"A large part of the part of the
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
• siege economy. In fact, you seem ever to come to the ides that an internation al economy as such is a bed thing and It would be better i we could isolate save.
EC. Everybody would seree in principle that world socialism is y desirable objec tive. But at the same time it's very difficult, We've concentrated a large part of our work in recent years on sesrching for people to work with on an international level. We've been trying to find out what are feasible and better config urations of growth and development and trying to analyse what conditions would have to be met. It's just so ditti cult. And it gets steadily more difficult.
Presumably there are objective conditions which have to be mat for different parts of the world to grow in harmony. It's quite difficult to know Just what theie arg. We've got a rough understanding of and employment and deindustrialisation and so on at a national level, but at the level of the world economy I don't think anybody has got a reasonably accurate picture.
On top of that you've got the and Comecon. you need an awful lot of parts of the world to be parties to s deal for it to be successful.
In 1945 the United Stares ran the world, and at least they could run it according to their vision, with some strategic objectives in mind. We're not in that kind of situation.
And therefore the utopia of world socialism though I'm sure it's important to think about it and te discuss it - has precious little connec tion with the problems British socicty today.
BS. Bur it people in Britain try solutions to British problems which are nationalistic, that will make the inter. national utopia recede rather than grow closer. I'm thinking of protcc. *They're all woman, wade wars. insanely trying to get the FC: I'm not sure, it may be that even debt down. as a long-run proposition a bealthier recine would be for less economic Which is a interdependence. If the capital markets disaster. There were lat more reziona. you had isn't enough regional and local banking systems debt-creation". f there was much tess trade - it misht arle Sparham:Verwork 5 Wecembie 1985. Page 12 plete travesty. The "20s were absolutely appalling, and in many ways things got better in the "30% The US was almost the only prosperous part of the world in the "20s. And the '20s were a period of the destruction of socialism. Socialism was bring smashed even in the US in the "20s. Why not attribute the drift to war in the "30% to the destruction of socialism in the *20%, rather than just to protectionism in the 190s.
The Americans have always equated imperialisot and protectionism and fascism. They atuributed the war to the protectionism of the "30s, and they rewrote international ideology in favour of the global market system, which is a very American idea.
# was quite explicit. It you read about the negotiations during the war.
the whole American aim was to replace the imperialist system with free access, so that the American banks would like over from the British tanks, and Ameri companies коши таке ірогіз markets away from British and contin ental companies The Americans clearly had completely different vision of what the world should be like from oidfashioned imperialists but also completely different from European socialists We've all been brushed aside.
One explanation of Mrs Thatcher is that she's close to the American Establishment, and she's rather out of her own Establishment.
IT woold put i a different way.
lather than saying that free trade caused problems, or the colonial susten caused problems, or protectionism, you should look at what y What lay behind the First World War. the *30s, the Second World War, and the American-domina.
ted system after the Second World War, was in every case the competitive drive of the Jeading a Ditainst States dominate the world. to prefez Edon't think our job as SOCIaLISES IN expression of that drive, I think what Bob was saying was that if we as socialisis try to focus the tabout movement on national solutions that hes a reaction. ary effect on the possibility of progress towards a socialist world.
For example: the American dominsled system Droke down the old empires is just as much a capitalist system us the old imperial system. But if the attention of the British labour movement were focused on maintaining the British Empire in opposition having free trade, that would he tremendously reactionats...
EC: You're confusing things Youre confusing political arrangements and economic arrangements don't see how self-determination of peopies is to be equated with the global market system.
MT: Bur the alternative to the elabal market svstem was the imperial tracine blocs, based on colonial empires or spheres of intluence FO. You might have new alternatives. For example, the Labour goveroment a ter tbe war had a vision of changing the Empire into a Socisist commonweath in which there wou a bo autonomous states tong would nepotiste wow each other on their interpationai reason peo ple dor beli Labour Part promises is the experie last two I don't think you can have self management at a local level without i measure of self-management at national level. That doesn't mean that you don't want market mechanisms at all, bue there have to be elements of negotiation and planning.
We don't want United Nations MT: Why not?
FC. We don't want a very large clement of centralised power, It's very dilficul to make centralised power accountante MT: There sooms to be an assumption what you're saying that for example.
socialism in one country brilain 1 an casier proposition than get a socialist Europe, It's not at Clear to me that that's true FC, Tm not making that assumption all i think the two are complementary.
A very important ingredient of any more rational social development is considerably more collective self-manugement at a national level, If the national economy is going to be as much a yo-yo of the international system as it is now then there won't be much collective rationality.
But a national AES, to me, is absolutely complementary trying to develop socinlist alternatives in Western Europe, People in France and Italy and Spain and West Germany and exery where else need similar things.
In the attempts Tve made over the inst few years to find groups of econo.
For you book macrocconomict. 0) Francis Cripps and Wunne Godel? in terms of the theory of vour book cant see why there should be an problems with the world cconomy ar all. In that theory, the only problem.
тої тле патолаї ссолоту come essen.
Bly Brom international truce anni You lake the world economy ara arnold there is no external trade So why isn' itself-montine?
monetary System cause you don't know what assumptions you Te making. But it seemed to us that taore is one set of thines discussed In that book, which should be able to be agroed by a wide tange of peoplo. That cowa get some of the muddle out of the way and we could get on to the other questions.
I've got my own extension of the book licite which is the answer to your question THe book tries to show that the monetary system can generate scends roal growin nrovided that the fisca унит 15 set up approprately taink That probably is true in the world eco notty as a whole, But it requires a con dition to be met, namely that the theni system r rather. on a world. cale ots of fiscal systems - should be set up appropriately.
craments who want to have expansion ary policies and in favour of govern.
ments who have fibancially orthodox, dellationary policies. That is an endemnic chatacteristic of rather liberal balance.
or-payments systems and a global monetary system. I think it's almost bound to happen.
It's very difficuli to the probiem MT. Why is there this bias i denations ro. Because the penaities for governments which push ahead of the other and overspend are very severe They get into financial difficulties with the IMP and they have terrible nolitical conse.
quences, The world needs debricreation at ar International Jeve. on a pretty big seale But hecause the debts are private debts of the particular countries, you don't think of the Brazilian debt is part of a set of arrangements which thank end or it. has kept the worle economos going. So they're all Insanely trying to got the debt down. Which is a disaster There isn't enouch dent areation MT Dicurdons of the crises or thr world economy from a Marxist point of view have all in different ways stressed the question of the rate of prout. but row beoretice susten the race of profit seems to play no role at all.
PC. in this part of the 20ta century governments have become very, very amportant in determining the dynamic: of the economy, and I think they an more importani on the whoie than thr ale or pront. Or course, profit feed back onto government policy, and that
Scan page 13
the IME was their best way of imposiog be looked it by Americans und by You can take the economic part of the anyway - and making it appear as an say, the workers of Hong Kong, or other Sit was all anout having ating something extremely similar to the More Whitehali run in a different way, and Wash't it actually more the case But secondly, there is a difference be MT You my in your article un New on that the rolers of Britain decided that Tween how British protectionist might Socialist that if everybody took a 13% page sut in wages, all the unemployed courd 14 is amportant.
The main point about the world economy since World War 2, I think, is that in the '50s and the '60s the world shifted from a situation where the dollar was a very scarce currency and the United States had competitive domi nance to the opposite situation. That resulted in very rapid growth The Americans were strong enough to afford it, and they went from very lange surplus to large deficit in 20 years. There were a lot of things that cause ed the breakdown The liberalisation of capital flows meant more and more money washing around, and all the currency speculation made the fixed exchange tale system untenable.
BS. On the one hand, you reduce problems to the international dimession which to my mind tends to lead towards national so stonist in your solutsons.
Sum 20410 201-36 foz o sumo amotos somop in me state's economic management, and less to the rate of profit. That aspect leads to an attitude towards 10 DSEU 100 S1 0ITM SISU 001 8U103 1602 5035s 0 S000 11 S519 0 SEI the economic crisis will be solved by better government policy - that it isn't really anything basically to do with having a system which is still fundamentally capitalist, hased on profits Certainly there are a lot of people in the labour movement who will take what you are saying to underestimate what is necessary for socialists to do in aftacking the rights of private property and the rights of capital.
I think that from the point of view of economic management, if tho international monetary and trading problems could be solved, then the social-demo.
cratic recipe of state-managed capitalism is in economic terms fairly viable But I absolutely agree that viewed as an entire social and political process, it probably contains the seeds of its own destruction.
The re-entrenchment of capitalism In its managerial form in post-war Britai is what absolutely destroyed the vision or the Labour Party. Egalitarianism 1s thrown out of the window, and you move into un elitist, hierarchical vision of society.
But I think that Ene old analyses which emphasies profit and capital as economic mechanisms is too economist sc. It's looking at capitalism completely as an industrial system in which profits are made and chen re-invested. In the 20th century the government is at the centre. The struggle is over the nature of the state, The failure of the Labour Party in post-war Britain was a failure to define a socialist state anu besin to impiement it. Instead, the stato remainextremely paternalistic, was managed capitalism.
That's what's wrong with Keynesian ism as a political philosophy: it's the enlightened application of imperialist manugement to Britain BS. either from the route l took from the route you've taken, we arrive at the conclusion that were not going advanco towards socialism without fundamentally conttonting the class nature of society, and that means attacking the rights of private property.
What do you think about the ABS in that regard" It seems to mo that the AES doesn't represcat any fundamental attack onentiste property. or uny fundamental questioning of the form of the state. It seems to me on the whole to be going backwards - to be saying. IcEs go back to 194S.
FC In my perception the AES is vory different. The time when I was most interested in the AES as political ido Feast hail of it was about trying fundsmentally to change the machinery of decisions made in a different way.
AES, in the narrow sense, by itself, and say it's a programme which could have British imperialist state - and you'd be been implemented the post-war correct The Treasury could be converted to do an ABS all by itself without consulting anyone tise. They coald do import controls and increase publie expenditure, and that could be called an AEST But i don't think that that's what it's about, What was impelling the Deft in the Labour Party at that time was the shop stewards" movement. A wide group of people who are at a certain managerlal level in society feit themselves completely alienated from top management and Whitehall, They wanted to break in and say that the whole thing could bel done quite differendly!
Whitehall could have done an ABS:
they didn't precisely because they were unaccountable. If you're in a cosy club with top bureaucrats and top industria?
ists in the United States and Brussels and France and Japao and so on, why bother to do an AES in your hoare patch?
Whereas if the process of government was genuinely accountable to propic in Britain, presumably the would not be so casual about dropping a few tens of thousands of jobs here or lopping a lew billion pounds there. And wo wouldal have negotiated with the IME in the same way.
When the gorernment Tan our of money in 1976, the whole thing was handled by the Governor of the Bank of England. There was a Treasury otan in the IMF mission who was esping then on to do us in. You'd think they were on the other side, most of the top Prop be Bulain, iT: Perhaps they are.
FC. Yes, Indeed. Whereas if it had been an open, accountable Labour Britsin, the IMF would have had to come and negotiste with all the shop stewards! committees, and they wouldn't have got atf so lightly.
Why should we have conceded to the ISTF at all? We didn't need their money! We could bare closed the foreign exchange markets and put on import controls instead external imposition FC. Exactiy. That's precisele wby the AES couldet sork without fandaren.
SUE SES LaM0 S0 1 Se is way accountabulity is a groconditios ToTan AEC isted with an identitiable 55. Do you see the ABS 30:20 se Labour Parts EC. Yes. But 1 see it as something on its way out It would have been an ideal policy for the '60s. The shop stewards were all ready to press for it, everything was catching fire, and internationally it wouldn't have been difficult to handle we weren't in the Common Market.
and other countries were feeling so minded much about Britain Prosperos that ther ruuldn't have in the "70s, as a desperate lasc effort, it might almost bave been viable By now I feel that its time is largely passed le's still a good idea, but the circumStances aren't there to do it. The groups in British society that need to have the confidence to demand it haven't got the confidence - and for good objective reasons: you can't expect shop stewards to he confident when they te in a weak Eargaining position And Britain is in an bargaining position internationally.
BS. Ithink that parts of the AES prob ably are goine to survive, but in differ eat hands.
The version you gave earlier of rel tive national economic self-sufficiency was economic nationalisma with a socialist, human face, because you put your emphasis on accountability and democracy and control, and the noed for small units in order for that to be a Also, you put your emphasis somewhat on national self-sufficiency as against the dominant power of the world conomy, which is the United States 1C. No. as against national system.
Fust of all. in the United States you have a labour movement which is advoc countrios whoso imports are outcompeting British production at the present time..
was d were true. the bit pe mainly Hong Kone and Third World imports as opposed to West European Imports tom the third world are massive in a very few product areas in have made a pracucu -C8D sween but the business than have taken away tom brit industry in tota! i much tess than what Kest Europeans have taken away One of the advaniages that we clair tor protection is that it could he used for managing trade according to soulst principles which mishi wal incinde saying that we should give some priority in our import quota scheme to very goor countries BS. You make various comments about the protectionist aspect which relate it to some kind of socialist goal. But the point is that in fact protoctionison is Being taken up, both inside and outside the labour novement, in very reactionaty ways. Reapan's steel quot co example FC: But It etirely reactionary for American workers to want a bit of protection? I would prefer well-organised schemes of protection with proper criteria and proper negotiation But is it entirely reactionary?
BS: It's nor at all reactionary for Ameri can workers to want their jobi profect: ed import controls 3r the one Toute t do it that they're presented with. Bul there are other routes for which thei inders aren arenated to tien FC. Their bosses might not even be abte to deliver on the other routes. The warle market is difficult for evervbody.
BS But my areument is that some of the other ways to fight for their jobs would involve the elimination of the bosses, or at least a severe reduction in their power, FC It's not clear that that would hels them much withoat aport controls Workerowned enterprises may go broke assasly as others Socialit Orgaoiser no. 254. 5 December 1985. Page 15 Unemployed youth in Port Talbot
Scan page 14
This interview radical policies 1 just mentioned, Why summer 1983 than public ownership and workers' From possible to do isolation Irom suppose taem position to do it.
Will Labour give him futurea was done in control?
Socialist Organiess. 254. 5 Decembar 1985 Pane Ta be employed Suppose that instead of taking 159 off everybody, the labour movemeet took all large industries out of the handi of the present owners and put them under workers' winstest, and even Hally eliminated the wealthy camer • could get your 15t of nationa me from that l FO what constitutes the wealthy class es? If it was mostty easily nationalish!
wealth in Britain, If most of the profi now was coming from British industries that would be quite a good argument But all the evidence is that there is practically no profit being made in pro duction in Britain. And it's not going to 0c so casy to nationalise all the hich y profitable assets that the weslthy clas es own around the world at all sure it's politically such a thing in Britain in the rest of Europe. But bour movement were in a • If it was last Britain, we would be severely restricted by international pres sures. But theis are certain measurer of could get hold of the income of the wealthy ciasses, which sa or more than what appears at the end or the day Bs profit But the sES doesnt-tal o that sort o. this chan Also, in terms of accountability ano Ene pollacal system, sl doesn't talk aboul any radical transtormation of the state machine - not even 2s much s electing too civi servants Be sione completeiv restructuring the whole aPParatus FC. If you wish that there were better worked-out radical ideas being coherent ly argued for by the Labour Party on income distribution, wealth distributon, and reros in toe system or government, then lin absolutely with We worked with some other people to do i book a lew cars 20o callou Manijesto. and one of the things we suggested there was an upper income ceiling. was very modest we suggested a 028,000 celling about three years ago - but I realised that virtually cverybody who has influence within the 8st che practically everybody who appears on television, for example - is above that shut. so where are we golng to look for the spokespeuple to advocate such a ceiling?
But I still chink that it's very umport ant to have some idea of the way that political action could one day translate itself into workable programmes. I think that's the point of the ABS..
MT. But it's not at all clear to me that it's any more workable than the more are planning agreements more workable Plannine aureements ute more taul cal than public ownership because you can have planning agreements with publiciy owned bodies.
lanning acteements are supposed to be about joint control by workers and government necolate with manure.
M1 Look at Chrysler. The manacemen at Chryser weren't cesred out and replaced by representatives of the workNo. And they haven' been in nationalised industries. I wish they had. But they don't get cleared out. Why? You have to come back to the machinery of government, the nature of the government process it's not accountI don't think anyone would disagree with the objective, it's how you get there. It's not necessarily casier to start by sweeping out all the top managers.
311. I the Labour gorernment 1n 94 Pioto: Chris Solver: had started off by sacking all the ton managers albe Kank or nand snd eplacine them hy peone who were elected and accountable...
FC If they do even bad arminister responsible for the Bank of England...
But it seems to me you're assuming that the power on the other side passive, It isn't The Bank of England, the Treasury, the top management of industry, represent mobile and dynamic power which the labour movement is desperately trying to contend with Say ing that we should sweep them all out of the way is just saying that we wish the problem was solved.
The problem is precisely how co contend with this active, mobile and dynamic power. Taking it head on is ike orivine your cal mio a onck wal The result would he a crash. You'se got to somehow winkle them out.
Bs. How you do il is to have a movement committed to Strongly enthusiasti FC: But it's 101340 DCODIC the say. Othe Wisher BS. The movement has got to has programme which people can see Nally changing their lives, But U sure that anvone sees the ARs thanging their lixes...
FC: When war st the Department of Industry with Tony Benn, there was a group of people who really fought for workers control. They really believed it would change their lives They made Incredibly tough struggles to get small bits of workers' control. But I dont think you'd pot many people to right lor that now. Because the experience was very disappointing. It's so difficult to make a success of workers control in che present economic environment.
That's why you need visions like the AES. You can't fust say workers conta, and nacionairation its a whole guestion of social rationaliti m sultals an argument for saying that the vision you nut forward must bo a genuinely radical one The AES is essentially aboul manakine a system where the institutions we now have stall remain, and managing it jointly through putting pressures on the people who here bower at the moment.
Fo But the whole idea of the AEs was that it had dimensions of taily tobid and drastic changes in accountability bothin coyernment and in industr there was the hope at that stage winch think has faded now ors Taller wide costition or people would think i was rely worth tenting for In the can. you see this idea of sweeping our all the managers is wrong There's a difference betwcen the social forms and the people, They're people 100, and they cmoody & targe part of our collective knowledge and skills You wantra philosophy ofchange in the structure which enouch noone think worth fontine or.
in we dau, some peone are going to have to desort their own clams percen GonN people have got to be prepared to are at one scot structures and sigh for another one would it rou be like to Chante she machinery or rovernment in a drastic waw How would you do t?
Covermen depantments and made Them accoumane you a have to have oreantsca ratraming or civ servants, and vous have to nave consultant psychiattists to help some cl them over 1. Youd Bare to go a bit carefully.
You'd hare to sack one or two of wei, bur you dont want a punitive ilulude towards nois amas.
its about chaneipe the struch MT. Following on from that, 1 want to ask a question about the thooretica. adeas in vour bockmacroeconomics The book very much follows the traditional method of academic econoside sueries of assumotions abou Dow Te cconomic asenis bensse.
Iscems tone that such a methoc inevitalily means that economic theory does not contain any critique of the sock sistem. Every prohlem must hr seen as coming from the behavioural Paramorets, pecause the ale the baiy thing that comes in from outside to a system of tautologies.
EC. The book is very, very narrow It's aimed at a particular narrow sto problems. And I agree with you, it's u problem with academic economics that thought.
FC Maybe the title can be faulted. But it's true that what we do here is much 10o narrow:
we are very perniciously constrained by the insticutions. For example. this is called a Faculty of Economics and Politics. But we can't do what i think of as contempor aty history.
Still, I would defend the book intellectually as being a useful enterprise in itsel. its important to clear un some of the muddle even though what you've 8ai0 is tuca It's also bloody difficult. sometimes feel like giving up economics because t's so difficult.
BS. lagre FC. That's wity 1 feel there is som to this idea of breaking down the into smaller units.
tro make t mee themamiste in anderstand?
not Just for econo mists. We've made the planet so incred ibly difficult to organise. When you have exploitation, by satellite at the opposite side of the globe, through such obscure institutions as the international monetary system, no wonder people can't cope.
Al least in the Middle Arca che system had the merit that Схро 300л was directly visible. hecause it was on a village basis. And now it's so impenetrable.
I went with Joan Robinson to Brazil shout three or four years ago, and the students in Brazi were on shout mult national capital and how it's a mechan ism whereby people in Britain are exploiting people in Brazil. But most of the people in Britain can't rell they're exploiting workers in Brazil. To me it's better to say that it's a system which is exploiting most of the poople the workers in Britain are exploited by multinational capitalism, too.
MT You YOUr 00Ok IS 8D0UL money. Marx wrote a lot about money, too. But he started off hy analysing the conditions under which money comes into existence, and examining the whole concept of money ing your book you could not imagine that anything othoc than a money eco. nomy was possible.
You End an equation, and one term in it is олоу. le's just an equation, лоthing ideologically loaded about if...
I don't think you can take that as fust a part of economies, and then have soroebody else studying institutions That's the traditional acadomilo meth od. People say. We're just economists there may be all sorts of тота] questions 2705 Inst rutiona questions, but that's sociology.
HO BUT In TA CORONE NOSE SOL economists studying institutions, and economists studying macro-theory 1e8 orel sis tools poe working rogether..
But isn't there lacolagica. in the very division?
FC Of course there's can-destogical bias We live in a society where ideo "ogy very very stropg. To me, really the probleon of socialism is ideological bias.
For example, the unthinking blas in favour of profi. which is sheolate ly universal in the labour movement, Every shap steward thinks it's crucial. ly important for his own factory to make a profit.
There are a set of biases in understanding the economy planning or less impossible. The notion or a fair price is an incred. ible impediment to any notion of planning, because you cant alter the market it you can't alter the price.
These are very deep problesos, and we ought to work at them If we bad well organised intellectual infrastruc ture in our society, that's what intel. get us out of all these traps and biases.
But intellectus! specialisation is pushed further and further all the time. Hardly anybody crea does macroeconomics today. They do bits of macroeconomics. Were trying to pull certain things together again.
85. Reynes wrote books ahout macroeconomics, and then at the and of each book he would write a chapter on social That's something whick FC much nicer, more integrated discussion than is permitted today. It was a local culture. It's partly the internationalisa bon ol economs wich has made chings very difficult.
Keynes has been replaced pretty well completely in the academic world by this borrible American mathematicised economics, and we're trying to find a way of fighting back
----- pull-quotes -----
plurality of political power. Americani and Muslims and Chinese and Japanese
FC. The book is about national ceo. nomits and it's only about one aspeci of national coonomics, namely the
It's very abstract I believe that con ventional cconomics a germing into more and more or a muddle, It's difficult to discuss anything in coonomics now be-
In fact in the world economy there is astrona defiatiorary biss. seainst tor
mics - you construct a series of equs- tions, and then you put in, itom out-