Workers' unity in Ireland
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
page workers work these things out? After all there is good reason to: be ocricted, and reason to tear mat roots out is int cout to a bloodbath and the repartition of Ireland.
How? 1 say, by reason and acceptthe nuntant nabonansts and an the demand "Troops Out Now" with no nonsense or procrastina: ton and notalk ota programme other than for how to withdraw.
This is metaphysics for anoth Fee how sell determination" and Troops Out going to be realised? By sudden Balish nul oat with no political settlement? I'm not entirely sure that Conor Cruise O'Brien's 'malign scenario" is ruled out, but it is far from likely in the foresecable future.
Serious Any serous talk of Britists withdrawal is necessarily talk of Britain negotiating its way out. arranging for a replacement for the state power wish Botan now sustains. it will be a neg otiated pull-out.
This is the Sinn Feis version of "Troops Out", and the only ome that does not raise the spectre of roons Oit meanina an mevitable bloody civil war. ing to Why should the left and the labour move ment confine itself nhrash mongerine role of SaVIng Troops Out and no discussion thereby possibie role in sh ping a polítical settlement?
The Troops Out and no chatline amounts selfSenying ordinance for the left in rying to explain and argue its case. may nor matter h if you confine yourself to a "constituency redisposed wards you b atitudes caragua, Cu having the issues arguments teased out in a way that Third World arallels difficat sustain.
I woeded carefully what 1 wrote abou the "fecbleness"" of the Troops Ou: current. i *Even strength in the last three or four years, the sil counts to gie in our eve ment""
Geoft Bell replies by claiming victories on the suryless courts rip-scarching. the Prevention of Terrorism ict, and Labour's commitment to a united Ireland.
Counterposed
Even if you accept the claim that the Troops Out current. won all those victories. the fact remams that BE mese positon land are counterposed by the and especially a united Irereadersasp to rooos vul It is true that these is a lot of support for Troops Out in the consaluency Labour Pant ica d there is also a lot of passive pport for Troops Out in the iritish population fover 50%l. has very limle ciout outside the compreensively left-wing sec tions of the CLPs. You that it counts foe little in the More is involved than numbers. Out current rent. that cannor ansaer opponents poitically and at the conference did not seriously Scare Also. kidding the solid Troops support can be identified with number of votes that Troops Out C W those who camel constituency answer the arguments of our opponens on the bloodbaths question and on Troops Out not cading under pied e Ireland of a serious civil war scare? Passing resolution reflecting tional left wisdom at the or GC is one thing to it in lace of the harsh real ities that may unfold in Northern Ireland is something elsc, and o is being able to a out and gue and campaign in the trade antons for it example, given the wide ive support foe Troops Out cost penal to trap the Party Tim the ur best ho unable Troops t curecot is a lot bigger than was, and i don't neglect to feeble.
The argument that we have no support thase ruggle in Ireland is not only widespread but argument. I have difficalty taking it seriously because nooanterod and opposcd 1 a ar back as August 1909. when i Binst British sealers call was us as un wamiche in Belfast terru welcomed them SocialiS and Kepubbcans m Northern Ireland dict not call foe their withdrawal xplicitly welcomed them, he biggest revolutionary soc dist group in Beitain dropped previously prosinest call Ted la Sale Pocket act elsewhere avans those ala who refused to give de facto to the deplorment British Iroops: And as one of their most "clinching" arguments they used the fact that ncithos Bitt ocialist co-thinkers in th Six Counties not even the Republicans were calling fur Troops tor will agree, of course hat they were wrong. Bat Jogicalle, Geoff, vou shouida'T agree Por us that we have so option but to go along ern Ireland lett and Republicans. then the same principle been then, evou though it lod to diamettically opposite conclusious! Anand 700 weekers af the Atlas site of Sheffield Forgermasters now. heen t indefinite strike for over seren he catalyst for the dispute was the basic principle of tracke advent of a new MoGregat-type manager the full time union cor vener was locked out, and made renuntant, Agreements such joint works licalth and safety were erminated without negotiation. nd there was a refosal to mise cected shop stewards torever thete have beet pr blems. A few weeks into strike. mass noctings sete (temporarily as it tured out) abandoned and there WAs serious problem of getting infor. mation to strikers, Far. tar woese However the withdrawal of official ISTC upport for the strike after five and at instruction absolutels nothing. Having ane meeting of strikers voted overaney to sty less, and some ISTC niembers considered joining a union more interested in defending their living dandards. Faced such militant opposition. and