then would consider it a socialist duty to ignore it!
Neither Fish Indenendence, nor frish self-determination. nar Trish unity, is an absolute principle it voor srandpaint in that of. Maraisz socialism. That is what distinguishes us from all independenoe and unity is not the end but a means to an end. We ane for it oe agadrad iii depending on other things.
Programme
seif sufficient prograntee and per Troops Out as meting that can be a euen d. Your position conflates ahe Marxist support for a democratic nroetime andear thase hoht kays condirional in the seose of being a means to an end - with ne nationalist view of slogans ke Troops Our as an end in themselves You collapse the particular. anel exceptionally complicated, Irish question into generalities about self determination uncrete into the abstract For a certainty the 26 Counties have seidetermination nd full political independence from Ene in world War 2 did the Falklands war. they arguc with Britain as an cqual withio the EEC.
Southern Ireland hasn't got oconomic independence? No. asn't. But that is an entirely lifferent question. The sociulist programme against colonialist and imperialism is not the reac tionary stopia at -pendence autarky. hich the Irish bourgeoisie partly attempted berween 1932 and 105k soluton to the monoaht deestons is diass struggle and soctalism Seif-determination is a0-org: arising pelociple for socialists, and an always binding and active principle. We are obliged anx! democracy. But how, if not by discussion. can we decide con cretes wilt we are for self determination particular proups. whit self-determinatior means in Darkular circumstan ces, and what form of self-determination?
The Brush labour mosemer Is faced with an Irish situation out sey determination Protestants — what before Partnone let Certainly the CH TA NO CHIS TUNE sent something like that powerful force in political tis don't believe that the 1 Counties croteis the democra tie rights of the Protestants: but it is impossible to deay that the Six Countice do essage. only in a negarive way las agunstable, murocrous way, some deprec Protestant self-determination.
You cannot make scif-deter mination", meamine concreter Troops Out and no talk about what cumes after? an shorite pance, presented to Brinsh workers in a spirit of ultimatistic sectarianism. Self determina. ton kes to be arcavor. mnenet ised, discussed, and weighed: you have to make your case for How Saouk Beinsh Turn to page 15
----- pull-quotes -----
ste i tut that we cas t hach isves. Netber the Britsh bb-