Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Defend the jury system!

Socialist Organiser no. 255, 9 January 1986 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 1,958 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

A committee led by Lord Roskill has recommended the abolition of trial by jury for fraud cases. And the government wants to cut defendants' right to challenge potential jurors from three challenges to one.

As the Sunday Times put it, **The right to challenge jurors is enshrined in statutes dating back to 1509, when the limit was set at zu tor each ucienuan. ach dafandant It was reduced from seven to three in 1977."

Trial by jury is a principle of justice or it is nothing. All SortS ot special arguments are made about fraud cases - they are long, they are complicated -and shady business people accused of fiddling the books seem poor candidates for the eft's sympathy.

But no-jury courts once established for fraud would spread their scope to other offences. Many other cases, after all, are long and complicated.

The grain - also wants to neve the right to jury trial for fences and dri legal delays can be reduced. But common assualt, minor offence though it is, can get you sent to prison for a year. And some magistrates' courts are practically automatic conviction machines.

Challenges

The reason given for cutting challenges to jurors is that defence lawyers are getting too clever and too many defendants get off. Jury-vetting in important cases has been introduced for the same reason.

But who says too many? In truth challenges just give defendants a good chance of getting umes a reasonable prowomen, of young people, or whatever, or of getting at least a few black people onto the jury. They sateguard the basic right to trial by a 'jury of your peers Behind it all the basic trouble for the Tories was the abolition of property qualifications for jurors.

In Northern Ireland the Diplock Courts operate completely without juries. Recently one High Court judge sent 27 men to jail for long periods on the uncorroborated evidence of one "supergrass" - Three of them have just finished a hunger strike in protest.

Learn the lessons of Northern Ireland: resist every attack on the right to trial by jury!

In the event Ireland was lucky and nobody invaded though the US as well as Britain and Germany had contingency plans to invade (in preparation for the Allied invasion of Hitler-occupied Europe, in June 1944). Ireland remained neutral, and that neutrality is generally considered to have contributed a great deal to the hardening of partition into the two distinct Irelands we have now, 6s years after Partition.

In his statement denouncing the Anglo-Irish agreement. see the last issue of Socialist Organiser - lan Paisley bitterly denounced the South for its neutrality during Britain's struggle against Nazi Germany. Duggan's revelations of the RAF's contingency plans will only confirm Irish nationalists in their prejudices and expectations from Britain, though the sheer monstrousness of it will startle even the most bigoted Irish nationalist.

And what will lan Paisley -and the other 'Loyalists' - say to the revelation that Mother England's rulers planned to make large parts of Ireland, and perhaps of their North-East of Ireland, uninhabitable, after having subjected her people to the indiscriminate slaughter of poison gas borne on the

Scan page 5

Socialist Organiser no.255 9 January 1986 Page 5 This week we examine the Strategic Defence Initiative (SDI) of Ronnie Raygun in an article that draws heavily on the pamphlet 'Star Wars: the technology and politics of space weapons' Since the US developed and used nuclear bombs 40 years ago, there has been a costly competition between the US and the USSR to catch up or stay ahead. The result is that enough atomic weapons exist to destroy all life several times over (Mutual Assured Destruction -MAD).

At present, there is virtually no protection against these weapons. Instead, 'Early Warning Systems' give notice of the approach of missiles (or of flocks of geese, etc.,) allowing retaliation. The "balance of terror" reigns.

Attempts to develop anti-missile missiles (and anti-antimissile missiles, etc) were halted by a treaty in 1972 amid fears lest one side should feel it had the ability to win a "First Strike" nuclear war.

Now, the SDI threatens to upset the "balance of terror" by holding out the prospect of being able to knock out the other side's retaliation. This could lead to the US believing in a winnable nuclear war, which could have all sorts of consequences.

STAR WARS The term "star wars" encompasses anti-satellite measures (ASAT) and ballistic missile battle management and surveillance satell Chemical laser orbiting ana pontin mid-course mission pop up mirror *x-ray deoloved laser 'a booster kille EMPICBM launch defence (BMD) and involves weapons in space. BMD banned by treaty but ASAT is not. Many ASAT weapons could be used against Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles (ICBMs) so BMD research can be "disguised" as ASAT research.

ICBMs are the main target of SDI research because the USSR has some 70% of its warheads in this category — over 6000).

Treaty

An ICBM consists of a rocket made up of several boosters and a much smaller "bus" containing the re-entry veciels (RV's) with their warheads. There are four stages to its flight:

a) The boost phase gets the bus into space — 200-400 km up in three to five minutes. The exhausted boosters drop away, leaving the bus with its cargo.

b) In the post-boost, or *bussing" phase, the bus carries the warheads up through its momentum, making small changes to its course to keep the warheads on target. After five minutes or so, the RVs are released.

c) The RVs travel through space following the same path as a bullet or a ball (hence ballistic). This mid-course phase lasts 20-25 minutes and the RVs reach 1200 km height before starting the descent on their targets.

d) The RVs are travelling at 25,000 km per hour when they hit the atmosphere at 100 km up. They are designed to resist the mid-cor and po deployed warheads and chaff homing — * warhead vehicle Amid course / intercer terminal intercept triction that causes the empty bus to burn up and they speed towards their different targets. This terminal phase lasts about two minutes.

Submarine-launched ballistic missiles (SLBMs) have a similar path or trajectory but have less distance to travel and do not go as high.

Any Star Wars strategy has to adopt a multi-layered approach, with attempts to eliminate missiles in all phases of flight. The most successful approach would be to concentrate on the boost phase, since there are fewer, larger targets. However, this only lasts a few minutes, making it difficult to get anti-missile missiles up in time. So what could be better than a weapon travelling at the speed of light —laser beams? LASERS Three systems have been proposed, based on different types of light. All require colossal hallance satellte ind surve 36,01 I Kills 3-0 km amounts of energy.

Infra-red [Heat] Lasers.

These would be powered by vigorous chemical reactions and would require bulky supplies of fuel. They would simply melt a hole in their targets. They would be mounted on a "battle station" satellite with an infra-red telescope for tracking the hot exhaust of the ICBM and a mirror for focussing the laser light.

But where should the satellites be placed?

In a low earth orbit (LEO) of 1000 km, the satellites have a limited field of view but are closer to their targets. They spend much of their time out of sight as they orbit the Earth so 10-20 LEO satellites would be needed to cover an ICBM launch site.

At an altitude of 35,600 km, a satellite takes one day to orbit the Earth and so appears stationary in the sky. One satellite in Geostationary Orbit (GEO) can cover a launch site but would need a more powerful laser and a bigger detection system. Simple calculations show they would need telescopes with mirrors of over 100 metres. This compares with the largest mirror so far built which is only 5 metres across.

This problem arises because of the diffraction of light which causes even the narrowest beam to spread out. The longer the wavelength, the larger need to 1200 be the focussing mirrors...and infra-red light has a long wavelength.

In LEU, accurate ana lawless 1. ThA mirrors of 4 metres would be required.

In CEn minene of murar 150 In GEO, mirrors of over metres would be needed and even a tiny blemish would cause the maser to he est ared by its way from these infra-red (chemical lasers. Currently-planned ones are less than a tenth of the power which will be required for Star Wars.

Visible Light and Lasers These radiations have a shorter wavelength and therefore less diffraction problems but require greater power sources. These would have to be based on the ground and would require GEO mirrors to beam their light down to "fighting" mirrors in LEO.

Turbulence

There would be great problems with dust, turbulence and clouds as the beams passed through the atmosphere. They would need between 20% and 60% of the entire US electricity output to operate. Therefore special power stations would have to be built though they would only ever operate for a few minutes. "Pop-up" X-ray Lasers To get round the above problems, Professor Edward Teller (EI), (father of the H-bomb and virulent cold warrior) has suggested rocket-launched x-ray lasers to be sent up when an ICBM attack seems likely — in other words they "pop up".

X-rays have a very short wavelength and so their beams would not spread out so much. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to focus X-rays well. Also, they do not penetrate air and so can only be used in space. This is probably just as well as their extremely high energy means that they must be powered by a "small nuclear explosion. They could only operate once as they are self-destroying but the X-rays could knock out a had tha Vanna missile's electronics, even at a range of several thousand kms.

Despite ET's enthusiasm for his new brain-child, there is yet another huge obstacle. The X-ray lasers have to intercept the ICBMs in the boost phase. This gives the Americans 3 to 5 minutes to locate the ICBMs and to get the rei laos 200-400 to a height of 200-400 km in time to intercept the ICBMs. If the ICBMs are past the boost phase, there is very little damage the X-rays can do since the electronics have done their work already and the missiles are heading for their targets.

The need for speed dictates the use of massive booster rockets thousands of times bigger than the rocket that took the atronauts to the moon! DEFENCES Even assuming that they are practicable, laser systems would be immensely costly. Defences against lasers, though, could be quite cheap. Here are a few of the suggested defences the Russians could deploy against the proposed US laser systems:

1) Increase the number of missiles and warheads (or pretend to by use of decoys and metal "chaff").

2) Attack the battle stations or the mirrors. Even a handful of sand could wreck a mirror!

3). Make pop-ups useless by letting the boost phase take place in the atmosphere or use larger boosters so that boosting takes less time.

4) Increase the thickness of the missile's skin, give it a reflective coating and spin it like a bullet so as to spread out the effect of a laser.

In future articles, I will look at some of the other exotic ideas in the SDI as well as describing the turmoil into which the scientific world has been plunged by the SDI gravy train.

*By Steven French. From SANA (Scientists Against Nuclear Arms, London Production Centre, SW18 4JQ) at E1 plus postage.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 255

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →