Defended to death?
Socialist Organiser1986 1986-01-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Edward Ellis reviews 'Defence of the Realm', now showing at the Odeon Haymarket.
Strong-willed, ambitious and none-too-scrupulous reporter (Gabriel Byrne) helps destroy the career of a former Labour Defence Minister (lan Bannen), implicated in spying for the other side, as a result of sharing a prostitute with a KGB agent.
But there is more to the business than meets the eye. What is the significance of the death of a boy attempting escape from Borstal? What revelations were about to be made in the House before the scandal hit the headlines? Is the death of an alcohol ic left-wing journalist (Denholm Elliot), an old friend of the ruined MP, an accident? How much does the press baron (Fulton McKay) really know?
The search for the answers to these questions forms the tense plot to David Drury's 'Defence of the Realm' '. It is an absorbing political thriller, which takes its central character through a discovery of his own integrity towards discoveries of a more dangerous nature, that point to a sinister government cover-up. "Edge of Darkness' meets 'All the President's Men"
How far would the governdeen do natiohat ass curity? defend Pretty far, the film suggests certainly as far as making a terrible mess of your flat, and probably as far as political assassination.
In fact the film's hypothetical nuclear-age subject matter is a vehicle for an attack on the Official Secrets Act. 'Are you in favour of freedom of information?' the starch-faced bureaucrats ask the reporter in some disbelief. 'Yes" * he answers beligerentlyPolitically, however, Detence of the Realm' is firmly Pontingesque. 'What? All information? Free across the counter?' the bureaucrats go on. 'No, of course not' the newspaperman replies. Well what information?' 'I don't know...
Therein lies the film's message: I don't know"
Gabriel Byrne in 'Defence of the Realm' It is a story of ordinary people who fall victim to a bureaucrat's view of national security. But the film does not question for a second that such a thing as national security exists. It is difficult to define, they story says, and the security services have defined it wrongly.
But the fundamental problem is injustice. The victims of bureaucratically-defined national security are not traitors; their fate is therefore unfair.
Yet the reality is not that an ex-Defence Minister wasn't secretly a Russian spy. As a Defence Minister, he was not only not a 'traitor': he was an active creator of British imperialist policy — in fact, in history, for the last Labour government, of support for the Shah, of support for military dictatorships in Latin America, and so on.
The Official Secrets Act deserves to be attacked, and as far as it goes a liberal critique can do some good in exposing its absurdities. The problem for the writers of Defence of the Realm' is that so long as the basic concepts of capitalism's 'national security' are accepted, the alternatives remain elusive. They don't know...
It's a well-made film that provides for some good performances and its portrayal of Fleet Street is more convincing than is usual. Even with a disappointing conclusion, this is a thriller worth going to see.