A New Partnership USTR A New Britain
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
are not very forgivable about the 1974 here - in this department, in this be tackled.
It's very difficult to know all the reasons why there isn't a tide of suppor for a strona set of policies to deal wit? с ссопотіс chis. think оле ехріятаton misht be that peon e are nessimistic or tatalistic about economic policy.
Economic bolicy which it's culte difficult even for econc mists to believe in, and for non econo mists it mew he sust hot sir trik BS. I scems to me wast toere 15 a pata lel between the failure of Labour Party polry to be convincing, and on the other side a tature to hame the Torie for unemployment, to the extent that peopic ole a lew cas seo. ne maste o. expectatons abour what LOveTT ments can do has become very ditterent meone don't expect governments to h able to soles economic nrob ems FC. I wonder if they ever did.
MT. As taras i can remember, when people don't believe the Labour Par same policies again, then no thanks.
To in the bus people were very opt mistic was. we thought we had a political syst ch which al least hall worked. and that social democracy gradually led towards That's true. But talking ahout econo mic pollcy specuically i doubt tha people in '64 had very strome dens about what Labour was going to schiese l Karology ini it part c with the bolicies could all the all problems.
FC. I think economists believed it I'm not sure how many ou 3040 beliered it.
Do you FC. I don't now.
MT. Did you believe the Labour Party es in the international situation, which are very deep-rootcd.limit national cov ernments ayerage person Party mantesto theonsings ing Of Soulsi stupid after all..
re. you stand outside as an snaivst. and watch the thine unfold. then vou can say the political conditions aren t there and it all looks nevitahle Rut you art one of the 20 million electorate who can potentially cer logether with dach other, then thete ourht to bo no What that clettorite can achieve.
1 mean, don't think the viston wrong. 1 think is essentsal The AEs represents an aspiration for collective social and andite a noroughis admirable aspiration.
MI. A lot of people would agree. They net the i Patty cadership to do it. thir BORs leadership.
MI. Yes. They don't bave safticient confidence in themselves to produce an alternative. The lack of confidence in other pcople is only decisive because they see economic policy as something that ant he inne hy other nenne. come. where else nothing that they would have any control over. Collective. con trol would not be control by them There wasn't anything in the Labour Party Icaflets at the General Election to give any working class person any idea that Labour would fight for any SOME OF WOTE SIESS COROL NOURIOR to give them any confidence that collec five control was something they could win themselves.
FC: But I'm not sure the Labour leader. ship could do it either, even supposing they had complete confidence.
Take the 1974-79 Labour government. Suppose it had been led by very determined people trying to carry out all aspects of the policy. Could they have pulled i off?
I don't know. I'm not sure. It might be that the electorate were right to be sceptical, and it might even be tbat up to a point the leadership were right to be sceptical.
There are certain things which to me Carlos Asgasto Guarite Refer are not very forgives bic about the 19749 Labour government. It's perfectly understandable for a Labour govern. ment to say: this year we are obliged by the situation to do so and-so, although it is really the wrong thing to do.
But if this is something that is against the aspirations of the labour movement, they should come clean about it. But they try to justify themselves, and to do so they make anti-Labour propaganda. What was unforgiveable about tbe 19749 Labour government was last Laes became converts to the profit motive It may have been nonessary for them to make tax concessions to increase profits, or even to squeeze wages, but to say such ponies see thorougne; laudable social objectives was to destroy the whole sense of being a movement in pursuit of something.
But even if they had boen determined, they might not have been able to do what they wanted Why not?
rL. International power i which is not fuse something outside Britain. enm. pletely interpenctrates inside Britain. A technocracy ano Joanagement are more intesrated into the international sysiem than they ne British You can see that in every sphere, It's bot just 1a business and industry t's Restes faculty - amone economists in British trive 51105. What Is the British economics profession. and hast cot at particular national characteristics? To me the obvious thing about economics in Britain today is that it's American виамензо economies isa shorthand Io: international economics he same textbooks are read around lie word but a success Conomist, sol might as mell go from a job in Britsin to a job in the United States...
BS: l'in just about to go to a job in the hitad Crotee FC. Economics has been internationalised. There are some minority currents in coomis which are more local and more national. but mainstream coono mics is totally internationa MT: Why is that a bad thing?
FC. The culture of internatiunal economics is broadly a culture in support of the present international systeri, extremely antennistic to the about Party's objectives, and antagonistic to the whole idea of socialism in one country.
F did think chat it would be possible to met auropean Alterestine Economic Strateay that would be widely support 234. 5 Dionsber Kinnock and Willis: Labour's new partnership for Britain; Partship for whom?
More on page
Scan page 12
ed a synthesis of the Keynesian an Marxist traditions, acceptable to a broad page centro-left. But I'm now very dubiou about the success of the proiest because American eco where in Europe.
65. would nave a basic ditterence with the aim of socialism in one country. seems to me inal socialism is essentiall! Baust nacions isolation. But all the re commencations Of the Alternative Econotice Strategy come down to a ratlie narrow sort of nationalism. And li seems to get narrower and narrower The conclusion looks to me almost like bauce much octer conditions. to cople to control the development a their societies!
mightmean fewer conflicts between different groups of people.
BS. But don't you thin cally protectionist has gone torethe wild multarm anc eased natons. conflicts?
FC Not necessarily. It's a post-war re. write of history to look at the 30s as the bad time. There's a legend that crerything was ail right in the "20s and then it broke up in the 30s. It's a com«coomic relationships After all. socialism involves search for self management. You want seif-management at a local level: but then isn't there a need for a certain amount of selt manasement national level? If you say that a country has got to fit into a glohal market, then that implies thai regions have got to fil into it too, and so on down until factories are opened and closed according to the dictates of the global market. which is roughly where we are now mists cisewtere ro collaborate with 1 found that if we said were spainst the Common Market because it takes away the possimility tor national and regional planning to be effective a lot of people wit agree thats not apainst the idea of Eurape-wide socialism. much more autonomy at the nacionsi level Can go onto a different tack?! heree with sot or what won have com about the elects of the market eco nomy on a world scile. But how do you account for those in torms of the theor
----- pull-quotes -----
Labour Government was elected 1964, a lot of people thought that a of things were going to change radically. A targe part of the reason
promises today is the experience of last two Labour governments. They say: if Labour is offering